BookClub logo

First Wifes Shadow

Book Review

By Sid CoultonPublished about a year ago 10 min read

Introduction

Adele Parks’ new First Wife’s Shadow is a profound and rather powerful novel about love, loss, second chances and strength. As much as Parks is famous for her detailed plots and the ability to add the search for soul in banality Parks gives the reader a novel filled with suspense and unexpected turns of events combined with the examination of human relationships.

Plot Summary

It deals with Emma Westly, the strong, organized, successful CEO of AirBright, a manufacturing wind power company. Emma leads a life fully organized: her timetable and career success are perfectly aligned to show her obsessive-compulsive nature. But as is often the case, the measured life starts to fall apart when Kaia bumps into Matthew Charlton – a kind, lonely widower in his forties with the dubious occupation of a freelance photographer. These two meet immediately and fall in love and the lovers experience an extraordinary romantic odyssey full of trials on screen.

When Emma becomes connected to this man, she learns that she has not yet kicked her fear and that Matthew had a wife whom he buried named Becky. Their romance adds happiness and enthusiasm to Emma’s character although being in love with him unveils the setbacks she has not wanted to address. On the other hand, a string of challenges probing her resilience augments her challenges such as a high-profile job and painful origins from the alcohol-abusing parents.

Themes

Love and Loss

Let me note that the problem of coming to terms with death is described by Parks with great sensitivity and passion. Lena’s dead wife, Becky, is another important female character in the novel who is constantly evoked by Matthew and simultaneously appears to be a rival to Emma. Notes of hope and loss are heard throughout the book: it is a story of how people start from scratch after the loss and, at the same time, love helps as well as hurts.

Identity and Self-Worth

Emma’s character is a study in contrasts: young men who appear to be very self-assured and successful men, on the inside they are always struggling with grit. Her obsessive routines and disciplined lifestyle are a shield against the unpredictability of a life defence mechanism as a result of childhood trauma The occurrence in the story helps to raise concerns as well as demonstrate the fact that relying on someone in profound need may be a bad thing though finding more independence can also be challenging and dangerous.

Gender and the role of Women in the society

A woman trying to survive in a male-dominated world and industry necessitates enduring scepticism and criticism which responds with equal determination. Parks also focuses on scrutinizing women within society as career movers and shakers, lovers, and surviving and overcoming their abuse.

Trust and Vulnerability

The interaction between Emma and Matthew explains the level of trust as being an easily shattered thing. My two characters have their fair share of pain; Emma has lost her parents while Matthew lost his wife which builds the romance aspect adding tension between the two characters.

Character Development

About the main character Emma Westly: She is also a penis-wearing, manipulative, materialistic, elliptical cheater who has a disciplined lifestyle due to her obvious need for control. One could say that Emma is an independent woman but this was effectively portrayed by Parks as a lonesome woman. It is gratifying to see her growth from the closed and rather independently sustained character to the person who is ready to take some risks in terms of emotions during the novel.

Matthew Charlton is also convincing and yet the ghost of Becky sometimes obliterates him. According to Parks, he is a man struggling between the dead and the living as well as working through the grief in order to create a future with Emma. His character is one of the major elements of happiness and trouble for Emma throughout the setting of the novel.

Despite the fact that she died, Becky still plays an important role of the novel. Matthew and Emma’s love is ‘hailed’ by Parks’ casting of Raynell as an embodiment of pure love which darkens their view of their relationship. This forms an irresistible tension, given the fact that Emma is going to be forced to fight her personal demons of having to be the second best.

Heidi and Gina, friends of the protagonist Emma, are also used in the story in an effort to present the author’s audience with two different approaches to life and love. He grounds her but he also listens to her and reflects back to her what she has become.

Writing Style

Adele Parks is a great prose writer whose descriptive and aesthetic style focuses on depicting a character and social concerns both within and outside of him. Switching between these two characters’ points of view offers a broad outlook on the story and gives readers an insight into Emma’s obsessed-like thinking and Matthew’s tendency to betray his emotions. Parks uses both contemplation with timely snap moments of dialogue so the play never bored me.

The novel also has the advantage, achieved through Parks’ skills at creating the element of suspense. Despite a strong contention of the emotional and psychological drama, one finds himself on the edge of the seat once in a while. The slowness with which details of Emma’s awful past are unveiled, along with complexities in her interaction with Matthew, generate the plot.

Strengths

Parks is good at portraying the depth of feelings of the characters. The characters have been well developed, especially, the composed exterior of Emma, the grieving soul of Matthew and, the spectral apparition of a character, Becky.

The book deals with themes that affect everyone in society including loss, fear, and a quest for acceptance. The major social issues highlighted by Parks are worked out in more detail; thus, the story is at once thought-provoking and emotionally charged.

The shifting of the story between the characters’ view and the brief chapters are the ones leading to a build-up of intrigue with people getting more invested in the story. The pacing is consistently brisk, and there are enough betrayals and reveals to keep viewers interested at all times.

Though the situations in the film may sometimes look quite cinematic the film can be mainly viewed as character-driven. Emma’s development is most touching as through the relationship with Matthew she faces fear and reforms her identity.

Weaknesses

Now and then, the novel can seem somewhat formulaic; the trappings of middle-aged doubt can become heavy and the strands of Matthew’s despair somewhat predictable. However, these two themes are core to the story, though some readers may consider moments of great introspection as time-consuming.

There are many themes which might have been more developed, for instance, Emma’s problems at her workplace or her poor relations with her brother. What plays to some extent, is seen as adding texture to the plot, although not as crucial as the couple’s dramatic relations.

A typical example of what readers experience is in Becky’s Overshadowing Presence.

Although Becky is symbolic of Matthew’s past, she is present too often and it jeopardizes Emma to lose control over the relationship. It is precisely this dynamic that could have been played much more subtly.

Overall Impression

This is a real tale of love, loss, and transformation with the power of First Wife’s Shadow. Adele Parks presents a powerful and meaningful story which will be liked by all the people who like to read deep-feeling books. It tells the story of Emma Westly, a former strict chief executive officer and transformation to a woman with an opportunity to be vulnerable. Matthew Charlton’s inability to progress when in a losing position enhances the richness and intricacy of their relationship; makes them deserve each other.

Thus at times, the pacing feels a bit off and some of the themes are overdone and I found it to be a relatively small criticism of the novel. That is why First Wife’s Shadow is a worthy addition to Parks’ oeuvre: due to her skills in creating the play’s multi-dimensional characters and her themes’ sensitive handling.

Recommendation

Lovers of Adele Parks previous works and anyone who has an interest in the more dramatic sagas in the likes of Jojo Moyes’ Me Before You or Liane Moriarty’s Big Little Lies will find so much to enjoy in First Wife’s Shadow. Through it, readers can see what a great storyteller Parks is and how well she knows the world – and people.

What a beautiful, masterful beginning at love this is and is a novel that will stay with you long after the last page, a final embrace of the social, the messy and the complex and an absolute validation of risk.

Click here to listen to this book for free with Audible

Review

About the Creator

Sid Coulton

I have discovered a love for writing blogs, creating stories and writing articles. My book reviews do contain affiliate links as i am an Amazon Associate.

Reader insights

Be the first to share your insights about this piece.

How does it work?

Add your insights

Comments

There are no comments for this story

Be the first to respond and start the conversation.

Sign in to comment

    Find us on social media

    Miscellaneous links

    • Explore
    • Contact
    • Privacy Policy
    • Terms of Use
    • Support

    © 2026 Creatd, Inc. All Rights Reserved.