A Court of Mist and Fury by Sarah J. Maas - Review

Sarah J. Maas’s A Court of Mist and Fury (ACOMAF), the successor to the author’s phenomenally successful A Court of Thorns and Roses, delves deeper into the high-fantasy universe established in the first book, providing a multitude of new opportunities to analyze characters’ developments, mythologies inside the story, and moral shades of grey. Published in 2016, the novel not only explores the consequences of the action committed in the first book but also the introduction of new connections, allies and enemies, and the war that still rages in the world of Prythian with Feyre Archeron.

The reader will find in this review the analysis of the structural, character, thematic social and cultural significance of the novel as well as its contribution to the understanding of the fantasy genre and its public. For these reasons and because Maas describes a very detailed, multidimensional and emotional world, ‘A Court of Mist and Fury’ is the most contemporary successful young adult/everything (?) fantasy novel.

Click here to read A Court of Mist and Fury for free with a 30-day free trial

Plot Summary and Structure

The sequel begins three months after the story of A Court of Thorns and Roses where Feyre becomes a High Fae to face the terrible curse of Amarantha under the mountain. After moving to the Spring Court with her lover, Tamlin, Feyre deals with PTSD from the events she had to endure. She still remembers the violent trials she underwent to save Tamlin and the world of Prythian from Amarantha. Nevertheless, while she is running from despair and seeking safety in Tamlin’s court, the reader realizes soon enough that Feyre’s inner demons are only further amplified by Tamlin’s protective arrogance.

This part is devoted completely to Feyre’s internal process which includes PTSD survivor’s guilt, and feelings of loss. The character of Tamlin, who was her protector and lover of her, is now transformed into the image of oppression. The climax occurs when, after realizing the true feelings of the heroine, the High Lord of the Night Court calls upon the bargain made with a mortal in the first part of the tetralogy. Being forced to live with Rhysand for one week each month, viewers are also introduced to the Night Court which sharply differs from the oppressive Spring Court.

The more time Feyre passes in Night Court, and in the secret city of Velaris in particular, the more she experiences the themes of healing, freedom, and purpose. She learns more about the High Fae and being a woman in that world, thus stepping away from the person Tamlin made her into. Rhysand, who in the first book was the antagonist, is much more than what folks could think about. He is introduced as Feyre’s father figure and then betrothed, showing her how to be a warrior and gain her freedom.

This is where the storyline of the novel deepens with a war threat from the King of Hybern thus having Feyre and her new companions seek a way to ready themselves for the powerful battle capable of shattering the last threads of peace in Prythian. The climax of this novel unfolds with powerful and surprising moments and Feyre has to make choices that seem heart-wrenching in preparation for the next novel of the set.

Character Development

What seems to be one of the biggest strong points in A Court of Mist and Fury is its extensive and complex character progression, especially regarding Feyre. In the first book, Feyre’s motivation was primarily her love for Tamlin and her responsibilities towards the people who matter to her but in ACOMAF, the character starts discovering herself independent of others. I have to say that Maas has done a phenomenal job when it comes to describing Feyre’s trauma and her journey towards the path of healing makes her a realistic, and sympathetic character.

Feyres development is linked to her changes in relationships. Her relationship with Tamlin develops into one of the key relationships and advancements of the book. While Tamlin was an element of comfort and protection for Feyre in the first two books, his behaviour here seems domineering and completely unwilling to sympathize or even understand the plight of the character he professes to love. Their relationship represents toxic and emotionally abusive relationships and thus, people must learn that they need to listen to each other and respect one another’s boundaries.

Click here to read A Court of Mist and Fury for free with a 30-day free trial

At the same time, Rhysand who is one of the main characters of the series transforms in this book. First seen as a self-interested, possibly malevolent character in the first book, Rhysand is one of Feyre’s primary sources of healing. In our story, Maas shows the depth of Tarzan’s character, which is full of tenderness, kind-heartedness, and duty to his people. As much as Feyre reciprocated his calm and polite advances, she had quite a different treatment with him than with Tamlin. The reflections of power dynamics and symmetry between those two characters, desperation, and passion bring the reader the feel of Feyre and Rhysand’s love at its finest and complicated.

Supporting characters are great in ACOMAF too. The characters Mor, Cassian, Azriel and Amren as part of Rhysand’s inner circle provide complexity to the narrative and all have their complex histories and personal desires. Maas incorporates those characters in the development of Feyre’s main character, and at the same time, the reader is given interesting secondary story arcs.

