Politics On the Edge Review

Introduction

Rory Stewart’s ‘Politics on the Edge’ is a candid exploration of his experiences and observations in the political arena, presenting a profound analysis of contemporary politics. Stewart, a former Conservative Member of Parliament in the UK, brings a unique perspective, having also served as a diplomat who walked across Africa and became Governor of Iraq. This book is not just a memoir but a reflection on modern politics, providing readers with an insider's view of the intricacies and challenges those in power face.

‘Politics on the Edge’ spans Stewart’s political career from his election to Parliament in 2010 until his departure from politics in 2019. The book is divided into several thematic sections, each delving into different aspects of his political journey and the broader political landscape. Stewart recounts his initial enthusiasm and optimism upon entering politics, only to be met with the stark realities of bureaucratic inertia, partisan conflict, and the often disillusioning nature of political life.

Click here to read 'Politics on the Edge' for free with a 30-day free trial.

Several themes are discussed in his memoir, as follows.

Disillusionment with Party Politics

Stewart’s narrative reveals a deep disillusionment with the party political system. He describes how party loyalty often supersedes individual judgment and the best interests of constituents. This theme is particularly poignant when Stewart recounts his experiences during the Brexit debates, where party lines were rigid, and compromise seemed impossible. He argues that this rigid partisanship stifles genuine debate and progress, leading to a political culture that is more about winning than governing effectively.

Challenges of Constituency Work

Stewart provides a detailed account of his work as an MP for Penrith and The Border, a rural constituency in Cumbria. He highlights the disconnect between Westminster politics and the realities of rural life, illustrating the challenges MPs face in balancing local concerns with national responsibilities. Stewart’s commitment to his constituents is evident, but so is his frustration with the limitations imposed by the political system.

Brexit and Its Aftermath

Like many comparatively moderate politicians from the period, Stewart is scarred by the political battles around Brexit and dedicates a significant portion of the book to Brexit. Stewart’s position on Brexit is complex; he was a Remain supporter but respected the referendum result. His accounts of the parliamentary debates, the infighting within the Conservative Party, and the ultimate fallout provide a sobering look at how Brexit has reshaped British politics. Stewart’s reflections on the erosion of trust in politicians and the rise of populism are particularly insightful.

Click here to read 'Politics on the Edge' for free with a 30-day free trial.

The Nature of Leadership

Stewart explores the concept of leadership through his own experiences and those of his colleagues. He contrasts the inspirational leaders he admired, such as David Cameron, with those he found lacking in vision and integrity. Stewart’s candid assessments of various political figures, including Boris Johnson, add a personal dimension to his analysis of leadership.

Public Service and Its Rewards

Despite the disillusionment and challenges, Stewart’s book is also a testament to the rewards of public service. He recounts moments of genuine achievement and the satisfaction of making a positive difference in people’s lives. Stewart’s passion for public service shines through, reminding readers of the noble intentions that often drive individuals into politics.

Writing Style

Stewart’s writing is engaging and accessible, as you would expect from such an articulate and thoughtful writer. He writes vivid prose that clearly explains the depth of his reflections. Stewart’s ability to weave together personal experiences with a wider commentary on the political system makes the book informative and compelling.

One of the book’s strengths is its honesty. Stewart does not shy away from admitting his own mistakes and shortcomings, another facet of his character that goes some way towards explaining how he transcends politics to be widely respected in society. This self-awareness adds credibility to his critiques of the political system and his fellow politicians. By presenting a balanced view that acknowledges both the positive and negative aspects of his political career, Stewart provides a nuanced perspective that is often missing in political memoirs.

Stewart’s dissection of the Brexit process is particularly noteworthy. His insider’s view of the machinations within the Conservative Party and the broader political ramifications of Brexit is enlightening. Stewart’s nuanced take on Brexit – recognising the legitimate grievances that fuelled the Leave vote while lamenting the divisive nature of the campaign – adds depth to the ongoing debate about the UK’s future.

Click here to read 'Politics on the Edge' for free with a 30-day free trial.

Another significant aspect of the book is Stewart’s emphasis on the importance of localism. He argues that the centralisation of power in Westminster has alienated many communities, particularly in rural areas. Stewart’s advocacy for devolving more power to local authorities is a recurring theme, and he provides compelling arguments for why this could lead to more effective and responsive governance.

My Verdict

‘Politics on the Edge’ by Rory Stewart is a compelling and thought-provoking exploration of contemporary politics. Stewart’s insider perspective, combined with his articulate writing and balanced analysis, makes this book a valuable read for anyone interested in understanding the complexities of the political system. His candid reflections on the challenges and rewards of public service offer a sobering but ultimately hopeful view of what politics can and should be.

Stewart’s call for greater localism, his critique of rigid party politics, and his nuanced take on Brexit provide important insights into the current state of British politics. It makes a balanced contribution to the ongoing conversation about how to create a more effective and responsive political system.

‘Politics on the Edge’ is a must-read for those looking to gain a deeper understanding of the inner workings of politics and the challenges faced by those who seek to navigate its treacherous waters. Stewart is a unique politician, award-winning podcaster and someone who has something to say and the ability to say it. Stewart’s blend of personal narrative and political analysis offers a unique perspective that is both informative and engaging, making this book a significant addition to the literature on contemporary politics.

Click here to read 'Politics on the Edge' for free with a 30-day free trial.