8 Best Rookie Seasons on MTV's The Challenge
Some have become Challenge Champions
The Challenge is an interesting show because every season it pairs veteran players with rookies and tells them to battle it out for money. Other shows will just do rookies or veterans so it is impressive when rookies make it far. This is my list of the best rookie seasons of all-time.
8. Jordan Wiseley & Marlon Williams - Rivals II
Original Shows - The Real World: Portland
Place on Rivals II - 3rd
Daily Wins: 1
Elimination Record: 2-0
Jordan and Marlon are the only team on this list and it's because they were Rivals on Rivals II. They won 1 daily challenge and won 2 eliminations. One of my favorite eliminations is Jordan and Marlon vs Leroy and Ty in a Hall Brawl. If you haven't seen it please go and watch.
7. Tori Deal - Dirty 30
Original Show - Are You The One? 4
Place on Dirty 30 - 3rd
Daily Wins: 3
Elimination Record: 1-0
Tori came in with a boyfriend on Dirty 30. He left pretty early and she found her footing in the game. She got close with Jordan Wiseley and they got to the finals together. Tori had 3 daily wins and an elimination win which is impressive. It was her first final and she was against Challenge Champs in Camila Nakagawa and Cara Maria Sorbello so you can't blame her too much for getting 3rd place.
6. Kam Williams - Vendettas
Original Show - Are You The One? 4
Place on Vendettas - Purged in Final
Daily Wins: 1
Elimination Wins: 3
Kam had one of the best rookie seasons ever as she beat 2 mercenaries in eliminations in Tori Deal and Ashley Mitchell. Ashley was a Champ at the time and Tori is now a Champ so this really proves how great she is. She wasn't ready for a final and that shows as she was purged out. I just can't believe she still hasn't won yet.
5. Theo Campbell - War of the Worlds
Original Show - Love Island UK 3
Place on War of the Worlds - 2nd
Daily Wins: 5
Elimination Wins: 1
Theo had 5 daily wins in his rookie season. He was partnered with Cara Maria Sorbello who is one of the best but he made it to the final during the individual portion. Theo was so close to winning his rookie season but ran into another rookie.
4. Wes Bergmann & Casey Cooper - The Duel
Original Shows -
- Wes - The Real World: Austin
- Casey - The Challenge: Fresh Meat
Place on The Duel - 3rd
Daily Wins: 0
Elimination Wins: 5
To go 5-0 in eliminations as a rookie/rookie duo is hard. Wes and Casey did it. I know Wes carried this team but you have to give credit to Casey as well. They made it to the final and got 3rd place.
3. Frank Sweeney - Battle of the Seasons (2012)
Original Show - The Real World: Back to San Diego
Place on Battle of the Seasons (2012) - 1st
Daily Wins: 4
Elimination Wins: 1
I know I just put Wes and Casey together on this list but I'm putting Frank by himself. Frank was the leader of this team and ran the political aspect of the game. To lead the political game as a rookie is impressive even if it's a mostly newby season. He also has 4 daily wins and 1 elimination win.
2. Amber Borzotra - Double Agents
Original Show - Big Brother 16
Place on Double Agents - 1st
Daily Wins: 1
Elimination Wins: 2
Amber won a recent season of The Challenge which is so impressive. There was 15 women on this cast and for her to win against the likes of Tori Deal, Kam Williams, Kaycee Clark, and Lolo Jones is impressive. She had 2 elimination wins and stayed out of the drama. It's also impressive that CT did not carry her in the final. She held her own especially with the running. If you don't rememeber please go back and watch. She was calling out "CT hurry up!"
1. Turbo Camkiran - War of the Worlds
Original Show - Survivor Turkey 8
Place on War of the Worlds - 1st
Daily Wins: 6
Elimination Wins: 0
To have 6 daily wins and not be sent into an elimination as a rookie is impressive. It's also impressive that he dominated the final as a rookie. Turbo had the best rookie season of all-time. In my opinion there is no debate.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Dylan Deckard is a content creator, podcast host, and blogger. He talks about reality TV, Grey's Anatomy and more. Please click the links below...
About the Creator
Dylan Deckard
Chillin with Dylan Podcast on all podcast platforms.
Charleston, South Carolina
@thedylandeckard on Instagram
@dylan.deckard on TikTok
Keep reading
More stories from Dylan Deckard and writers in Geeks and other communities.
Fantasy Cast for The Challenge: Brain vs Brawn vs Beauty
The Challenge has had some amazing themes including Rivals, Exes, and more. They have yet to do a Brawn vs Beauty vs Brain theme like Survivor did. Survivor did this twice on Cagayan and Kaoh Rong and they were both iconic seasons. If The Challenge brings this theme I can expect fireworks.
By Dylan Deckard7 months ago in Geeks
Thank You, John Cena
When December 13, 2025 arrived, I welcomed it. I welcomed it with open arms. The reason was simple: I wanted to see how John Felix Anthony Cena, Jr, someone who I've been a fan of for over 20 years, would end his iconic and legendary career.
By Clyde E. Dawkins28 days ago in Geeks
The 31st Critic Choice Awards
If you have been watching the 31st annual Critics' Choice Awards, you will know that One Battle After Another won Best Feature, after Paul Thomas Anderson pulled off an upset by winning Best Director and Best Adapted Screenplay for the Warner Bros. thriller.
By Shahjehan Khan 7 days ago in Geeks
A Failed Artist, A Disillusioned Poet, An Underpaid Game Show Host
I took my son and niece to Gori, a small town in Georgia where Joseph Stalin was born. They talked me into visiting the Stalin's Museum, the largest in the post-Soviet space. I had resisted going there because I just can't stand the monster and know enough about him, or so I thought.
By Lana V Lynx6 days ago in FYI
Comments
There are no comments for this story
Be the first to respond and start the conversation.