Horror logo

The Disappearance at Pine Lake

They are watching

By Tales by J.J.Published about a year ago 5 min read
The Disappearance at Pine Lake
Photo by Matt Hardy on Unsplash

It was a cold, foggy evening when Sarah stepped out of her car, the dense mist swirling around her feet as she approached the old cabin by Pine Lake. She had received a cryptic letter the previous week, a single sentence that sent chills down her spine: "They are watching, and you are next."

Determined to uncover the truth, Sarah had spent days researching the cabin, once owned by her great-uncle, a reclusive man who vanished mysteriously two decades ago. Rumors of strange occurrences and unexplained phenomena had shrouded Pine Lake in an eerie mystique, but Sarah was resolute.

Inside the cabin, cobwebs clung to every surface, and the air was thick with the scent of decay. She found a dusty diary hidden under a loose floorboard, its pages filled with unsettling accounts of shadowy figures and inexplicable events. As she flipped through the brittle pages, she noticed one entry dated the night before her great-uncle's disappearance: "They're closer than ever. I fear my time is running out."

Suddenly, a faint sound echoed through the cabin, like footsteps on the creaky floorboards. Sarah's heart raced as she turned to face the source, only to see the door slowly creaking open. She reached for a rusted lantern and lit it, casting a dim, flickering light across the room.

A shadowy figure stood in the doorway, eyes gleaming with malevolence. "Who are you?" Sarah demanded, her voice trembling.

The figure stepped forward, revealing a familiar face twisted in fear. It was her great-uncle, unchanged by time, as if he had stepped out of the past. "You must leave this place," he whispered urgently. "They are still here, and they won't let you go."

Before Sarah could respond, the air grew colder, and an unearthly howl filled the cabin. The lantern flickered and died, plunging the room into darkness. She felt a hand grasp her wrist, pulling her toward the door. "Run!" her great-uncle shouted, his voice echoing in the blackness.

Sarah stumbled through the cabin, her breath coming in ragged gasps as she fled into the night. The shadows seemed to follow her, whispering her name with every step. She reached the edge of the lake, her reflection shimmering in the moonlight. There, she found an old rowboat, hidden among the reeds.

With trembling hands, she pushed the boat into the water and began to row, the murky depths of Pine Lake swallowing the sound of her escape. As she glanced back at the cabin, she saw the shadowy figures gathered on the shore, watching her with unblinking eyes.

The truth about Pine Lake remained a mystery, but Sarah had escaped with her life, her great-uncle's warning echoing in her mind. She knew that the shadows would always be there, lurking in the dark corners of her memory.

And somewhere, in the depths of Pine Lake, they continued to watch, waiting for their next victim.

Weeks passed since Sarah's escape from Pine Lake, but she couldn’t shake the eerie feeling that had gripped her that night. The shadows of the lake seemed to follow her in her dreams, whispering her name and urging her back. Determined to uncover the truth behind her great-uncle's disappearance and the haunting figures, she returned to the village with a group of friends who were eager to solve the mystery.

As they approached the cabin, the once-familiar terrain now felt alien and threatening. The cabin itself stood as a dilapidated relic, its windows like eyes watching their every move. Sarah and her friends hesitated at the doorstep, but the need for answers propelled them forward.

Inside, the cabin was eerily silent, the air thick with the scent of decay. They lit their lanterns, casting long, dancing shadows on the walls. Sarah felt a chill run down her spine as she approached the hidden diary, the pages now crumbling and barely legible.

“Look at this,” whispered Emily, one of Sarah's friends, pointing to a peculiar symbol etched into the wooden floor. The symbol seemed to pulse with an otherworldly energy. Sarah recognized it from her great-uncle’s diary, a mark that appeared on the night he disappeared.

Suddenly, a cold gust of wind extinguished their lanterns, plunging the cabin into darkness. The door creaked open, and the room filled with an unearthly howl. Heartbeats racing, Sarah and her friends huddled together as the temperature dropped even further, their breaths visible in the frigid air.

The shadows in the cabin began to take shape, forming into the figures Sarah had seen before. Eyes glowing with an eerie light, the figures circled them, whispering in a language that was both ancient and sinister.

“You shouldn’t have come back,” a voice echoed, seemingly from everywhere at once. Sarah recognized it—it was her great-uncle’s voice, but twisted with pain and fear.

“We need to understand,” Sarah shouted into the darkness. “What happened here?”

The shadows surged forward, and the cabin seemed to warp around them. Sarah felt herself being pulled into a vision, a window into the past. She saw her great-uncle standing in the cabin, frantically writing in his diary. The shadowy figures loomed closer, their whispers growing louder. He turned to face them, his eyes wide with terror, before everything went black.

Sarah gasped as she was snapped back to the present. Her friends were still huddled close, their faces pale with fear. “We need to leave, now!” Emily urged.

But Sarah knew they couldn’t leave without confronting the source of the evil. “We have to finish this,” she insisted, her voice trembling but resolute.

Drawing upon the wisdom from her great-uncle’s diary, Sarah began to chant an incantation, her words mingling with the whispers of the shadows. The air grew heavier, and the shadowy figures recoiled, their shapes flickering like candle flames in a strong wind.

The cabin shook violently, and the floor beneath them seemed to open into a void. Sarah’s voice grew louder, more confident, as she continued the chant. The shadows let out a collective wail, their forms disintegrating into the air.

As the last of the shadows vanished, the cabin fell silent. The air warmed, and the oppressive feeling lifted. Sarah and her friends stood in stunned silence, the gravity of what they had just witnessed sinking in.

“We did it,” Sarah whispered, her voice barely audible. “We freed them.”

With the cabin’s secret now laid to rest, Sarah and her friends made their way back to the village, the dawn’s light breaking through the trees. Though the shadows of Pine Lake no longer haunted her, Sarah knew that the memories of that night would stay with her forever—a reminder of the courage it takes to face the darkness within and around us.

artfictionhalloweenmonsterpsychologicalslashersupernaturaltravelurban legendvintage

About the Creator

Tales by J.J.

Weaving tales of love, heartbreak, and connection, I explore the beauty of human emotions.

My stories aim to resonate with every heart, reminding us of love’s power to transform and heal.

Join me on a journey where words connect us all.

Reader insights

Nice work

Very well written. Keep up the good work!

Top insights

  1. Compelling and original writing

    Creative use of language & vocab

  2. Easy to read and follow

    Well-structured & engaging content

  3. Excellent storytelling

    Original narrative & well developed characters

  1. Expert insights and opinions

    Arguments were carefully researched and presented

  2. Heartfelt and relatable

    The story invoked strong personal emotions

  3. On-point and relevant

    Writing reflected the title & theme

Add your insights

Comments (2)

Sign in to comment
  • Judey Kalchik about a year ago

    This is an unattributed AI story. That is against Vocal standards and has been reported. Your spammed comments on Top Stories have also been reported. It would be best for you to delete them asap

  • Maryam Batoolabout a year ago

    I actually felt like I was watching a movie. Every step was like another foot toward the dark mystery. Sarah's character is a strong one. I loved the way you wrote the horror story. I'm amazed that you can write so well, with the best possible vocabulary 🤝❤

Find us on social media

Miscellaneous links

  • Explore
  • Contact
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use
  • Support

© 2026 Creatd, Inc. All Rights Reserved.