The Saul Goodman Guide to Persuasion: Craft Unforgettable Arguments

“Rhetoric, in the general sense of the use of language in such a manner as to impress the hearers and influence them for or against a certain course of action, is as old as language itself and the beginnings of social and political life.”

Saul Goodman (a.k.a Jimmy McGill) is one of the most compelling and multifaceted character in television history, brought to life by (two Primetime Emmy Award winner) Bob Odenkirk in Breaking Bad and its spin off Better Call Saul.

The persona of Saul Goodman is a carefully crafted facade — an embodiment of Jimmy’s cynisism and survival instincts. The name itself is a play on the phrase “It’s all good, man,” reflects his desire to reinvent himself as someone untouchable societal judgement.

As Saul he embraces moral flexibility, using his rhetoric(Art of persuasion) and legal knowledge not just to defend his clients but to exploite loopholes and manipulate the system to his advantage and he does that soo gracefully, often extracting himself out of any situation with just his words alone. He can gain a jury’s confidance or nagotiate a drug dealer with equal ease.

So, how does he do it? Let’s break down the Saul Goodman playbook to learn how to craft unforgettable arguments that stick.

Getting Started:

“Persuasion is the lifeblood of any successful endeavor, whether you’re selling a product, a service, or even just yourself. Think of it this way: every interaction is an opportunity to influence someone.”

So, how did Saul do it? Let’s break down a few of his key tactics (and how you can use ethically sound versions of them):

Identifying the Need (and Opening Strong):

Saul rarely launched straight into a pitch. He’d open with something like, “So, tell me, what’s keeping you up at night?” or “What’s the biggest problem you’re facing right now?” He’d ask questions to understand the real issue before offering a solution.

Your Takeaway: Start with genuine inquiry. Don’t just assume you know what someone needs. Ask open-ended questions. “What are your goals for this project?” or “What’s your biggest challenge in this area?” are good starting points.

Building Rapport (Fast — and with Flair):

Saul was a master of the quick connection. He’d use phrases like, “I’ve been there, believe me,” or “I know exactly what you’re going through.” He’d find common ground, even if it was fabricated.

Your Takeaway: Find genuine points of connection. “I noticed you’re a [shared interest] fan too!” or “I read your article on [related topic] — interesting insights!” Sincerity is key. Don’t fake it.

Creating a Sense of Urgency (Carefully — and with Nuance):

Saul might say, “This offer’s only good for 24 hours!” or “This opportunity won’t come around again.” While often manipulative, his urgency was effective.

Your Takeaway: Instead of false scarcity, highlight genuine time constraints. “We have limited availability for this service,” or “The deadline for applications is next Friday.” Be transparent about the reasons for the urgency.

Leveraging Social Proof (Where Appropriate — and Authentically):

Saul would boast, “I’ve handled cases just like this, and the results speak for themselves!”

Your Takeaway: Use testimonials and case studies, but be honest. “We’ve helped other clients in your industry achieve similar results,” or “Here’s a case study that demonstrates our approach.” Quantifiable data is always persuasive.

The Art of the Deal (Negotiation — and with Flexibility):

Saul was a master negotiator, often using phrases like, “Let’s see if we can find a win-win here,” or “I’m sure we can work something out.”

Your Takeaway: Focus on mutual gain. “I’m willing to be flexible on [point] if you can agree to [point].” Be prepared to compromise, but know your bottom line.

Paint Vivid Pictures:

Saul Goodman wasn’t just a lawyer; he was a storyteller. He understood that facts and figures are dry. Stories, on the other hand, stick. Saul didn’t just tell his clients the potential consequences of their actions; he painted vivid scenarios. He’d say something like, “Imagine yourself, sitting in that courtroom, the judge looking down at you, the weight of the world on your shoulders…” or “Picture this: you walk out of here a free man, a clean slate, ready to start over…” He’d craft a narrative that resonated emotionally, making his arguments not just persuasive but unforgettable.

So, how can you use this storytelling power for good? Let’s break it down:

Know Your Audience’s Aspirations and Fears:

Saul understood what his clients wanted (freedom, money, a sense of justice) and what they feared (prison, financial ruin, public shame).

Before crafting your story, understand your audience. What are their goals? What are their anxieties? Tailor your narrative to resonate with their specific needs and concerns.

Use Sensory Details:

Saul’s stories weren’t just abstract ideas; they were filled with sensory details. He’d describe the courtroom, the judge’s expression, the weight of the handcuffs.

Your Takeaway: Bring your stories to life with vivid language. Instead of saying “This could be difficult,” say “Imagine the frustration of dealing with endless paperwork, the anxiety of unexpected delays, the sheer exhaustion of fighting this battle alone.”

Create Emotional Resonance:

Saul’s stories weren’t just descriptive; they were emotionally charged. He’d tap into his clients’ hopes, fears, and desires.

Don’t just present facts; connect with your audience on an emotional level. Share anecdotes, use metaphors, and paint a picture of the positive outcomes they can achieve or the negative consequences they can avoid.

Keep it Concise and Relevant:

Saul knew how to tell a compelling story without rambling.

