America's Deadliest Election: Dana Bash

Click here for a free audiobook.

Introduction: America's Deadliest Election: The Cautionary Tale of the Most Violent Election in American History by Dana Bash, CNN’s Chief Political Correspondent, dives deep into the election of 1872, one of the most turbulent and violent periods in U.S. political history. It examines the deeply contested gubernatorial race in Louisiana, which devolved into deadly violence, political chaos, and widespread racial tension. Bash warns readers of the dangers of a fractured democracy and draws stark parallels between the events of 1872 and today's political climate.

Chapter 1: The Election of 1872

The book begins with an exploration of the historical backdrop of the 1872 election, setting the scene in post-Civil War America. Reconstruction efforts were underway, but racial tensions ran high, particularly in the South. The election between Ulysses S. Grant and Horace Greeley was contentious, not just on the national level but more notably in Louisiana, where rival factions vied for control.

Chapter 2: Louisiana’s Political Chaos

Bash outlines the intense battle in Louisiana, a focal point of the 1872 election violence. Two rival governors, William Pitt Kellogg and John McEnery, claimed victory, leading to mass confusion and outrage. Political violence exploded, especially in rural areas, as both black and white citizens were pulled into the fray. Local militias and the Ku Klux Klan exerted force in favor of white supremacy, making Louisiana a battleground.

Chapter 3: The Colfax Massacre

This chapter recounts the tragic Colfax Massacre, where more than 150 Black men were killed by white supremacists. Bash underscores the event as a brutal symbol of the racial violence that characterized the era. The massacre became a turning point, signaling the diminishing federal will to protect Black citizens during Reconstruction.

Click here for a free audiobook.

Chapter 4: A Nation Gripped by Violence

Beyond Louisiana, the election of 1872 mirrored unrest across the country. Bash details the national response, highlighting the fragility of democracy at the time. Newspapers engaged in partisan attacks, political leaders exploited tensions for power, and violence became a political tool.

Chapter 5: The Train Race to New Orleans

In a dramatic retelling, Bash focuses on the extraordinary "train race" from New York to New Orleans, as leaders of rival political factions raced to seize control of Louisiana's government. This chapter highlights the absurdity and peril of the situation, as both sides resorted to desperate measures in their battle for legitimacy.

Click here for a free audiobook.

Chapter 6: Reconstruction’s Final Blow

This chapter discusses how the 1872 election, and events like the Colfax Massacre, contributed to the ultimate end of Reconstruction. The U.S. Supreme Court’s ruling in United States v. Cruikshank severely limited the federal government's ability to prosecute crimes against Black Americans, further entrenching white supremacy and segregation.

Chapter 7: The Rise of Segregation

Bash argues that the Supreme Court's ruling had lasting impacts, laying the groundwork for segregation in the South. This legal precedent would dominate the American legal system for nearly a century, shaping racial dynamics and institutional inequality.

Chapter 8: Parallels to the Present

In the final chapter, Bash draws unsettling parallels between the 1872 election and the political climate of the 21st century. The narrative serves as a warning of the dangers of partisan conflict, racial violence, and leaders who prioritize power over democracy. Bash urges readers to reflect on the lessons of history and recognize the warning signs of political instability today.

Click here for a free audiobook.

Conclusion: Dana Bash’s America's Deadliest Election is not only a gripping account of the most violent election in U.S. history but also a stark reminder of the fragility of democracy. Through vivid storytelling and historical analysis, Bash connects the chaos of 1872 to modern-day challenges, offering a timely reflection on the state of American politics and race relations.

*Some of the links in this book summary are affiliate links meaning we will receive a commission at no additional cost to you. In fact, you will receive a free book as a result of our partnership with audible.

*This summary was written with the assistance of AI technology, specifically OpenAI's GPT-4 model. While every effort has been made to ensure accuracy and coherence, it is important to recognize that the content may contain interpretations and phrasing generated by AI, with human oversight to ensure quality.