Top 10 Best Penalty Takers in Premier League History

Penalties are one of the most reliable ways to score goals in football. In the English Premier League, some players have stood out for their ability to convert spot kicks consistently. From rising stars to legendary forwards, these players have shown composure, accuracy, and confidence when taking penalties under pressure.

The best penalty takers in Premier League history are not only those who scored the most goals but also those who performed when it mattered most. In this article, we rank the top 10 penalty specialists based on stats, conversion rates, and performances in crucial games.

List of 10 Best Penalty Takers in Premier League History

10. Bukayo Saka (Forward | England)

Bukayo Saka, Arsenal's talented young forward, has developed into a dependable penalty taker. Despite missing a crucial penalty in the Euro 2020 final, Saka quickly learned from the experience. His calm approach and accurate finishing make him one of the most consistent best penalty takers in Premier League history. He has successfully scored 11 out of 12 penalties for Arsenal, with a conversion rate of 91.8%.

9. James Beattie (Striker | England)

James Beattie, who played for Southampton, Everton, Sheffield United, and Stoke City, was known for his deadly accuracy from the spot. Beattie scored 16 out of 17 penalties in his Premier League career, missing only once in 2006. His consistency and calmness under pressure earn him a spot among the best penalty takers in Premier League history.

8. Callum Wilson (Striker | England)

Callum Wilson has been a reliable penalty taker during his time at Bournemouth and Newcastle United. Known for his composure in high-pressure situations, Wilson has scored 16 out of 17 penalties in the Premier League. Even though he missed once against Cardiff City, his consistency ranks him among the best penalty takers in Premier League history.

7. Erling Haaland (Forward | Norway)

Erling Haaland, Manchester City's prolific striker, has quickly become one of the most lethal best penalty takers in Premier League history. He has scored 15 out of 17 penalties in his Premier League career. Known for his calm demeanor and clinical finishing, Haaland remains deadly in high-pressure moments, making him a modern penalty specialist.

6. Danny Murphy (Midfielder | England)

Danny Murphy, a midfielder for Liverpool, Charlton, Tottenham, and Fulham, was famous for his penalty-taking precision in the 2000s. Over his Premier League career, Murphy missed only one penalty out of 19, showcasing remarkable reliability. His consistent performance in important matches makes him one of the best penalty takers in Premier League history.

5. Harry Kane (Forward | England)

Harry Kane, Tottenham Hotspur's forward, has scored 33 out of 37 penalties in the Premier League. Known for his calm approach and precise placement, Kane has been instrumental in winning key matches for Tottenham. While his conversion rate of 88% is slightly lower than some others, his impact under pressure makes him one of the best penalty takers in Premier League history.

4. Cole Palmer (Attacking Midfielder | England)

Cole Palmer, now playing for Chelsea, was known for his perfect penalty record early in his career. He scored 12 out of 12 penalties, demonstrating composure and confidence under pressure. Palmer's precision and calmness at the spot make him one of the best penalty takers in Premier League history, even though his streak ended against Leicester City.

3. Matt Le Tissier (Forward | England)

Matt Le Tissier, a Southampton legend, converted 24 out of 25 penalties in the Premier League. Nicknamed "Le God," Le Tissier's composure and technique set him apart from other penalty takers. His only miss came against Nottingham Forest in 1993. He remains one of the most technically gifted and consistent best penalty takers in Premier League history.

2. Yaya Touré (Midfielder | Ivory Coast)

Yaya Touré, during his time at Manchester City, scored all 11 penalties he took. The Ivorian midfielder's composed style and flawless technique made goalkeepers helpless. His 100% penalty record secures him a spot as one of the best penalty takers in Premier League history.

1. Alan Shearer (Forward | England)

Alan Shearer is widely regarded as the best penalty taker in Premier League history. The Newcastle United and Blackburn Rovers legend scored 56 penalties, the most in Premier League history. Although he missed more than 10 penalties, his ability to score in crucial matches and maintain composure under pressure is unmatched in English football.