Cleats logo

Exploring the Rivalries in Major League Soccer

A Fan’s Perspective

By Mutonga KamauPublished about a year ago 5 min read

Exploring the Rivalries in Major League Soccer: A Fan’s Perspective

Rivalries are the heartbeat of any sports league, igniting passion, excitement, and an unyielding sense of loyalty among fans. In Major League Soccer (MLS), rivalries have evolved over the years, becoming more intense and celebrated as the league has grown. From geographical battles to historical grudge matches, these rivalries provide a unique flavour to MLS, uniting and dividing communities in equal measure. This article delves into the essence of these rivalries, exploring their origins, significance, and impact from a fan’s perspective.

The Roots of MLS Rivalries

Rivalries in MLS often stem from geographical proximity, cultural differences, or competitive clashes. Unlike older leagues with decades of history, MLS rivalries have had to develop rapidly, fuelled by the league’s expansion and the growing enthusiasm of its fan base. For many supporters, these rivalries are not just about the game but also about identity, pride, and a sense of belonging.

One of the most iconic rivalries is the Cascadia Cup, contested between Portland Timbers, Seattle Sounders, and Vancouver Whitecaps. Rooted in a history that predates MLS, this rivalry showcases the deep connection between fans and their teams. For the supporters, it’s more than just a competition; it’s a celebration of their cities’ distinct cultures and footballing traditions.

The Power of Proximity

Geographical rivalries are a cornerstone of MLS, with derby matches often delivering electrifying atmospheres. The "El Tráfico" clash between LA Galaxy and LAFC is a prime example. Born from the proximity of the two Los Angeles-based teams, this rivalry has quickly become one of the league’s fiercest. The matches are characterised by packed stadiums, passionate supporters, and unforgettable moments that resonate beyond the 90 minutes on the pitch.

Similarly, the Texas Derby between FC Dallas and Houston Dynamo pits two cities with contrasting cultures against each other. The matches are fuelled by a rivalry that transcends football, reflecting the broader competition between Dallas and Houston as major Texan hubs.

Cultural Clashes and Historical Grudges

Beyond proximity, MLS rivalries often reflect cultural and historical differences. The Hudson River Derby between New York City FC and New York Red Bulls is a prime example, representing the classic divide between the urban sophistication of New York City and the suburban grit of New Jersey. Fans take pride in their unique identities, and this is evident in the fervour and creativity they bring to derby days.

The rivalry between Atlanta United and Orlando City SC, while relatively new, has quickly gained traction. Rooted in the competitive spirit of two ambitious clubs, this clash is emblematic of the growing intensity in MLS. The fans’ chants, banners, and unwavering support underscore the emotional investment in these matches, making them memorable for players and spectators alike.

Fan Experiences: The Soul of Rivalries

From a fan’s perspective, rivalries are about more than just the matchday experience; they’re about storytelling, tradition, and camaraderie. Supporters pour their hearts into creating an atmosphere that reflects their dedication to their clubs. Tifo displays, choreographed chants, and vibrant colours transform stadiums into cauldrons of emotion.

The shared rituals among fans are equally significant. Pre-match gatherings, marches to the stadium, and post-match celebrations or commiserations create a sense of community. These moments, steeped in passion and unity, forge lifelong memories for fans. For many, attending a derby match is a rite of passage, an experience that cements their connection to their club and fellow supporters.

The Role of the Players

While fans are the lifeblood of rivalries, players play a pivotal role in shaping their narratives. Iconic performances, dramatic goals, and controversial incidents often become the defining moments of these clashes. Players who embrace the spirit of the rivalry; by displaying passion, commitment, and respect for the occasion, earn the admiration of fans and become legends in the process.

For instance, Zlatan Ibrahimović’s performances in "El Tráfico" elevated the rivalry to new heights. His charismatic presence and knack for delivering in crucial moments made him a central figure in the clashes between LA Galaxy and LAFC. Similarly, Diego Valeri’s contributions to Portland Timbers in the Cascadia Cup have endeared him to fans, solidifying his legacy as a club legend.

Rivalries Beyond the Pitch

The impact of MLS rivalries extends far beyond the 90 minutes of play. These matches often serve as a focal point for broader discussions about city pride, cultural identity, and community engagement. Clubs leverage rivalries to engage with their communities, hosting events and initiatives that bring fans together.

Moreover, the commercial aspects of rivalries cannot be ignored. Rivalry matches draw larger crowds, higher television ratings, and increased merchandise sales. They provide an opportunity for clubs to showcase their brand and connect with a wider audience, further cementing the significance of these clashes in the league’s growth.

Challenges and Opportunities

While MLS rivalries have grown organically, the league faces challenges in maintaining their authenticity. The rapid expansion of MLS has introduced new teams and rivalries, but creating the deep-rooted passion seen in older leagues takes time. Ensuring that these rivalries remain genuine and not manufactured is crucial for their long-term sustainability.

At the same time, the league’s growth presents opportunities to foster new rivalries and expand the reach of existing ones. The addition of clubs like St. Louis City SC and Charlotte FC has already sparked excitement, with fans eagerly anticipating the emergence of new clashes. By nurturing these rivalries through fan engagement and community initiatives, MLS can continue to build its reputation as a league defined by passion and connection.

The Future of MLS Rivalries

As MLS continues to grow, the future of its rivalries looks promising. The league’s commitment to fostering a fan-first culture ensures that these matches will remain a cornerstone of its identity. By embracing the unique characteristics of each rivalry and allowing them to evolve organically, MLS can create a rich tapestry of stories that captivate fans for generations to come.

Moreover, the international appeal of MLS is likely to bring new dimensions to its rivalries. As the league attracts more global talent and expands its audience, the significance of these matches will only increase. Fans from around the world will have the opportunity to experience the passion and intensity that define MLS rivalries, further elevating the league’s global profile.

Conclusion

Rivalries are the lifeblood of Major League Soccer, embodying the passion, pride, and unity that make football a universal language. From the fiery clashes of "El Tráfico" to the cultural battles of the Hudson River Derby, these matches transcend sport, becoming emblematic of the communities they represent. For fans, rivalries are not just about the results; they’re about the stories, emotions, and memories that define their love for the game.

As MLS continues to evolve, its rivalries will remain a driving force behind its growth and appeal. By staying true to the essence of these clashes and embracing their potential to unite and inspire, MLS can ensure that its rivalries remain a cherished part of the league’s legacy.

celebritiesfifafootballmlsnwslpremier leaguerecordsworld cup

About the Creator

Mutonga Kamau

Mutonga Kamau, founder of Mutonga Kamau & Associates, writes on relationships, sports, health, and society. Passionate about insights and engagement, he blends expertise with thoughtful storytelling to inspire meaningful conversations.

Reader insights

Be the first to share your insights about this piece.

How does it work?

Add your insights

Comments

There are no comments for this story

Be the first to respond and start the conversation.

Sign in to comment

    Find us on social media

    Miscellaneous links

    • Explore
    • Contact
    • Privacy Policy
    • Terms of Use
    • Support

    © 2026 Creatd, Inc. All Rights Reserved.