XP Deus II vs Garrett AT Pro: A Complete Metal Detector Comparison Guide

Introduction

Metal detecting is more than just a hobby—it's an adventure. Whether you're combing the beach for coins or exploring relic-rich soil, choosing the right metal detector is key. Two standout models in the industry are the XP Deus II and the Garrett AT Pro. Both are respected for their performance, but they serve slightly different needs. This guide breaks down the core differences, helping you choose the best detector for your style and environment.

Overview of XP Deus II

Key Features

The XP Deus II is a cutting-edge, multi-frequency metal detector using Fast Multi Frequency (FMF) technology, allowing it to search at frequencies from 4 to 45 kHz. It’s completely wireless, from the control unit to the coil and headphones. It also boasts a waterproof rating of up to 20 meters (66 ft), making it suitable for deep diving and submerged environments.

2.2. Ideal Use Cases

The Deus II is best suited for serious detectorists who require versatility. It's ideal for:

Saltwater beach hunting

Diving expeditions

Areas with complex mineralized soils

Users who prefer high customization

3. Overview of Garrett AT Pro

3.1. Key Features

The Garrett AT Pro runs on a single 15 kHz frequency, optimized for detecting coins, relics, and jewelry. It features Pro Audio™ and Iron Audio™, which help users distinguish between trash and treasure. It's waterproof up to 10 feet (3 meters) and comes with manual and automatic ground balance options.

Ideal Use Cases

Perfect for beginner and intermediate detectorists, the AT Pro is great for:

Coin and relic hunting on land

Shallow freshwater detecting

General-purpose metal detecting

4. Side-by-Side Comparison Table

Performance Comparison

Depth and Accuracy

XP Deus II offers slightly deeper detection due to its FMF technology. Its signal processing is more advanced, allowing users to detect smaller targets at greater depths. Garrett AT Pro provides reliable depth for most common targets like coins and relics.

Target Separation and Recovery Speed

Deus II has ultra-fast recovery speed and superior target separation, making it effective in trash-heavy areas. The AT Pro is decent but can miss targets when multiple objects are close together.

Performance in Mineralized Soils

XP Deus II handles high mineralization better thanks to its ground balancing modes and frequency flexibility. AT Pro performs well in moderately mineralized environments but may struggle in extreme conditions.

Ease of Use and Portability

Deus II is extremely lightweight and collapsible, designed for long hours of use. Its menu system has a learning curve but offers greater customization. The AT Pro is heavier and slightly bulkier but has a simpler interface, ideal for users who prefer plug-and-play functionality.

Battery Life and Power Options

The XP Deus II features a rechargeable battery lasting up to 20 hours. The AT Pro uses 4 AA batteries, lasting around 20–30 hours, which can be quickly swapped in the field. Both have comparable runtimes, but Deus II has the convenience of USB charging.

Wireless and Tech Features

XP Deus II excels with its fully wireless setup, including a wireless coil, control pod, and headphones. It also supports firmware updates and advanced settings. Garrett AT Pro is more traditional and lacks wireless tech, which may be a downside for modern users.

Waterproof and Underwater Capabilities

XP Deus II is fully submersible to 20 meters, perfect for serious underwater treasure hunting. The AT Pro, while waterproof, is limited to 10 feet and is more suitable for shallow streams and lakes. For scuba or deep-sea detection, Deus II is the clear winner.

Price and Value for Money

XP Deus II is priced at a premium, reflecting its advanced features and flexibility. It's a long-term investment for serious detectorists. Garrett AT Pro, on the other hand, delivers excellent performance at a mid-range price point, making it a great entry-level to intermediate option.

Pros and Cons Summary

XP Deus II

Pros:

Multi-frequency capability

Fully wireless and waterproof

Lightweight and ergonomic

Exceptional depth and speed

Cons:

Expensive

Steeper learning curve

Garrett AT Pro

Pros:

Affordable and reliable

Easy to use for beginners

Good for coins and relics

Durable and proven design

Cons:

No wireless features

Limited to single frequency

Lower waterproof depth

Final Verdict: Which One Should You Buy?

Choose the XP Deus II if you want high-end performance, versatility across terrains, and deep water capability. It's the best choice for professionals or passionate hobbyists who demand the most from their gear.

Choose the Garrett AT Pro if you’re on a budget, new to the hobby, or mainly detecting on land or in shallow water. It's a proven, dependable detector that balances price with performance.

FAQs

Q1. Is the XP Deus II worth the higher price?

Yes, especially for users needing multi-frequency, wireless convenience, and deep diving capability.

Q2. Can the Garrett AT Pro be used in saltwater?

It can, but performance may drop in saltwater sand or high-mineralized zones. It performs best in freshwater.

Q3. Which detector is better for gold hunting?

XP Deus II, due to its higher frequency options and sensitivity to small targets.

Q4. Can I upgrade the Garrett AT Pro with wireless accessories?

No, it doesn’t support wireless coils or headphones.

Q5. Is the XP Deus II beginner-friendly?

It has a learning curve, but once mastered, it's incredibly powerful. Beginners may prefer starting with the AT Pro.