What If the Reality We Live in is Hell, and We are Simply Dreaming?

What if the reality we live in — this messy, chaotic, unpredictable, and beautiful thing that we call life — is hell? And what if it’s all just a dream? What if everything we experience, from the deepest joy to the worst pain, exists as a fragmented echo of something far beyond comprehension? What if death, instead of being an end, is waking up to whatever real — or worse — awaits us?

I’ll admit, this sounds bleak. But stay with me here. The idea has haunted philosophers, writers, mystics, and even religious thinkers for centuries. And the more I think about it, the more it makes a discomforting kind of sense. Let’s dive into this.

The Game of Suffering

Start with this: why is suffering so intertwined with existence? Look around. Sure, sunsets are beautiful, love is transformative, and moments of connection can feel divine — but suffering is everywhere. Pain, loss, war, sickness — they stalk every corner of life. Hell is often imagined as a realm of eternal suffering. What if…this existence is softly camouflaged by beauty to keep us distracted from the fact that we are already in it?

In Dante’s Inferno, there’s a quote that chills me: “Midway upon the journey of our life, I found myself in a dark forest, for the straightforward path had been lost.” It almost feels autobiographical every time I think about life. You know, that sense of being adrift, unsure of the next step, bracing for the next terrible event? It’s the way suffering sneaks up unexpectedly, hitting harder when you least expect it. What if this constant imbalance — this agony wrapped in shreds of bliss — is the punishment?

The Buddhist tradition has a fascinating word for this: Samsara. It’s not explicitly hell, but the cycle of birth, life, death, and rebirth that keeps us trapped in suffering. If existence is karma in motion, constantly cycling, maybe this dream — this life — is us playing out consequences for something we can’t even remember.

Are We Just Dreaming?

Then there’s the concept of a cosmic dream. What if this is all just a fleeting illusion? I’ve got chills just typing that thought. The Hindu Upanishads flirt with the idea of the world being but a dream of Brahman, the divine source of all existence. They invoke the cosmic being dreaming this play we call life, where all events, people, and realities are imagined. If that’s the case, we’re not even the authors of our own misery — the nightmare belongs to some deeply slumbering force far beyond us. And if it’s their dream, are we powerless?

René Descartes, the great philosopher, once doubted everything he could perceive and coined, “Cogito, ergo sum” (I think, therefore I am) — but does thinking really provide evidence for existing? What’s physical is tricky enough to trust, but what if consciousness itself is just part of the dream, our awareness floating in something unspeakably dark? The Greek philosopher Zeno believed reality was an illusion. While his paradoxes dealt with motion, the deeper implication is profound — what if we seem to move forward, but the experiences here aren’t even real?

At this moment as I write, I wonder: is my reality already crumbling? How would I even know the difference if I woke up tomorrow into yet another dream, or, worse, into the bleak coldness of not-dreaming?

Religious Questions of the Soul

From a Christian lens, the idea of living in hell is unthinkable, but not entirely foreign. The Bible warns, “For we wrestle not against flesh and blood, but against…spiritual wickedness in high places” (Ephesians 6:12). Spiritual battles are real, suggesting a tension between the mortal coil and another dimension. Could it be…this is the battlefield? Some religious thinkers (like the mystic Saint John of the Cross) have referred to the “dark night of the soul,” a stage of despair so profound and isolating that it feels like wandering through God’s absence. Isn’t that what hell sounds like? A world where we are perpetually searching — reaching — but somehow always cut off from the divine?

And yet, if we’re dreaming, religious doctrine creates an eerie tension. Both Islam and Christianity describe judgment. In Luke 16, hell is vividly described through the story of the rich man and Lazarus, where torment is constant and unrelenting. Is life any different? Disease takes the healthy; injustice thrives; heartbreak lingers. Could this be punishment for some forgotten, primordial sin? I shudder to think — what if we’ve already been judged, and this “life” is our sentencing?

The Literature of Discontent

I can’t shake how well the world echoes this idea in literature. William Blake wrote, “The mind is its own place, and in itself can make a Heaven of Hell, a Hell of Heaven.” Isn’t that what we do every day? Waking up, convincing ourselves this endless cycle of working-living-loving-losing has meaning, or at least purpose? What if that purpose is the cruelest lie of all?

Franz Kafka’s The Trial and The Metamorphosis also hit hard for me in this context. Kafka’s protagonists are trapped in systems they don’t understand, yet are forced to participate in. We’re not so different. Whether we agree with society or not, the trap is constant — work to live, live to die, perpetuate the system. It’s absurd. It’s Kafkaesque. It’s, dare I say, hellish.

And let’s not forget Jean-Paul Sartre, who cut straight to the bone: “Hell is other people.” I feel that deeply — don’t you? Relationships can be tormenting, their entanglements sharp and suffocating. Yet they’re also what we cling to. Is hell the push-pull of connection in a world designed to keep us hurting?

Waking Up — Or Just Falling Deeper?

But here’s the thing: if this is a dream, who is dreaming it? And if it’s hell, is there an escape? Different spiritual ideas claim ascension — a way out. Buddhists chase Nirvana, a stillness that dissolves existence entirely. Christianity speaks of salvation, where belief and repentance lead to heaven. Even the Gnostics, long-ago outcasts of Christian theology, believed this material world was flawed, even damning, a prison forged imperfectly by a lesser god. They spoke of gnosis, or spiritual knowledge, as the key to awakening to a divine reality beyond the illusion.

In my darker moments, I wonder: what if the idea of escape itself is part of hell’s design? What if every fleeting sense of hope is just the dream’s sadistic way of keeping us running in circles?

But maybe not. Maybe dreaming isn’t inherently bad. After all, dreams are dynamic. They can change. If this is hell, maybe lucidity — the awareness inside the dream — is the key. Something as simple as recognizing we are dreaming might shatter the illusion entirely. The philosopher Alan Watts once said, “Waking up to who you are requires letting go of who you imagine yourself to be.” What if hell isn’t escapable through a ladder or a door, but by letting go…absolutely, entirely? What if we just stop participating in the nightmare?

The Final Question

If this life is a dream and a certain kind of hell, should it change the way we live it? I want to say “yes,” but part of me hesitates. Knowing or suspecting doesn’t mean I understand how to act decisively. Maybe that’s also the trap — the “What If” constantly circling but never resolving. For now, I lay awake some nights, questioning everything, stretched between terror and fascination.

And honestly? Part of me hopes to wake up someday. Part of me hopes this is hell, because at least if it is…there’s something better out there waiting, even if it’s on the other side of suffering. I’ll take that hope — barely steady, barely lit — because what else is there?

What if this really is all just a dream? Or worse, what if it isn’t?

Read more at shownd.com.