She Forgave Me, But I Couldn’t Forgive Myself"

me.

Zainab was the light in my life. She was soft-spoken, kind-hearted, and loved with a depth that I never truly appreciated—at least not when it mattered most. We met in college, in those days filled with laughter, long walks, and hopeful dreams about the future. We talked about growing old together, building a life, and chasing goals side by side. But all it took was one mistake, one selfish decision, to tear it all apart.

I still remember the day I got my first real job. Everything changed. The new environment, the praise, the attention—it inflated my ego. Among my coworkers was Asma, confident, charming, and always around. I started enjoying the attention she gave me. It made me feel important in a way I hadn’t felt in a while.

Zainab trusted me. That was her strength, and maybe her biggest vulnerability. She noticed the changes—how I started coming home late, how my phone was always on silent, how I avoided eye contact when she asked simple questions. But she never confronted me. She just kept smiling, kept believing in me.

One afternoon, she surprised me at work. She brought lunch—my favorite—and was standing at the door of the meeting room with a warm smile. But I was sitting with Asma, laughing, our heads a little too close, our body language saying more than words ever could.

Zainab saw everything. She didn’t say a word. She just turned around and left. That was the moment everything started crumbling.

That evening, she was calm. Too calm. She served dinner, talked about her day, and kissed my forehead before going to sleep. But I couldn’t eat. Her silence was screaming now, and it echoed in every corner of the house.

Days passed. She didn’t accuse me. Didn’t cry. She just kept living like nothing happened. But I knew I had broken something inside her.

A week later, she handed me a letter.

> "I saw everything. But I’ve seen you too—truly, deeply. I know this isn’t who you are. I’ve loved you through your best and your worst. And yes, I forgive you—not because you deserve it, but because I deserve peace. I deserve to let go of the pain. You may not love me the way I loved you, and that’s okay. But don’t carry this guilt forever. Let it teach you, not destroy you."



She left the next morning. No drama. No tears. Just quiet footsteps and a closed door.

I never saw her again.

People say time heals. But some wounds don’t want to heal. They stay open to remind you of what you lost, what you ruined.

I’ve tried to move on. I’ve had other relationships. I’ve even tried reaching out to Zainab once or twice, but I never had the courage to press ‘send’ after typing the message. What would I even say? “I’m sorry” seems too small.

I see her sometimes in my dreams—still smiling, still gentle. And every time, I want to ask her, “Why did you forgive me?” But I know the answer. Because she was Zainab. Because she had a heart made of something purer than mine could understand.

She forgave me.

But I can’t forgive myself.

And maybe that’s the price I have to pay.

Not for cheating.

But for not seeing her worth when she was standing right in front of me—loving me when I didn’t even love myself.

---

Sometimes I sit alone at night, wondering where she is. Is she happy? Did she find someone who truly sees her? I hope she did. I pray she did. Because someone like her—who forgives with grace and walks away with dignity—deserves nothing less than a lifetime of true love and peace.