Wheel logo

Mistakes When Choosing Aftermarket Wheels and Tires for Pickup Trucks

Common Mistakes in Choosing Aftermarket Wheels and Tires for Pickup Trucks

By Jen DemkinPublished 9 months ago 6 min read

Upgrading with a new set of wheels and tires is one of the popular modifications that can dramatically improve your pickup truck’s performance, reliability, and safety. However, the process involves more than just selecting from the wide variety of tire and wheel packages you can find on the market. With so many options available, this upgrade is not as simple as it looks. It's easy to make a mistake, which can lead to costly errors, poor performance, safety hazards, and worse—damage to the vehicle. Learning about the common mistakes when selecting aftermarket wheels and tires allows you to avoid these pitfalls.

Common Mistakes When Choosing Aftermarket Wheels and Tires

Unsuitable wheel and tire setup can lead to safety hazards, poor performance, and unnecessary expenses. These common mistakes will help you understand what to avoid, especially when purchasing aftermarket parts for pickup trucks.

  • Ignoring Load Rating: Choosing wheels and tires with insufficient load ratings can lead to tire failure and compromised safety and performance, especially when carrying heavy loads or towing. Always ensure the selection matches your truck’s weight requirements.

  • Incorrect Offset and Backspacing: Improper offset and backspacing can cause the tire to rub against fenders or suspension components. Overlooking these factors can also result in suspension damage and handling issues. Improper wheel offset can also affect both appearance and drivability.

  • Focusing Solely on Aesthetics: While style is important, prioritizing looks over performance and functionality can lead to poor handling and reduced safety. Flashy wheels and aggressive tires may look appealing, but they should be chosen based on performance needs rather than just aesthetics.

  • Disregarding Tire Size Compatibility: Choosing tires that are too large or too wide can cause rubbing, damage fenders, and compromise suspension travel.

  • Neglecting Terrain and Driving Habits: Selecting tires unsuitable for your driving conditions can lead to poor traction and reduced performance. Different tires are designed for particular terrains. Using mud-terrain tires for highway driving or all-terrain tires in deep mud can lead to performance issues.

  • Choosing Cheap Option and Skimping on Quality: Choosing cheap, low-quality wheels and tires can lead to premature wear, tire failure, and compromised safety.

  • Not Considering Brake Clearances: New wheels can interfere with your brakes, especially if you have upgraded brakes.

  • Failing to Account for Fuel Efficiency: Larger, heavier wheels and aggressive tires can reduce fuel economy significantly. Be mindful of how modifications impact mileage.

  • Skipping Professional Installation and Balancing: Installing the wheels and tires yourself can save you from paying extra charges. However, if you’re not confident in your skills, seeking the expertise of professionals prevents headaches, especially if you improperly installed them onto the vehicle. Unbalanced or improperly installed wheels and tires can cause vibration, resulting in uneven tread wear and unsafe driving conditions.

Why Replace the Factory Wheels and Tires?

You get stock wheels with standard tires designed for general-purpose driving when you drive your pickup truck from the dealer’s lot. This combination prioritizes comfort and fuel efficiency. While suitable for daily driving in city streets and high, they often fall short when driving off-road or in more demanding and harsh conditions.

  • Size Compatibility: Off-road tires are wider and taller than standard tires for daily driving. If the truck’s factory wheels are too narrow, they may not accommodate the new tires properly. They won’t fit since the rims cannot provide adequate clearance or support for larger tires.

  • Load Ratings and Durability: Not all stock rims are rated to handle the increased load capacity of off-road tires, particularly when carrying heavy cargo or towing. The factory wheels may not be strong enough to bear the added weight and stress of chunkier, more aggressive-looking tires. This can lead to damage, such as cracks or bends.

  • Off-Road Capability: In some cases, off-road tires can be fitted onto factory truck wheels, but you have to take note of the limitations. Tires for pavement lack the aggressive tread patterns and durable construction needed for challenging terrains. The tread patterns and sidewall are not flexible and thick enough to endure the harshness of the trails. All-terrain tires from brands like Nitto Tires are recommended as they provide versatility, especially if you want to retain the ability to drive on smooth roads and occasionally in rugged terrains.

  • Aesthetic and Functional Concerns: While using off-road tires on stock wheels is possible, upgrading to aftermarket wheels designed for off-roading will provide better durability and performance. Stock wheels often lack the style and customization options available in aftermarket options.

