Supreme Court rejects appeal from special counsel to expedite Trump immunity case

Special counsel Jack Smith's request to immediately settle former President Donald Trump's claim of immunity in his election interference probe has been denied by the Supreme Court.

The recent development from the Supreme Court reveals that Special Counsel Jack Smith's request for an immediate resolution on Donald Trump's immunity claim in the election interference probe has been rejected. This denial means that Smith's attempt to fast-track the decision on presidential immunity has been unsuccessful. Trump had also sought the Supreme Court's involvement in this case.

The interpretation of this decision holds significant implications, potentially impacting forthcoming cases and even influencing the 2024 election. NBC's Justice and Intelligence Correspondent, Ken Dilanian, along with U.S. Legal Analyst Barbara McQuade, shed light on the implications. Dilanian stated that Smith faces setbacks as the case will now navigate through the D.C. Circuit Court of Appeals first. Although the D.C. Circuit Court has expedited the matter and scheduled oral arguments for January 9th, the timing suggests the trial, initially set for March 4th, could face delays, possibly shifting to a summer trial rather than a spring one.

McQuade estimated the trial's duration at about two months, which could potentially intersect with the primaries and conventions, impacting the electoral process.

Regarding the legal aspects, Dilanian explained that there are two separate arguments about immunity underway. One involves civil cases where Trump is being sued by Capitol Police officers over the January 6th incident. The Appeals Court ruled against Trump's presidential immunity in this context, suggesting that his actions during that time weren't in line with presidential duties. This ruling could be influential for the ongoing criminal context and potential Supreme Court involvement.

Ultimately, the denial of the expedited decision by the Supreme Court indicates a setback for Smith's strategy. The unprecedented nature of this case, dealing with the immunity of a former president for actions during office, makes it a high-stakes legal battle, even as the case proceeds through the regular legal channels rather than a fast-tracked process.

The recent Supreme Court decision not to expedite the special counsel Jack Smith's case, determining former President Trump's immunity in the election interference case, is significant. Instead of fast-tracking, the case will follow the regular legal process, starting with a federal appeals court. Oral arguments will be presented there, and a judgment will be made, potentially leading to appeals to the Supreme Court. This means a lengthier legal journey through the federal court system and potential future proceedings in the Supreme Court.

There are immediate implications, notably in Colorado, where a deadline in early January looms for determining Trump's presence on the ballot. This decision could influence down-ballot outcomes, such as in a highly competitive House race involving Lauren Boebert in Colorado. Boebert's narrow victory in the previous cycle could be affected if Trump is not on the ballot as the Republican nominee, potentially impacting Republican votes in the state. Such nuances often play pivotal roles in determining control in a closely divided House of Representatives.

This outcome contradicts earlier expectations, especially among Republicans, who anticipated a favorable Supreme Court ruling based on Trump's lack of conviction in a court of law regarding the insurrection allegation. The timeline and trajectory of this case now suggest a longer legal process ahead, challenging previous assumptions about its expeditious resolution by the court.

MSNBC delivers breaking news, in-depth analysis of politics headlines, as well as commentary and informed perspectives. Find video clips and segments from The Rachel Maddow Show, Morning Joe, The Beat with Ari Melber, Deadline: White House, The ReidOut, All In, Last Word, 11th Hour, and Alex Wagner who brings her breadth of reporting experience to MSNBC primetime. Watch “Alex Wagner Tonight” Tuesday through Friday at 9pm Eastern.