The Slayer (a.k.a. Nightmare Island)

The Slayer is a 1982 independent horror and slasher film that unfolds with a sluggish, almost interminable pace, drawing viewers into its unsettling atmosphere. The plot revolves around two couples who travel to a remote island after one of the women, Kay (Sarah Kendal), begins experiencing terrifying and vivid dreams. Her visions are filled with demonic hands, eerie landscapes, and ominous buildings that she obsessively paints, blurring the line between her nightmares and reality. These dreams serve as a harbinger of the horrors to come, setting a foreboding tone that permeates the film.

Upon arriving on the island, the group encounters a creepy private pilot ("Marsh," played by Michael Holmes) who delivers an ominous warning about the island’s dark history. This character functions as a mythological "gatekeeper," similar to "Crazy Ralph" (Walt Gorney) in Friday the 13th (1980). His warning marks the transition from the normal world into the dangerous, unknown territory where the true horrors of the story will unfold. It’s a classic horror trope that signals the presence of lurking monsters and impending doom.

As the story progresses, the film adopts a weird, slow-moving, and dreamlike quality that deepens its eerie atmosphere. Kay begins to recognize the island’s buildings and landscapes from her nightmares, intensifying her sense of detachment and disorientation. This surreal detachment is palpable; Kay seems trapped in a waking dream, drifting through a reality that feels increasingly unreal. Her mental state deteriorates as she becomes unhinged, struggling to differentiate between dream and reality.

The tension escalates when Kay’s husband, David (Alan McRae), mysteriously disappears. His fate remains a mystery to the other characters—Kay, her brother Eric (Frederick Flynn), and their friend Brooke (Carol Kottenbrooke)—but the audience is given glimpses of his grim end. Kay’s disturbing dreams about David’s fate grow more vivid and terrifying, driving the group to search the island as a looming hurricane adds to the sense of impending disaster. Throughout this ordeal, Kay feels the presence of an invasive force, further pushing her towards madness.

The film builds to a night of murder and possibly supernatural menace, culminating in Kay barricading herself in a house, desperate to survive. However, rather than providing clear answers, the climax spirals into a series of ambiguities that leave viewers with more questions than answers. Some critics have lauded these ambiguities as "masterful," especially considering the film’s low-budget origins. Despite borrowing heavily from Friday the 13th—with its isolated setting, gruesome killings, and splashes of stage blood—The Slayer offers surprisingly few gory shocks, favoring a more psychological approach to horror. Those expecting a splattery, Grand Guignol-style experience may find the film’s restrained violence disappointing.

The film’s ending is deliberately unresolved, leaving the viewer to grapple with multiple interpretations. Is Kay the unwitting monster of her nightmares, or is there a supernatural menace at work? The conclusion is shrouded in mystery, with the film’s dreamlike surreality lingering long after the credits roll. How many layers of meaning are buried within its ambiguous ending, and what is the ultimate truth? That’s left for the viewer to decide.

On the surface, The Slayer might appear to be just another cheap exploitation flick. But to dismiss it as such would be to overlook its intriguing subtext of mental fugue and the suggestion of shifting realities. The film skillfully employs an unreliable narrative technique, reminiscent of Edgar Allan Poe’s gothic tales, to elevate what could have been a pedestrian horror flick into something bold, dreamlike, and uniquely unsettling. While The Slayer may not deliver the visceral thrills expected of an early '80s slasher, it succeeds in crafting an eerie, atmospheric experience that lingers in the mind, inviting viewers to explore its depths long after the final scene.

***

Connect with me on Facebook