Painting Over Wallpaper vs. Removing It: What’s the Better Option?

When it comes to giving your home a fresh new look, the walls often take top priority. But what happens when those walls are covered with dated or stubborn wallpaper? Homeowners are faced with a common dilemma: should you paint over wallpaper or remove it altogether? If you're looking for a smart and effective approach, this guide compares both options—along with advice from expert House Painters in Hobart—to help you make the right decision.

The Case for Painting Over Wallpaper

If the wallpaper is in good condition (no peeling, bubbling, or mold), painting over it can be a time-saving and cost-effective solution.

Pros:

• Saves Time & Effort: No need to scrape, steam, or deal with glue residue.

• Prevents Wall Damage: Older plaster walls can be delicate, and removing wallpaper can cause gouges or tears.
• Instant Transformation: With the right prep, you can create a clean, modern finish within hours.

Cons:

• Requires Perfect Prep: Any loose edges or texture will show through paint if not sealed properly.
• Not Ideal for Vinyl Wallpaper: Some types won’t hold paint well without a special primer.
• Pro tip from House Painters Hobart: Always prime the wallpaper with an oil-based primer to seal the surface and prevent peeling.

The Case for Removing Wallpaper

While more labor-intensive, removing wallpaper is often the more long-term solution—especially for homeowners planning to stay put for years.

Pros:

• Better Surface for Painting: Bare walls offer a smooth and paint-ready finish.
• No Risk of Wallpaper Peeling Later: A painted wallpaper layer may peel if the bond weakens over time.
• Ideal for Bathroom or Kitchen Walls: High-moisture areas may cause painted wallpaper to bubble.

Cons:

• Time-Consuming: Wallpaper removal can take hours—or days—depending on glue strength and paper type.
• May Require Wall Repairs: Especially in older homes, removing wallpaper can reveal imperfections that need plaster patching or sanding.

Comparing Cost, Effort & Results

When comparing the options of painting over wallpaper versus removing it, the decision often comes down to time, cost, and the kind of results you want to achieve. Painting over wallpaper is generally quicker and more affordable. It requires fewer tools, less labor, and can usually be completed within a day or two—making it ideal for homeowners or renters looking for a fast refresh. However, it may not offer the same level of finish or long-term durability as removing the wallpaper.

In contrast, removing wallpaper takes more time and effort, especially if the wallpaper is old, has been applied in multiple layers, or is difficult to peel. The process might reveal damaged walls that need repairs, adding to the overall cost and timeline. But in return, you get a smooth, clean surface that provides a superior base for paint. It’s a more permanent solution and is often preferred for high-traffic areas or if you're aiming for a flawless, professional look.

For those on a tight budget or timeline, painting over wallpaper can be a practical choice. But if you're focused on achieving the best possible results for the long term, especially in moisture-prone spaces or older homes, wallpaper removal is often the better investment.

What Do House Painters Hobart Recommend?

Professionals like House Painters Hobart suggest a case-by-case approach. Their advice:

“If the wallpaper is textured, damaged, or coming loose, it’s best to remove it. But if it’s flat and firmly attached, you can save time by painting over it—as long as you prep the surface with primer and seal any seams.”

They also recommend avoiding painting over multiple layers of wallpaper or wallpaper applied to unprimed drywall.

How to Paint Over Wallpaper Properly (Step-by-Step)

• Inspect and Repair: Ensure the wallpaper is glued tightly and not peeling.
• Clean the Surface: Use mild soap and water to remove dust or grease.
• Seal the Seams: Use joint compound or caulk to smooth out edges.
• Prime: Apply an oil-based primer (not water-based—it could loosen the glue).
• Paint: Use high-quality paint, ideally in two coats for solid coverage.

When to Call the Professionals

Painting or removing wallpaper can be a daunting project—especially in larger or older homes. Trusted local experts like House Painters Hobart bring the experience, tools, and safety measures needed to handle the job efficiently. They can also guide you on color selection and whether painting over wallpaper will hold up well in your home’s environment.

Final Verdict: Which Option Is Right for You?

• Choose Painting Over Wallpaper if the wallpaper is in good condition, you want a fast result, or you're updating a rental property.
• Choose Removal if you're after a premium finish, planning to stay long-term, or dealing with moisture-prone areas.

Both methods have their place—but whichever path you take, proper preparation is key to achieving a beautiful, long-lasting finish.