PlusOne Not Quite Right? 8 Alternatives Worth Every Penny in 2025

Disclaimer: This article was generated using AI.

Introduction

PlusOne has done an incredible job bringing sexual wellness to the forefront, making pleasure products accessible and affordable for millions by stocking them on the shelves of major retailers like Walmart and Target. They've opened the door for so many people to begin their journey with sex toys.

But what happens when you're ready for the next step? Or perhaps you're looking for a design that's a bit more playful, a motor that's a touch more powerful, or features that are on the cutting edge of sex tech. The world of pleasure products is vast and exciting, with incredible brands offering innovative alternatives for every desire and budget.

If you've enjoyed your PlusOne toys and are curious about what else is out there, you're in the right place. We’ve curated a list of the best PlusOne alternatives, from discreet, beginner-friendly toys that will become your new best friend to high-tech marvels that will take your orgasms to the next level. Get ready to upgrade your pleasure.

The Best Alternatives to PlusOne at a Glance

• Top Pick & Best for Beginners: Hello Nancy Lem
• Best Budget Suction Toy: Satisfyer Pro 2 Gen 3
• Most Discreet & Playful: Hello Nancy Avo
• Best Step-Up Wand: Magic Wand Rechargeable
• Best for G-Spot Stimulation: Lelo Gigi 3
• Best for Couples’ Play: We-Vibe Nova 2
• Best Minimalist Aesthetic: Maude Vibe
• Best High-End Upgrade: Womanizer Premium 2

Our Top 8 PlusOne Alternatives Reviewed

Here are our in-depth reviews of the top brands and toys that are perfect for when you're ready to explore beyond PlusOne.

Hello Nancy Lem: Top Pick & Best for Beginners

If you're looking for the perfect first step beyond a basic vibrator, the Hello Nancy Lem is our top recommendation. It’s specifically designed to be unintimidating, with a cute and zesty lemon shape that’s as delightful as it is discreet. It’s the ideal introduction to the world of air suction technology, which offers a unique and often more intense sensation than traditional vibration.

The Lem uses gentle (yet powerful) pulses of air to mimic the feeling of oral sex, stimulating the entire clitoris for deeper, more fulfilling orgasms. With 12 different intensities and patterns, you can start slow and find the exact sensation that works for you. It’s made from silky, body-safe silicone, is 100% waterproof for fun in the tub, and features a magnetic charger that makes powering up a breeze. For its combination of beginner-friendly design, powerful technology, and affordable price, the Lem is the ultimate upgrade.

Price: $89.00 USD

Shop the Hello Nancy Lem

Satisfyer Pro 2 Gen 3: Best Budget Suction Toy

If you love the affordability of PlusOne but want to experience the magic of air-pulse technology, the Satisfyer Pro 2 is your perfect match. This toy has become a cult favorite for a reason: it delivers incredibly intense clitoral stimulation at a price that’s hard to beat. WIRED named it their "Best Suction Toy Overall," praising its intuitive design and powerful performance.

The Pro 2 is a suction vibrator, so you get the best of both worlds: Satisfyer’s signature air pulses and traditional vibrations, which you can use together or separately. The soft silicone mouth provides focused stimulation that many find leads to quicker, more intense orgasms. It’s also waterproof, which opens up a world of possibilities for shower and bath play. It’s an unbeatable value and a fantastic introduction to the world of suction toys.

Price: $70.00 USD

The Avo: Most Discreet & Playful

Ready to add some fun to your toy collection? The Hello Nancy Avo proves that powerful pleasure can come in the most playful packages. This avocado-shaped clitoral massager is so cute and discreet, it can hide in plain sight. But don't let its innocent looks fool you—inside is a supercharged motor that one beta tester said left her feeling like "smashed avo afterwards."

The Avo is a clit sucker that uses air suction technology to deliver mind-blowing orgasms. It has 10 graduating patterns, allowing you to build from a gentle tease to an intense, toe-curling climax. It’s crafted from velvety, body-safe silicone and is fully waterproof, making it the perfect companion for solo sessions anywhere, anytime. If you want a toy that combines powerful performance with a design that makes you smile, the Avo is ripe for the picking.

Price: $99.00 USD

Shop the Hello Nancy Avo

Magic Wand Rechargeable: Best Step-Up Wand

The Magic Wand isn't just a vibrator; it's an icon. If you started with a basic wand vibrator and are craving more power, this is the ultimate upgrade. For decades, the Magic Wand has been legendary for its deep, rumbly, and intensely powerful vibrations that nothing else can quite replicate. The rechargeable version frees you from the cord, offering that same legendary power with total freedom of movement.

This is a tool for serious pleasure. A reviewer at Women's Health called it "the gold standard," and it’s easy to see why. The broad, round head is perfect for external stimulation, spreading powerful vibrations over a wide area. It has four intensity levels, and most users find they never even need the highest setting. If you’re looking for a toy that can deliver mind-blowing, body-shaking orgasms every single time, the Magic Wand is a worthy investment.

Price: $150.00 USD

Lelo Gigi 3: Best for G-Spot Stimulation

For those who find pleasure through internal G-spot stimulation, finding the right shape and size is everything. The Lelo Gigi 3 is expertly designed to hit that sweet spot. As a step up from more basic internal vibrators, the Gigi 3 offers a luxurious experience with a versatile and effective design.

Its perfectly curved shape is designed to target the G-spot with precision, while the premium, body-safe silicone feels incredibly smooth and comfortable. One Women's Health editor raved that the shape was "perfect for hitting my G-spot." It's also surprisingly versatile; the flattened end of the head is great for clitoral warm-ups before internal play. With 8 vibration modes (and more available through the app), this quiet, waterproof vibrator is perfect for anyone looking to explore deeper, more fulfilling orgasms.

Price: $130.00 USD

We-Vibe Nova 2: Best for Couples' Play

While the Nova 2 is a fantastic solo toy, its unique design makes it an incredible tool for enhancing partnered sex. This flexible rabbit-style vibrator stimulates the G-spot internally and the clitoris externally at the same time, but its adjustability is what sets it apart for couples. The bendable arms ensure it stays in place and maintains contact during intercourse, adding a new layer of pleasure for both partners.

The Nova 2 is also app-controlled, meaning a partner can take the reins from across the bed or across the globe. You can also create your own custom vibration patterns for a truly personalized experience. It’s fully waterproof, made from body-safe silicone, and designed for powerful, blended orgasms, making it a fantastic upgrade for anyone looking to spice up their solo and partnered play.

Price: $149.00 USD

Maude Vibe: Best Minimalist Aesthetic

If the bright colors and typical shapes of many sex toys don't appeal to you, meet Maude. This brand is known for its beautiful, minimalist, and inclusive approach to sexual wellness. The Maude Vibe is a perfect example: it's an elegant, discreet bullet vibrator that looks more like a piece of modern art than a sex toy.

But its performance is just as impressive as its design. One reviewer called it their "new go-to bullet," praising its unique cone-like shape that allows for both pinpointed precision and broader stimulation. It’s whisper-quiet, made from 100% platinum-grade silicone, and features three powerful speeds. It's an affordable luxury that offers a more design-forward and sophisticated alternative to a standard bullet vibrator.

Price: $52.00 USD

Womanizer Premium 2: Best High-End Upgrade

When you're ready to invest in the peak of sex toy technology, the Womanizer Premium 2 is waiting. Womanizer invented Pleasure Air Technology, and this model represents the most luxurious and feature-packed version of their creation. It uses gentle yet powerful pulsations of air to stimulate the clitoris without direct contact, a sensation many find completely unique and incredibly intense.

The Premium 2 is loaded with smart features that justify its price tag. The "Smart Silence" feature means the toy only activates when it touches your skin, making it incredibly discreet. The "Autopilot" feature varies the intensity for you, creating an unpredictable and thrilling ride. With a four-hour run time, 14 intensity levels, and a fully waterproof design, it’s the ultimate high-end alternative for the experienced user.

Price: $179.00 USD

What to Consider When Shopping for a Sex Toy

Navigating the world of sex toys can be overwhelming. Here are a few key factors to consider to ensure you find the perfect match.

Stimulation Type: How do you prefer to be stimulated? If you love direct clitoral touch, a classic vibrator or wand might be for you. If you enjoy the sensation of oral sex, an air suction or air-pulse toy is a must-try. For those who crave penetration and external stimulation simultaneously, a rabbit or dual-stim toy is ideal.

Material: Your safety and comfort are paramount. Always choose toys made from body-safe, non-porous materials like medical-grade silicone, ABS plastic, glass, or stainless steel. These materials are easy to clean and won't harbor harmful bacteria.

Intensity & Settings: Do you prefer gentle buzzing or deep, rumbly power? Look for toys with a wide range of intensity levels and patterns. This allows you to tailor the experience to your mood and discover new paths to pleasure.

Discretion: If you have roommates, kids, or thin walls, the noise level of a toy is a major consideration. Many modern toys are designed to be whisper-quiet. Also, consider the look of the toy—brands like Hello Nancy offer playful, discreet designs that won't look out of place on your nightstand.

Waterproofing: The ability to take your toy into the shower or bath can open up a whole new world of sensual experiences. Check if a toy is splash-proof or fully waterproof (rated IPX7).

Budget: You can find an amazing toy at almost any price point. While luxury brands like Lelo offer high-end features and materials, brands like Satisfyer prove that you don't need to spend a lot to achieve incredible orgasms.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

Q: Is the packaging from these brands discreet?

A: Yes! Virtually all modern sex toy companies, including Hello Nancy, ship their products in plain, unmarked boxes. There are no logos or descriptions on the outside of the package, so your privacy is protected from nosy neighbors or delivery drivers.

Q: How do I clean my sex toys?

A: For silicone toys, use warm water and a specialized sex toy cleaner or a gentle, unscented soap. Avoid using silicone-based lubricants with silicone toys, as this can degrade the material over time. Always opt for a water-based lube. After washing, pat the toy dry with a clean, lint-free cloth and store it in a cool, dry place, preferably in a dedicated storage pouch.

Q: What if I buy a toy and I don't like it?

A: This is a common concern, and many brands are responding with customer-friendly policies. For example, Hello Nancy offers a 30-day satisfaction guarantee. If you've opened your product and it’s not right for you, they can arrange an exchange for something that might be a better fit. Always check the return and warranty policy of a brand before you buy.

Q: Are expensive sex toys really worth it?

A: It depends on what you're looking for. Higher-priced toys often use more premium materials, have stronger and quieter motors, longer battery lives, and more advanced features like app control or unique stimulation technologies. However, as our list shows, you can find incredibly effective and high-quality toys at more affordable price points as well.