Beat logo
Content warning
This story may contain sensitive material or discuss topics that some readers may find distressing. Reader discretion is advised. The views and opinions expressed in this story are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the official policy or position of Vocal.

The X Factor New Zealand incident

The harsh reality of bullying in reality shows

By Allwyn Roman WaghelaPublished about a year ago 3 min read

During the X Factor New Zealand incident in 2015, Natalia Kills and her husband, Willy Moon, were judges on the show. They harshly criticized a contestant named Joe Irvine. Natalia accused him of copying her husband’s style, calling him a “doppelgänger” and making comparisons to a serial killer. Willy Moon added to the criticism, likening Irvine’s performance to something out of a horror movie.

Their comments were seen as overly harsh and inappropriate, leading to a public outcry. The backlash was swift, and both Natalia Kills and Willy Moon were fired from the show the next day.

This incident had a significant negative impact on Natalia Kills’ career, and she has since apologised for her actions.

What was the public's reaction to Natalia Kills' comments?

The public reaction to Natalia Kills’ comments on X Factor New Zealand was overwhelmingly negative. Many viewers and fans were shocked and outraged by the harshness and perceived bullying nature of her remarks. Social media platforms were flooded with criticism, and there was a significant backlash against both Natalia Kills and Willy Moon.

The incident quickly went viral, with many calling for their removal from the show. The producers responded swiftly, firing both judges the day after the incident. This decision was widely supported by the public, who felt that their comments were unprofessional and unnecessarily cruel.

The backlash had a lasting impact on Natalia Kills’ career, and she has since apologized for her actions. However, the incident remains a notable example of how public opinion can swiftly turn against public figures perceived to be behaving inappropriately.

How did Natalia Kills respond to the public backlash?

In response to the public backlash, Natalia Kills issued an apology. She expressed regret for her comments and acknowledged that her behavior was inappropriate. She stated that her intention was never to hurt anyone and that she was deeply sorry for the impact her words had on Joe Irvine and the viewers.

Despite her apology, the incident had already caused significant damage to her reputation and career. She has since kept a lower profile in the public eye.

What was Joe Irvine's reaction to her apology?

Joe Irvine handled the situation with grace. After the incident, he received an outpouring of support from the public and fellow contestants. While he didn’t publicly respond to Natalia Kills’ apology in detail, he did express gratitude for the support he received during that difficult time.

He continued to pursue his music career and used the experience as a learning opportunity. His positive attitude and resilience were widely praised.

What happened to Joe Irvine's music career after the incident?

After the X Factor New Zealand incident, Joe Irvine continued to pursue his music career. The public support he received helped him gain more visibility and opportunities. He released several singles and performed at various events, leveraging the attention from the incident to build his profile.

While he hasn’t reached mainstream stardom, Joe has maintained a presence in the music industry and continues to create and perform music. His resilience and positive attitude have been inspiring to many.

How has Natalia Kills' career evolved since then?

Since the X Factor New Zealand incident, Natalia Kills has kept a relatively low profile. She rebranded herself as Teddy Sinclair and focused on songwriting and producing for other artists. Under this new identity, she has worked with notable musicians and contributed to several successful projects.

Her work behind the scenes has allowed her to stay active in the music industry, even if she’s not as visible as she once was. This shift has helped her rebuild her career and reputation over time.

celebritieshumanitypop culturesocial mediatv review

About the Creator

Allwyn Roman Waghela

I am a professional blogger, writing about topics such as travel, food, and lifestyle thus, showcasing my creativity and communication skills.

YouTube

Instagram

LinkedIn

Threads

Reader insights

Good effort

You have potential. Keep practicing and don’t give up!

Add your insights

Comments (1)

Sign in to comment
  • Andrea Corwin about a year ago

    Rebranded with a new name - 🥴

Find us on social media

Miscellaneous links

  • Explore
  • Contact
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use
  • Support

© 2026 Creatd, Inc. All Rights Reserved.