Scarlett O’Hara: The Most Complicated Character I’ve Ever Met

There are characters you love, characters you hate, and then there’s Scarlett O’Hara—someone who somehow makes you feel both at the same time. When I first started Gone with the Wind, I didn’t think I’d have much to say about her. She seemed like a spoiled Southern belle who only cared about getting what she wanted. But the more I read, the more I realized: she’s not simple, and she’s not forgettable.

____________________________________________________

Scarlett is the kind of character who forces you to sit with contradictions. She’s smart, but reckless. Self-reliant, but emotionally immature. Brave, but incredibly selfish. She spends half the book obsessing over someone who doesn’t want her, and the other half doing things that shock everyone around her, including the reader.

And yet, I couldn’t stop watching her. Even when I didn’t like her decisions, I was fascinated by how far she would go to survive, to win, to feel secure again. While others around her struggled to adapt to the war and everything it destroyed, Scarlett charged ahead. She did things “nice girls” weren’t supposed to do—like working outside the home, marrying for money, or taking charge of a business. She lied, she manipulated, and she used people, all in the name of survival. And somehow, that didn’t make her seem fake. It made her real.

____________________________________________________

One moment that really stuck with me was when Scarlett returned to Tara after Atlanta, hungry and desperate, and said that famous line:

“As God is my witness, I’ll never be hungry again.”

That was the moment I stopped underestimating her. You could feel her shift—from a girl who relied on charm and dresses, to someone who would do whatever it took to stay alive. She wasn’t kind. She wasn’t graceful. But she was strong. And that moment made me ask myself: what would I do if everything I knew collapsed overnight?

Still, Scarlett’s strength doesn’t come without damage. She doesn’t treat the people who care about her very well. She pushes Melanie away emotionally, even though Melanie always supports her. She chases Ashley long past the point of reason, ignoring what’s right in front of her. And she hurts Rhett, even though he’s probably the only one who ever sees her clearly. Scarlett is blind to her own feelings and to other people’s, too. That’s part of what makes her so frustrating. And so human.

____________________________________________________

There were times I wanted to grab on her shoulders and shake and say, “Just stop. Look at what you have.” But I also recognized that kind of tunnel vision. When you’re in survival mode, especially emotionally, it’s hard to slow down and reflect. Scarlett isn’t written to be perfect or redeemed. She’s written to be raw and complicated, and I think that’s why she’s stuck with readers for so long.

It also made me think about how female characters are usually expected to be either likable or “strong,” and how Scarlett breaks that idea completely. She’s not morally good. She doesn’t sacrifice herself for others. She doesn’t apologize. But she’s strong in a way we don’t always see—in her refusal to collapse. She survives a war, poverty, loneliness, loss, and rejection. And even when she’s wrong, she keeps going. There’s something powerful in that kind of grit, even when it’s messy.

By the end of the book, Scarlett doesn’t magically change into a better person. In fact, she only realizes what she had when it’s already slipping away. But even that felt honest. Growth isn’t always clean or complete. Sometimes people don’t figure it out in time. That felt more truthful than a perfect ending ever could.

____________________________________________________

Reading her made me reflect on how we judge people—especially women—for being too much of anything. Too cold, too emotional, too demanding, too proud. Scarlett is all of that and more. And instead of apologizing for it, she lives with it. Or maybe in it. She stumbles through love, grief, and ambition without ever really softening. She just keeps going. And that made me think about the kind of strength that doesn’t get celebrated. The kind that looks selfish on the surface but comes from a place of survival.

So no, I didn’t always like Scarlett O’Hara. But I respected her. And by the end, I realized she’s probably one of the most complicated characters I’ve ever read. Not despite her flaws, but because of them.

Check my other stories about Gone with the Wind!