Horror logo

The Turn of the Screw: Henry James’ Masterpiece of Psychological Terror

Is the Governess Haunted—Or Haunting Herself? The Enduring Mystery of Literature’s Most Debated Ghost Story

By Silas BlackwoodPublished 8 months ago 3 min read
The Turn of the Screw: Henry James’ Masterpiece of Psychological Terror
Photo by Jeffrey Grospe on Unsplash

Like no other ghost story, The Turn of the Screw has divided readers, academics, and critics ever since it was published in 1898. A young governess at Bly Manor is tasked with caring for two seemingly perfect children in this chilling novella by Henry James. However, she encounters apparitions that may or may not be real. But are these ghosts really there, or are they just the deteriorating psyche of the governess? The Turn of the Screw is one of the Gothic literature works that has received the most research due to its ambiguity, which has sparked debate for more than a century. The novel's enduring power, psychological complexity, and the reasons for its terrors' continued potency are the subject of this article.

1. The Plot: Two ghosts, two children, and a governess Miles and Flora, orphaned siblings living at the remote Bly Manor, are taken care of by a young, inexperienced governess. The children's sole guardian, their charming uncle, tells her one thing: no matter what, she must never talk to him about the children. The governess begins to see figures as soon as she arrives: Peter Quint, the former valet of the manor (now deceased). The previous governess, Miss Jessel (also deceased). She becomes convinced that the children, who appear to be innocent but exhibit eerie, knowing behavior, are being corrupted by these ghosts. Miles's death is the novella's climax; however, was he killed by Quint's ghost or the governess's own hysteria?

2. The Most Important Concern: Do the Ghosts Exist? The Interpretation of the Supernatural The children are secretly communicating with the ghosts, who are real. In life, Quint and Jessel were abusive, and in death, they continue to be corrupt. The governess is a brave protector fighting evil.
Evidence:
Mrs., the housekeeper, Grose makes the appearances of Quint and Jessel official. The fact that Flora knows where Jessel is puts Flora in a supernatural position. The psychological explanation for it The governess's repressed sexuality and paranoia are the source of the ghosts, which are hallucinations. Miles and Flora are regular kids who are caught up in her fantasies. The governess is unreliable and possibly insane as a narrator. Evidence:
After she describes the ghosts, nobody else sees them. Sexual repression in the Victorian era is mirrored in her obsession with purity. Miles' last remark, "Peter Quint—you devil!," could accuse her, the ghost could not. Why the Uncertainty Works James intentionally leaves the truth unanswered, requiring readers to consider: Ghosts or the mind that creates them? Which is scarier? In horror, can any first-person narrator be trusted?

3. Gothic Symbolism and Contemporary Psychology Classical Features of Gothic The Haunted House: The grandeur of Bly Manor conceals its secrets. Miles and Flora's precociousness feels out of place in The Innocents in Peril. The Isolated Setting: The governess's reality is distorted because she is cut off from society. Inflections of Freud (Before Freud!) The novella, written years before psychoanalysis became popular, anticipates: Repressed Desire: The governess's obsession with Quint, a figure who is sexually aggressive. Projection: Her worries about the kids might be a reflection of her own irrational desires. The Strange: The ghosts look like her in distorted form.

4. From Stage to Screen, Adaptations The Innocents, a movie from 1961 Deborah Kerr stars in the definitive adaptation. blurs reality through sound design and cinematography. strongly suggests the madness of the governess. The Turning, a 2020 movie a contemporary take that divides people and has a hazy conclusion. focuses less on ghosts and more on psychological horror. Opera and Stage The eerie atmosphere of the story is heightened by Benjamin Britten's opera from 1954. Immersive, unreliable storytelling has been used in recent theatrical productions.

5. Inspirations from Actual Life The Ghost of Cheltenham a known instance of a woman experiencing a hallucination of sleep paralysis after seeing a ghostly figure in her home. James probably knew about it. Fears the Victorian Governess Governesses had no family or servants, so they held a vulnerable social position. Culture was fascinated by tales of governesses going insane.

6. Why It Still Hurts to Turn the Screw

A. The Uncertainty Horror More terrifying than any monster is the inability to determine the truth.

B. Innocence's corrupting influence On a fundamental level, the idea that children might be complicit in evil disturbs.

C. The Untrustworthy Narrator The governess's account prompts us to consider the following: Is anyone's perception reliable?

artbook reviewscelebritiesfictionhalloweenhow tointerviewmonstermovie reviewpop culturepsychologicalslashersupernaturalvintageurban legend

About the Creator

Silas Blackwood

Reader insights

Be the first to share your insights about this piece.

How does it work?

Add your insights

Comments

There are no comments for this story

Be the first to respond and start the conversation.

Sign in to comment

    Find us on social media

    Miscellaneous links

    • Explore
    • Contact
    • Privacy Policy
    • Terms of Use
    • Support

    © 2026 Creatd, Inc. All Rights Reserved.