Poets logo

Rotten Fruit in the Fridge

I Don't Know Why I Keep Looking

By Tim CarmichaelPublished 7 months ago 1 min read
Runner-Up in I Didn’t Say That Out Loud Challenge
Photo created by FreePik

There’s a plum in the back of the fridge

that’s been there for three months.

I haven’t thrown it out.

I open the door, look at it,

close the door.

I don’t know what that says about me

but it says something.

I still Google people I used to love

just to make sure they didn’t die

without telling me.

Not because I’d do anything about it.

Just because I want to know

if I’m still allowed to be angry.

When I say I’m tired,

I don’t mean sleepy.

I mean I’m worn thin from holding in

every little thing I think would make people leave.

The real me is ugly in places.

Like a house with no couch.

Like a voicemail you delete before the beep.

Sometimes I pretend I’m on a talk show

explaining my side of the story.

Imaginary applause.

Imaginary understanding.

In real life, I nod a lot.

People like that about me.

I get jealous of people who cry in public.

Their faces go red and wet,

and nobody calls them dramatic.

I once bit my cheek so hard

to stop myself from sobbing at a Denny’s

that I tasted metal

for the rest of the night.

I tell people I don’t want kids.

But the truth is

I don’t trust myself not to mess one up.

I yell at dogs when I’m tired.

I’ve ignored texts from people who said “I need you.”

I think I believe in God,

but only on elevators.

My voicemail is full.

Not with messages—

with the pressure of pretending

someone might leave one.

Some nights I lie on the floor

like a crime scene

and wait for a reason to get up.

None comes.

Still, I brush my teeth.

Still, I feed the cat.

And tomorrow

I’ll open the fridge,

see the plum,

close it again.

Free Verse

About the Creator

Tim Carmichael

Tim is an Appalachian poet and cookbook author. He writes about rural life, family, and the places he grew up around. His poetry and essays have appeared in Bloodroot and Coal Dust, his latest book.

https://a.co/d/537XqhW

Reader insights

Be the first to share your insights about this piece.

How does it work?

Add your insights

Comments (14)

Sign in to comment
  • Sean A.5 months ago

    Those lines on god and elevators was a great blend of dark truth and humor.

  • F. M. Rayaan6 months ago

    This was quietly brilliant, Tim. The plum, the elevator God, the full voicemail with no messages—every line hit like a whisper you can’t un-hear. It’s raw, funny, and devastating all at once. Congrats on the well-deserved runner-up spot 👏🫀

  • Joe O’Connor7 months ago

    Excellent Tim- this is searingly honest, open to the point where readers will catch something they can empathise with, and the tone is on point. "I think I believe in God, but only on elevators." favourite line for me.

  • Well deserved Runner Up placing… I love the way you interwove commonplace occurrences with deeper issues.

  • Lamar Wiggins7 months ago

    Congrats, Tim! A very unique entry! So glad it was recognized!

  • Wooohooooo congratulations on your win! 🎉💖🎊🎉💖🎊

  • This is a real celebration of the mundane. I really admire your writing. Congratulations on your win

  • A. J. Schoenfeld7 months ago

    I love how you took something so mundane and turned it into a metaphor for something huge and overwhelming. Also, sometimes I pretend I'm on a talk show too. Give me a mic so everyone has to listen. Perhaps that's why we write instead. Congratulations on your Runner Up!

  • Julie Lacksonen7 months ago

    Yay!! Congratulations! This is stunning. What an accomplishment!

  • JBaz7 months ago

    Wow There is something special about this piece Congratulations

  • Imola Tóth7 months ago

    Congratulations on your placement! 🎉🎉

  • Tiffany Gordon7 months ago

    Superbly-written & touching... 🙏🏾Praying

  • Mother Combs7 months ago

    I've done that, and didn't even feel guilty about it

  • L.I.E7 months ago

    Wow, so real confession. Some are relatable. Sounds like depression. Excellent poem.

Find us on social media

Miscellaneous links

  • Explore
  • Contact
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use
  • Support

© 2026 Creatd, Inc. All Rights Reserved.