Critique logo

The Substance Review: A satire on the terror of growing old

The Substance is destined to be the most controversial film of the year and one that will be talked about for a long time

By Ninfa GaleanoPublished about a year ago 3 min read

The horror film The Substance, directed by Coralie Fargeat, has attracted attention for its bold fusion of body horror and feminist themes. Featuring Demi Moore in the role of Elisabeth Sparkle, a former aerobics instructor grappling with ageism in Hollywood, the film delves into issues of identity, beauty, and societal pressures through a grotesque storyline.

##Plot Overview

On her 50th birthday, Elisabeth loses her job, prompting her to pursue a clandestine black-market drug that claims to rejuvenate her appearance. This drug necessitates a weekly exchange with her enhanced counterpart, portrayed by Margaret Qualley. The narrative evolves from a science fiction concept into an intense horror experience, culminating in a chaotic and bloody finale that challenges the audience's understanding of monstrosity and self-identity.

##Cinematic Style

Fargeat's direction showcases a distinctive visual approach influenced by figures such as David Lynch and traditional body horror. The cinematography creates a suffocating atmosphere that reflects Elisabeth's internal conflicts and societal expectations. The movie serves as a critique of the cosmetic enhancement industry and the unrealistic ideals imposed on women.

The absurdity of the narrative is counterbalanced by insightful reflections on beauty and self-worth. It critiques not only the entertainment sector but also the wider societal norms that assess women's value based on their looks. This duality is illustrated through the contrasting journeys of Elisabeth and her younger self, Sue, emphasizing the futility of pursuing an idealized version of femininity.

##The Absurdity of Perfection

The Substance employs absurdism to critique the unrealistic standards of perfection imposed on women. Elisabeth's journey into body horror serves as a metaphor for the extreme lengths to which individuals will go to attain an idealized version of themselves. The narrative's escalation into grotesque violence underscores the futility and danger of chasing unattainable beauty standards.

##Performances

Demi Moore delivers an exceptional portrayal, capturing Elisabeth's vulnerability and desperation with striking authenticity. Her character's arc is both poignant and engaging, highlighting the emotional impact of societal pressures on women as they grow older. It can be said that this is Demi Moore's best performance in her artistic life.

Margaret Qualley's performance as Sue adds layers to the story, embodying a seemingly "perfect" version of femininity that ultimately reveals a lack of depth and self-awareness.

##Main themes

The Substance explores a range of significant themes that extend beyond mere body horror, weaving a complex narrative rich in social critique and psychological depth.

A prominent theme within the film is ageism, particularly its impact on women in the Hollywood landscape. The main character, Elisabeth Sparkle, played by Demi Moore, encounters rejection and marginalization as she ages, mirroring the harsh realities faced by many women in the entertainment sector. The film critiques societal norms that equate a woman's value with her youth and physical appearance, demonstrating how these pressures can drive individuals to extreme actions, such as Elisabeth's reliance on a black-market drug for cosmetic enhancement.

Another essential theme is the exploration of identity. The storyline presents a contrast between Elisabeth and her younger counterpart, Sue, portrayed by Margaret Qualley. This relationship prompts inquiries into self-perception and the lengths individuals may go to conform to societal beauty standards. As their identities interchange, the film delves into the struggle for dominance between the two, emphasizing the internal conflicts many experience regarding their self-worth and societal expectations.

Additionally, The Substance tackles the notion of the male gaze and its effects on women's self-image. Fargeat challenges conventional representations of women by depicting their bodies in a manner that is often more clinical than sexualized. This perspective compels viewers to confront the objectification that women endure and critiques the societal norms that dictate their appearance and behavior.

Conclusion

The Substance emerges as a thought-provoking examination of body horror interwoven with feminist themes. Its combination of unsettling visuals, incisive social commentary, and powerful performances creates a memorable cinematic experience that compels viewers to reevaluate their own notions of beauty and identity in a world that increasingly prioritizes superficiality.

Movie

About the Creator

Ninfa Galeano

Journalist. Content Creator. Media Lover. Geek. LGBTQ+.

Visit eeriecast ,where you'll find anonymous horror stories from all over the world. Causing insomnia since 2023.

Reader insights

Nice work

Very well written. Keep up the good work!

Top insights

  1. Eye opening

    Niche topic & fresh perspectives

  2. On-point and relevant

    Writing reflected the title & theme

Add your insights

Comments

There are no comments for this story

Be the first to respond and start the conversation.

Sign in to comment

    Find us on social media

    Miscellaneous links

    • Explore
    • Contact
    • Privacy Policy
    • Terms of Use
    • Support

    © 2026 Creatd, Inc. All Rights Reserved.