The Price of Words

Evelyn Marsh was a woman rarely forgotten and never easily forgiven. In the small city of Rosewater, her presence was announced by the sharp click of her heels and the sharper edge of her tongue. She was not a woman to cross ... so said the whispers in the city’s cafes and markets, though those whispers were sometimes planted by Evelyn herself. Her confidence was legendary, her judgment, however, was not. Evelyn’s words could cut through the thickest silence, but often, they left wounds that festered long after she had moved on.

Evelyn worked as a manager at Oak & Vine, a boutique wine shop known for its exclusivity and charm. To her staff, she was both a mentor and a storm. “I demand excellence because I expect nothing less from myself,” she’d proclaim, her icy blue eyes daring anyone to challenge her. Her employees ... young, eager, hopeful ... learned quickly that her approval was as fleeting as summer rain and her criticisms as biting as frost.

Outside of work, Evelyn’s circle was small but carefully curated. There was her neighbor, Linda ... a widow who tended her roses with more devotion than she ever gave gossip; her on-again, off-again friend, Simone, whose optimism both irritated and intrigued Evelyn; and her younger brother, Patrick, who bore her scolding with a patience that bordered on saintly. Evelyn’s relationships were defined by her need to be right, a trait that earned her admiration and avoidance in equal measure.

Inciting Incident

It was an otherwise ordinary Wednesday when the incident that would unravel Evelyn’s sense of control occurred. That morning, a new employee arrived at Oak & Vine: Julia, a recent college graduate with nervous energy and a hopeful smile.

Evelyn eyed Julia skeptically. "You’re early," she remarked as Julia fidgeted by the counter. "I hope you’re not one of those who fade by noon."

Julia’s cheeks flushed. "I just wanted to make a good impression, Ms. Marsh."

"Good impressions are for the first five minutes," Evelyn snapped. "Consistency is what matters. Let’s see how you do after a week."

Despite Julia’s diligent efforts, Evelyn found fault in every detail ... her penmanship on inventory logs, her tendency to ask questions, the nervous way she laughed when uncertain. By noon, Evelyn’s criticisms had grown sharper, echoing within earshot of both customers and staff.

It was during a busy lunch rush that Julia misrung a customer’s order, accidentally charging for the wrong vintage. The customer, a regular named Mrs. Carter, was gracious, but Evelyn seized the moment.

"Are you trying to ruin this business in your first week?" Evelyn hissed, her voice carrying through the store. "If you can’t handle simple tasks, perhaps you’re not cut out for this."

The words hung in the air, harsh and final. Julia’s eyes brimmed with tears as she stammered an apology, her hands trembling. The other employees exchanged glances but remained silent, wary of Evelyn’s temper.

Rising Action

By the end of the day, the atmosphere at Oak & Vine was brittle and tense. Julia left early, citing a migraine, and the remaining staff worked in near silence. Evelyn, feeling justified, congratulated herself on maintaining high standards.

That evening, Simone invited Evelyn for coffee. They met at the Velvet Spoon, a small cafe where the scent of pastries softened the worst of days.

"You were hard on the new girl," Simone began cautiously.

Evelyn sipped her espresso. "She needs to toughen up or she’ll never make it."

Simone leaned forward, her tone gentle but firm. "There’s a difference between high expectations and humiliation, Ev."

Evelyn bristled. "You’re too soft, Simone. In the real world, kindness is a weakness."

Simone shook her head. "Kindness is strength. You’d see that if you let yourself."

The conversation ended in awkward silence, each woman lost in her own convictions.

Over the next week, Evelyn’s interactions with others grew more strained. Julia called in sick twice, her absence uncharacteristic. Patrick canceled a dinner, texting a brief apology ... “Not tonight, Ev. Maybe next week.” Linda, who usually greeted Evelyn warmly in the hallway, seemed to vanish behind her rosebushes whenever Evelyn approached.

In her solitude, Evelyn found her thoughts drifting back to Simone’s words. She dismissed them at first, but they lingered, unsettling her.

Climax

The breaking point arrived at the monthly staff meeting. Tension buzzed through the room as Evelyn started her review.

"I’ve noticed some of you are slacking off," she began, scanning faces. "Mistakes are up. Motivation is down. If you can’t meet expectations, you’re replaceable."

A murmur rippled through the team. Julia, eyes downcast, spoke up. "Ms. Marsh, I’m trying my best, but ... "

"Trying isn’t enough," Evelyn cut in. "Competence is non-negotiable."

A voice from the back ... Miguel, a reliable staffer ... broke the silence. "With respect, Ms. Marsh, it’s hard to do our jobs when we’re constantly afraid of being humiliated. It’s not just Julia. We all feel it."

Evelyn stared at him, blindsided. "If you can’t handle pressure, perhaps you’re in the wrong field."

Miguel didn’t back down. "It’s not the pressure, it’s the disrespect. We’re human. We want to work hard, but not like this."

A few nods and murmurs of agreement filled the room. Julia, emboldened, added softly, "I love this job, but I can’t handle being talked down to every day."

Evelyn’s cheeks flushed, anger and embarrassment warring inside her. She stormed out, the sound of her heels echoing down the hall.

That afternoon, she received an email from the owner of Oak & Vine, requesting a meeting. The tone was neutral but firm: “Let’s discuss some concerns raised by your staff.”

Falling Action

Evelyn arrived at the meeting defensive and tense. The owner, Mr. Carter, spoke calmly.

"Evelyn, you’re talented, but your leadership style is causing turnover. We value excellence, but we also value respect. I need you to reflect on that."

Evelyn opened her mouth to argue but paused, the words dying on her tongue. She remembered the hurt in Julia’s eyes, the frustration in Miguel’s voice, and the distance growing between herself and those she cared about.

She left the meeting unsettled. That evening, she tried calling Patrick ... he didn’t answer. She texted Simone, but the response was brief. Even Linda’s roses seemed to turn away from her as she passed.

For the first time in years, Evelyn felt truly alone.

She spent the next day in quiet reflection, replaying her words and actions. The realization came slowly and painfully: she had mistaken cruelty for strength, and in doing so, had pushed everyone away.

Determined to make amends, Evelyn invited the staff for an after-hours meeting. She prepared coffee and pastries, a gesture that felt foreign but necessary.

When the team arrived, tension was palpable. Evelyn stood before them, hands trembling.

"I owe you all an apology," she began, voice unsteady. "I thought I was helping by being tough. I see now that I’ve hurt you. That was never my intention. I’m sorry."

Silence followed. Then, Julia spoke. "Thank you for saying that, Ms. Marsh. I just want to do a good job."

Miguel nodded. "We all do. We just want to feel respected."

Evelyn nodded, tears stinging her eyes. "You deserve respect. I want to do better. I hope you’ll give me that chance."

The meeting ended quietly, but something shifted. A few staff members lingered, chatting. Julia smiled ... tentatively but genuinely. Miguel offered to help clean up.

Evelyn realized that humility was a strength she’d never cultivated, but it was one she needed most.

Resolution

In the weeks that followed, Evelyn transformed ... slowly, sometimes painfully. She caught herself before lashing out, choosing patience over punishment. She listened more than she spoke, and when she made mistakes, she owned them.

Her relationships improved. Patrick invited her to dinner, where conversation flowed easily. Simone became a regular presence in her life again, their coffee dates filled with laughter instead of tension. Even Linda greeted her with fresh roses, and Evelyn found herself smiling in return.

The team at Oak & Vine flourished. Julia grew more confident; Miguel took on more responsibility. The atmosphere shifted from one of fear to camaraderie.

One evening, as Evelyn closed the shop, Julia approached her.

"Ms. Marsh, I wanted to thank you. For everything. I was going to quit, but now I’m glad I stayed."

Evelyn smiled, gratitude softening her features. "Thank you, Julia. For giving me another chance."

Walking home beneath the golden glow of streetlights, Evelyn realized the lesson she’d learned the hard way: Words have power, but the greatest strength lies in choosing them with care. In seeking to be better instead of simply right, she had discovered not only the value of others, but the value within herself.

She would never be perfect ... her tongue still sharp, her judgments sometimes flawed ... but she was learning. And that, she thought, was enough.

Julia O’Hara 2025

THANK YOU for reading my work. I am a global nomad/permanent traveler, or Coddiwombler, if you will, and I move from place to place about every three months. I am currently in Peru and heading to Chile in a few days and from there, who knows? I enjoy writing articles, stories, songs and poems about life, spirituality and my travels. You can find my songs linked below. Feel free to like and subscribe on any of the platforms. And if you are inspired to, tips are always appreciated, but not necessary. I just like sharing.

YouTube Top Song List.

https://www.YouTube.com/results?search_query=julia+o%27hara+top+songs

Amazon PlayList

https://www.amazon.com//music/player/artists/B0D5JP6QYN/julia-o'hara

Spotify PlayList

https://open.spotify.com/artist/2sVdGmG90X3BJVn457VxWA

You can also purchase my books here:

https://www.lulu.com /spotlight/julie-ohara

I am also a member of Buy Me A Coffee – a funding site where you can “buy me a cup of coffee.”

https:www.buymeacoffee.com/JulieOHara