Themes

Power, Autonomy, and Self-Discovery: Probably, one of the main concepts that effectively resonates through the pages of A Court of Mist and Fury is the main character’s path of regaining her independence. In the first book, she gives herself to people she loves over and over again, but in ACOMAF she realizes that she has a value greater than utility for others. Finally, during the Night Court, Feyre learns to develop several abilities; physical and emotional strength. It is the story of rediscovery, of learning the ability to place faith in the self and be in charge of one’s own life.

Trauma and Healing: Maas never politely avoids mapping the emotional consequences of trauma. PTSD is a major plot element of Feyre’s character development, and the reader sees her dealing with nightmares, flashbacks, and worthless feelings realistically. The novel under discussion pays a great deal of attention to the aspect of healing, whether it be somatic, psychological, or emotional. Rhysand as a healer for Feyre and his people enriches this theme. Of course the notion of ‘family found’ is also important to the process of mending, after Feyre loses everyone she knew and turns to Rhysand’s group of friends.

Love and Relationships: It goes deeper into various forms of love, which have passion, and those that do not have passion such as the love between friends and family. Both Feyre’s transformational relationships with Tamlin and Rhysand represent learning as well as contrasting scenarios. The book focuses on the subtlety of nuanced emotion, mainly the exploration of love that one cannot sacrifice one’s self-determination and self-realization for. Feyre and Rhysand’s romance is a strong selling point of the book, and Maas tops it up with an equal, technically Platonic love that is emotionally intimate. Instead, they forge a great friendship, which makes their love story believable and their marriage plain lovely.

Good vs. Evil and Moral Complexity: Although the first book focuses on the clear fight between the white-washing angels and the demonic creatures, ACOMAF adds more layers. Whereas Rhysand – at first – appears to illustrate the dangerous features of a villain, he is indistinguishable a kind and selfless leader, while Tamlin seems to present aspects of both a hero and a villain. Maas, thus, brings forward the concept that the human character cannot simply be lined up into two shades of black and white; the bad and the good because people are formed by their experiences, violence and decisions made.

World-Building and Mythology

In terms of world-building, Sarah J. Maas is an outstanding author, and in ACOMAF, the reader learns even more about Prythian which was at least mentioned in the first book. It is also important to note that there is a thing called Night Court, and the city of Velaris has to be one of the most recognizable settings in the entire novel. The patients speak of Velaris as home to beauty, art, and liberty, just the opposite environment from the wartorn regions neighbouring it. Maas’s more detailed visions of Velaris and the so-called starlit lands full of art and rather diverse and friendly inhabitants create the feeling of something enchanting.

It also takes a closer look at the Magical Systems of the world. A new ability that Feyre acquires in the course of the book is centred around her as a newly inducted High Fae after the events of the first book. When she starts practising her powers, the reader discovers fresh types of magic, mythological myths, and superior talismans. Maas constructs her universe that seamlessly intertwines all the aspects of the product of magic to have its backstory.

The politics of Prythian also becomes even more complex in ACOMAF. A conflict with the enemy from the ‘other side’ of the world, complicated relations between the courts and escalating tensions in the internal life of each court contribute to the creation of an atmosphere of mystery and suspense. Maas does not spare anything in the stories of her characters and the general political events on the continent are as much shown despite the setting, making the narrative mix personal and global in scale.

Writing Style and Pacing

In ACOMAF, Maas has successfully injected a lot of description and detail into the textual narrative. Her lovely writing makes the world of Prythian vivid: the beautiful Night Court, the agonizing blackness of the King of Hybern’s court. The growth of the characters is one of the major strong sides of the novel; Maas portrays Feyre’s inner battles as sincere and profound.

The narrative of ACOMAF is more leisurely than that of the first book but it also allows for character growth and intrigue. However, some of the readers may consider the first half of the novel as the slow-burning process revealing love interests, Feyre’s growth, and healing process, the slowness creates a growing anticipation for a more emotional impact in the second half of the novel. The last part of the novel is anticipated and adventurous with high suspense arcs that create expectations for the next series of episodes.

Conclusion

A Court of Mist and Fury *is an epic follow-up that extends in both size and complexity. Healing through love is evident in this book, but Maas also develops an elaborate universe in which readers can immerse themselves: Feyre’s journey from a diagnosed PTSD hunting-obsessed girl into a powerful High Fae is so fascinating. Full of the characters’ development, diverse lore of the world created by McGuire, and the different issues like the right to choose or post-traumatic stress disorder and moral relativism, ACOMAF might be seen as one of the most memorable and thought-provoking books in the genre of the fantastic at the turning of the turned millennium.

This book is a fantastic high fantasy finalist for the fans of romance, and character-oriented narratives that will not simply leave you with just a memory.

Click here to read A Court of Mist and Fury for free with a 30-day free trial