Poets logo

The Monster in the Mirror

A Powerful Reflection on Identity, Trauma, and the Inner Battle We All Face in Silence

By ibrahim khanPublished 7 months ago 3 min read
The Monster in the Mirror
Photo by 烧不酥在上海 老的 on Unsplash

Have you ever looked in the mirror and felt like you were staring at a stranger?

Not just tired eyes or messy hair—but someone who looks like you, yet feels nothing like you. Someone who holds your face, your skin, your features… but behind their eyes, there’s something cold, still, and cruel.

That’s what this is about. A story—not of ghosts or monsters hiding in closets—but of the one that lives inside us. The one who never leaves. The one who watches in silence while we fall apart.

It starts with a person looking at their reflection. But this reflection isn’t normal. It doesn’t blink, it doesn’t flinch, and worst of all—it doesn’t lie.

The person in the mirror isn’t reacting. They just sit there, still and quiet, like they’re waiting. Watching. Judging. While the real “you” on this side of the glass is struggling, shaking, trying to stay together.

The reflection isn’t a reflection at all. It’s a memory. A version of you that was left behind. The version that didn’t fight back. The one who smiled when it hurt. The one who said “yes” when they wanted to scream “no.” The one who stayed silent while others decided who they were allowed to be.

That person didn’t disappear. They stayed in the mirror.

They became a reminder of every moment that changed you. Every name they gave you that wasn’t yours. Every time you swallowed your truth just to survive. Every time you carved away a piece of yourself to make others more comfortable.

That version of you? They remember. They remember the nights you tried to disappear. The days you dressed up in someone else’s skin just to be accepted. The moments you said “I’m fine” when you were breaking.

They remember it all.

And the worst part? That version of you doesn’t move. They just stare. Not because they’re calm—but because they don’t need to run anymore. They’ve seen how this ends. They’ve already accepted the pain. The shame. The forgetting.

And that’s what makes them powerful.

You, the one who changed, who fought, who survived—you’re the one pretending now. Pretending that you’re over it. Pretending the past didn’t happen. Pretending you’re not still shaped by it.

That version of you in the mirror? They’re the real one. At least, that’s how it feels.

They wear your old face better than you do. They sit with their pain and own it. While you try to build a new life on top of the ruins. But the ruins are still there.

You want to hate them. You want to smash the mirror. Not because they’re lying—but because they’re not.

They are the truth you buried. The version of yourself you wish you could erase. But no matter how many times you run, or change, or grow, they are still there—quiet, still, and whole.

They’re the part of you that didn’t move on. And somehow, that makes them feel more real than you.

You try to tell yourself, “I’m better now. I’ve healed. I’m stronger.” But they don’t care. They know every dark corner of your past. Every mistake. Every time you broke your own heart just to be loved.

And sometimes, if you're honest, you wonder if they’re right to judge you.

Because part of you still fits into their shape. You still slip into that version of yourself when no one is looking. You still carry the same fears, the same memories, the same shame.

You hate them. But you made them. You need them. Because without them, you wouldn’t be here.

They are your proof.

Proof that you survived.

Proof that you changed.

Proof that you weren’t always this version of yourself—and maybe that’s okay.

In the end, the horror isn’t the monster in the mirror.

The horror is knowing the monster might be you.

But maybe that’s not such a bad thing.

Maybe the real strength comes from facing that reflection—not running from it. Accepting it. Knowing that even the darkest parts of ourselves are still part of the story.

Because healing isn’t about pretending the past never happened. It’s about looking into the mirror and saying:

“I see you. I remember. And I’m still here.”

***

humorlove poemsCinquain

About the Creator

Reader insights

Be the first to share your insights about this piece.

How does it work?

Add your insights

Comments

There are no comments for this story

Be the first to respond and start the conversation.

Sign in to comment

    Find us on social media

    Miscellaneous links

    • Explore
    • Contact
    • Privacy Policy
    • Terms of Use
    • Support

    © 2026 Creatd, Inc. All Rights Reserved.