  • Performance Constraints: Factory setups may not optimize braking, handling, or load-carrying capacity. If you go off-roading or haul heavy loads, upgrading from factory wheels and tires is necessary. Pairing off-road tires with aftermarket wheels designed for off-road use can withstand the stresses of rough terrain. They do not hamper the power and capability of your pickup truck as you drive in rugged landscapes.

Choosing the Appropriate Wheel and Tire Setup for Your Vehicle

Whether for off-road capability, aesthetics, or performance, having the right wheel and tire combination can enhance the functionality of pickup trucks.

  • Increased Performance: The best off-road wheels and tires for your truck can help enhance traction, durability, and maneuverability in challenging terrains.

  • Enhanced Safety: The right tire and wheel setup ensures better braking, handling, and stability, reducing the risk of accidents.

  • Better Fuel Efficiency: Choosing appropriately sized tires can prevent unnecessary fuel consumption caused by increased rolling resistance.

  • Added Aesthetic Appeal: Aftermarket wheels and tires can transform the look of a pickup truck, giving it a more aggressive and rugged stance.

  • Increased Resale Value: A well-maintained and properly upgraded pickup truck can be sold at a higher resale price, as aftermarket mods often appeal to potential buyers.

Recommended Wheel and Tire Packages for Off-Roading

Investing in the right wheel and tire combination ensures improved performance, safety, and durability, making your off-roading adventures more enjoyable and hassle-free. Here are some wheel and tire packages you can avail of for your vehicle

XD Wheels Gauntlet XD852 and Nitto Trail Grappler

The 9-spoke wheel design of XD852 will complement the style of pickup trucks due to its stunning satin black and satin black with gray finish options. Designed for aggressive off-road styling and durability, XD Wheels are made of one-piece alloy, which is popular among off-road truck owners. The Trail Grappler from Nitto provides a good balance of on-road comfort and incredible performance off-road. A lot of truck owners praise its aggressive tread pattern for effective tractions without compromising durability and ride comfort.

Fuel Wheels Rebel D681 and Toyo Open Country M/T

Fuel Off-Road Wheels give a strong-featured look and outstanding strength for extreme terrain conditions. The brand is known for its intricate designs and durability. The wheels come in different finishes, such as matte bronze black bead ring, matte fun metal black bead ring, and matte black. The Toyo Open Country M/T traction is a favorite among off-road enthusiasts, providing excellent grip in muddy, snowy, or rocky terrains. These tires are suitable for different seasons, boasting aggressive tread patterns for traction and long tread life.

Method Race Wheels NV305 and BFGoodrich All-Terrain T/A KO2

Lightweight, strong, and performance-driven, Method Race Wheels are ideal for serious off-roaders. The NV305 comes in many wheel finish selections such as Matte Bronze (with black lip), Double Black, Gloss Bahia Blue (with gloss black lip), matte black, machined (with matte black lip), red (with matte black lip), and titanium (with matte black lip). These wheels come in different sizes, bolt patterns, and offset spacing. Combining BFGoodrich All-Terrain T/A KO2 with Method wheels allows you to enjoy driving on smooth or bumpy roads. These all-terrain tires deliver exceptional toughness and traction for traversing rugged environments and road conditions. Moreover, the KO2 is made with a trademarked CoreGard Technology with a thicker, extended shoulder and bruise-resistant sidewall rubber.

Carefully considering your needs and choosing suitable parts is crucial to avoid common mistakes when upgrading wheels and tires. The appropriate tire type combined with trusty wheels can significantly enhance your truck’s performance, handling, and reliability. They can also help you achieve a safer and more enjoyable driving experience, whether on the pavement or off-road.

product review

About the Creator

Jen Demkin

Hi, I'm Jen from 4WheelOnline. My fascination with vehicles started in my childhood. I like cars more than dolls. I enjoy writing about automotive industry news, vehicle maintenance tips, and more.

Reader insights

Be the first to share your insights about this piece.

How does it work?

Add your insights

Comments

There are no comments for this story

Be the first to respond and start the conversation.

Sign in to comment

    Find us on social media

    Miscellaneous links

    • Explore
    • Contact
    • Privacy Policy
    • Terms of Use
    • Support

    © 2026 Creatd, Inc. All Rights Reserved.