Murder of Debbie Lynn Randall: How DNA and Determination Cracked Marietta’s Oldest Cold Case After 51 Years

January 13, 1972. Marietta, Georgia. Cold enough to make your teeth ache. Nine-year-old Debbie Lynn Randall left her apartment to run a quick errand to the laundromat. She’d done it before. This time, she never made it home. That’s how it starts — just an ordinary night, until it isn’t. Debbie’s mother, Juanita, waited for her little girl, probably watching the clock, maybe thinking about what was for dinner. Minutes turned to hours. By nightfall, the world had shifted for the Randall family and Marietta.

A City on Edge: The Search for Debbie

When a kid goes missing, everything else stops. In 1972, there were no Amber Alerts, no cell phones, and no social media. But word got out fast. Cops, ham radio guys, Civil Defense, and a new group called the Concerned Citizens Committee all jumped in. They called it “Operation Debbie.” Four thousand people — neighbors, strangers, students — searched every patch of woods, every empty lot, every abandoned building. This wasn’t just a box-checking search. People were scared, but they were determined. They wanted to believe Debbie was out there, cold and afraid, but alive.

Sixteen days later, hope ran out. A group of college students found Debbie’s body in the woods near Windy Hill and Powers Ferry Road. The search was over. The nightmare was just getting started.

The Crime Scene: Clues in the Dark

The scene was ugly. Debbie had been raped and strangled. Her body left in the woods, a piece of cloth with a flowery print, a single hair, and a bottle of laundry detergent spilled near her home. Witnesses recalled a dark pickup truck speeding away from the laundromat. These scraps became the bones of the case.

Back then, forensics was a different game. No DNA, no genetic genealogy, not even the kind of trace analysis we take for granted now. Cops canvassed, interviewed, and followed every tip. But the evidence didn’t point to anyone. The killer was still out there, and a family was left shattered.

The Investigation: Years of Dead Ends

When you work a cold case, the drill is always the same. The file gets thicker, the leads get thinner, and the questions never stop. Good detectives know this is the time to dig. Detectives chased thousands of leads, interviewed suspects, checked alibis, and even talked to psychics. They got false confessions — some from attention seekers, some from the mentally ill. None of it led to Debbie’s killer.

The case haunted the Marietta Police, the Cobb County Sheriff’s Office, GBI, and the whole community. For decades, the file sat in a drawer, pulled out when a new tip came in or a new detective got curious. But the trail was cold, and the years weren’t kind.

Unsolved cases eat at families; they certainly eat at cops. The not knowing is its own kind of torture. Every birthday, every holiday, every news story about a missing kid — another wound. For the Randalls, there was no closure, just survival.

The Breakthrough: DNA, Genealogy, and Relentless Work

This case could have stayed cold forever if not for two things: evidence that was saved and technology that kept moving forward. In 2015, Cobb County’s Cold Case Unit took another look. They sent the piece of cloth found with Debbie’s body for advanced DNA testing. They got a partial profile — enough to keep going.

By 2023, genetic genealogy had changed the game. Investigators uploaded the DNA to ancestry databases, identified distant relatives, constructed family trees, and narrowed down the list. It’s slow, detailed work — part science, part old-fashioned detective work.

The work paid off. The name William Rose resulted from the genetic genealogy work. They had a suspect at last. With the help of the suspect’s family, they exhumed the body of William B. Rose, a man who’d died by suicide in 1974, just two years after Debbie’s murder. DNA from his remains matched the crime scene. After 51 years, the case was closed.

As retired detective Morris Nix put it:

“Technology doesn’t get old, it doesn’t retire, it doesn’t quit. Technology was looking for William Rose, and it found him in the grave.”

The Suspect: William Rose, Hiding in Plain Sight

William B. Rose was 24 in 1972. He lived in Mableton, but had family in the same apartment complex as the Randalls. A few minor run-ins with the law — mostly booze — but nothing that would’ve put him on the radar for a crime like this. He was never a suspect.

Cops think it was a crime of opportunity. Rose may have seen Debbie alone and acted on impulse. No evidence he knew her or planned it. Sometimes evil just waits for a moment.

Rose’s suicide in 1974 raised questions. His family later said he was paranoid, afraid of going to jail. But nobody connected him to Debbie’s murder. The answer was right there, just out of reach.

The Family’s Burden: Grief That Doesn’t Quit

Behind every case file is a family. Debbie’s mother, Juanita, fought leukemia for years before passing in 2018. Her father, John, died in 2022. Neither lived to see their daughter’s killer named. Only her brother, Melvin, was left to carry the weight.

At the press conference, Melvin spoke with the kind of quiet strength you only get from decades of pain. He said,

“I wish my mother were here, but I know she knows in heaven now that it’s finally over… I blamed myself for a while, but I realized there was nothing I could have done. I’m just grateful for the community.”

Grief doesn’t end with an arrest. It lingers, changes shape, and becomes part of the family’s story. The best we can do is honor that pain by never giving up.

Bittersweet Closure: What Justice Looks Like After 51 Years

When the news broke in September 2023, there was relief, but no celebration. The answer came too late for Debbie’s parents, too late for a courtroom. But it mattered. It mattered to Melvin Randall, who could finally stop wondering who killed his sister. It mattered to the investigators who never gave up. And it mattered to a community that never forgot and still remembers.

District Attorney Flynn D. Broady, Jr. said it straight:

“The answer we are providing today cannot bring her back. We cannot extract justice from the perpetrator, but I know he must answer to a higher power, and I hope it will provide some relief and answer the question that has lingered for more than 50 years.”

Closure doesn’t mean the pain goes away. It means the story has an ending, even if it’s not the one anyone wanted.

Lessons from the Case: Evidence, Technology, and Tenacity

There are a few things worth remembering from this case.

First, evidence matters. The cloth and the hair found on Debbie’s body were saved for over 50 years. Without them, this case would still be unsolved.

Second, technology changes the game. Genetic genealogy isn’t magic, but it opens doors that used to be locked tight.

Third, never give up. The Cobb County Cold Case Unit, detectives like Morris Nix and Ron Alter, and outside experts like Sheryl McCollum kept the case alive when others moved on. That kind of grit makes the difference.

And finally, the human cost is real. Behind every headline is a family, a community, a ripple of pain and loss. We owe it to them to keep pushing, to keep asking questions, to keep caring.

Conclusion: The Work Never Ends

Debbie Lynn Randall was nine when her life was stolen. For over 50 years, her family waited for an answer. Now, thanks to science, persistence, and a little luck, Marietta finally knows the truth.

But the story doesn’t end with a name. It ends with a reminder: justice isn’t always quick, closure isn’t always complete, and the work of investigators — past, present, and future — matters. It matters to the families, to the communities, and to the memory of every victim whose story deserves to be told.

There are still plenty of Debbies out there — cases waiting for answers, families waiting for peace. This case proves that sometimes, even after decades, the truth can find its way home.

And that’s why law enforcement does the work. Remember. Every Crime Has A Story. My Mission. Yell It.

If you enjoy my writing, would you consider a $1.00 tip using the Vocal Media tipping link? Thank you!

Do you want to read more about this case? Visit my Substack, where you can find additional resources to explore this case in more depth.