Keep your stories brief and to the point. Don’t get bogged down in unnecessary details. Ensure your narrative directly supports your argument and reinforces your key message.

Ethical Storytelling:

Saul sometimes embellished or even fabricated details to make his stories more persuasive.

Never lie or mislead in your storytelling. While you can use creative language and emotional appeals, your stories must be grounded in truth. Exaggeration can undermine your credibility.

You might also like:

The Power of the Apparent Choice:

Saul is notorious for presenting options that appear to offer freedom of choice but are actually crafted to lead his audience to a preferred outcome. This is known as the false choice technique.

When it came to giving people the impression of choice. He’d present options that looked like genuine alternatives but were carefully crafted to steer his target toward his desired outcome. “So, you can either plead guilty and face five years, or we can fight this thing tooth and nail, and maybe, just maybe, get you off with probation. What do you say?” The choice seemed obvious, even if it wasn’t. This is what’s known as the false choice — a technique Saul used to manipulate and persuade.

Now, how can you use this technique… ethically? Let’s be clear: Saul’s version of the false choice was often deceptive. We’re not going there. Instead, we’ll focus on how to present options in a way that guides your audience while still respecting their autonomy.

Understanding the Ethical Line:

The key difference between Saul’s approach and an ethical adaptation lies in transparency and honesty. Saul often hid the true consequences of each option.

Be upfront about the pros and cons of each choice. Don’t manipulate or hide information.

Focusing on Benefits:

Saul would often emphasize the benefits of his preferred option while downplaying the risks.

Highlight the genuine benefits of your preferred choice, but don’t ignore the potential drawbacks. Present a balanced perspective.

Giving Real Agency:

Saul’s false choices were about control.

Empower your audience to make their own decisions. Even if you have a preferred outcome, respect their right to choose. Ask questions like, “Which of these options resonates most with you?” or “What are your thoughts on these two approaches?”

By presenting options strategically, honestly, and transparently, you can guide your audience toward a preferred outcome without resorting to manipulation or deception. It’s about influence, not control.

Know When to Walk Away:

Saul Goodman knew that persuasion wasn’t just about talking; it was about knowing when to stop talking. He understood that sometimes, the most powerful argument is the one you don’t make. He’d lay out his case, then… crickets. He’d let the silence hang in the air, allowing his words to sink in. He knew that overplaying his hand could be his undoing. Sometimes, the most persuasive thing you can do is to let your argument linger and give your audience space to come to their own conclusion.

So, how can you wield the power of silence? Let’s explore:

The Confidence of Silence: Saul’s silence wasn’t awkward; it was confident. It projected an air of certainty, suggesting that his argument was so strong it didn’t need further explanation. Your Takeaway: After presenting your case, don’t rush to fill the silence. Let your words resonate. A brief pause can convey confidence and give your audience time to process your message.

Respecting Audience Intelligence:

Saul knew that people don’t like to feel pressured or manipulated. By giving them space to reflect, he showed respect for their intelligence and autonomy.

Trust your audience to draw their own conclusions. Don’t bombard them with follow-up arguments or justifications. Give them the opportunity to internalize your message and come to their own decision.

The Power of Suggestion:

Silence can be more persuasive than words. It allows the audience’s imagination to fill in the gaps, often reinforcing your argument in their own minds.

Let your message linger. Plant the seed of an idea and let it grow. Sometimes, what’s left unsaid is more powerful than what’s explicitly stated.

Avoiding Over-Selling:

Saul knew that over-selling could be a turn-off. He’d present his case and then back off, letting the client come to him.

Resist the urge to keep talking. Once you’ve made your point, give your audience time to consider it. Over-explaining can weaken your argument.

Ethical Silence:

Saul sometimes used silence to create a sense of pressure or to manipulate the conversation.

Use silence strategically, but ethically. Don’t use it to intimidate or pressure your audience. The goal is to give them space to reflect, not to make them feel uncomfortable.

By mastering the art of strategic silence, you can make your arguments more persuasive and impactful, while also demonstrating respect for your audience’s intelligence and autonomy.

Closing Argument: Use Your Powers for Good:

Saul Goodman’s persuasion tactics are undeniably effective, but they can easily be misused. The key takeaway? Use these powers for good, not manipulation. Craft your arguments ethically, with integrity, and always with the best intentions for your audience.

The next time you need to persuade someone — whether it’s in a business meeting, a negotiation, or even just a casual conversation — channel your inner Saul Goodman. Charm them first, know their motivations, tell a compelling story, and deliver your message with unwavering confidence. Who knows? You might just become the most persuasive person in the room.

Saul Goodman’s journey, from Jimmy McGill to the slick-talking lawyer, is a compelling exploration of ambition, survival, and the choices we make. His persuasive tactics, though often ethically ambiguous, offer valuable insights into human behavior and the art of influence.

Writing this article, inspired by Saul’s character, has made me reflect on the importance of ethical communication and the responsibility that comes with the power of persuasion. As you apply these principles in your own life, remember that true influence comes from integrity and genuine connection.

You might also like:

If you like my work clap and share a response, Also consider buying me a coffee: