Horror logo

The Depths of Stillwater Lake

HORROR LAKE

By Ayushi MehraPublished about a year ago 5 min read

In the small town of Gray Hollow, nestled deep in the shadow of a dense forest, there existed a lake that no one dared approach. Stillwater Lake, they called it, though the name belied its ominous reputation. To the locals, it was a place of dread—a place that swallowed the unwary and echoed with the whispers of the lost. They spoke of it in hushed tones, telling stories of the cursed water and the strange happenings that occurred around it. Few believed the stories fully, but fewer still were brave enough to test their veracity.

It was said that on certain nights, when the moon hung low and the fog clung to the ground like a shroud, figures could be seen moving just beneath the lake’s surface—shadowy forms that glided through the water as though searching for something. Those who strayed too close claimed to hear voices—faint, pleading voices—calling to them from the water, beckoning them to come closer. Those who answered never returned.

---

Elena stood at the edge of the lake, her breath clouding the cold night air. The fog was thicker than she had anticipated, swirling in low, eerie waves around her legs. She could barely see the dark waters of the lake through it, but she could feel the weight of its presence, the oppressive silence pressing in on her like a living thing.

"Are you sure about this?" Ethan’s voice trembled slightly as he stepped up behind her, the beam of his flashlight flickering nervously across the mist.

"We have to," Elena said, her voice firm despite the unease crawling up her spine. "They’ll never stop until we find out what happened to them."

It had been six months since their friends, Rachel and Connor, had disappeared without a trace. The last place anyone had seen them was here, near Stillwater Lake. Elena knew the stories, had grown up hearing the warnings, but she couldn't believe that something supernatural had taken them. There had to be a logical explanation.

"You know the stories, Elena," Ethan muttered, glancing nervously over his shoulder as if expecting something to leap from the fog. "People don’t just vanish without a reason. This place... it’s cursed."

"Curses don’t exist," Elena snapped, more to convince herself than him. "We’re going to find some clue, something the police missed."

They had come armed with flashlights, a camera, and a healthy dose of skepticism. Yet now, standing here on the shore of Stillwater Lake, the weight of those old tales pressed heavy on their minds. The wind had died down completely, leaving an unsettling stillness in the air. Even the usual sounds of the forest—crickets, owls, the rustling of leaves—were absent. It was as though the world around them had fallen into a deep, unnatural silence.

Ethan shuddered, rubbing his arms. "Let’s get this over with."

They moved cautiously along the shoreline, their flashlights cutting weak beams through the fog. The lake’s surface, normally a calm mirror, seemed to ripple faintly, as though disturbed by something unseen. Elena felt a chill run down her spine. Something was off, but she couldn't put her finger on it.

They reached the dock where Rachel and Connor had last been seen. The old wood groaned under their weight as they stepped onto it, the sound unnervingly loud in the otherwise quiet night. Elena knelt down, running her hand along the damp, weathered boards.

"Look." Ethan’s voice was a strained whisper.

Elena looked up and followed the beam of his flashlight. There, at the end of the dock, was something that hadn’t been there before—a small, delicate object, glinting faintly in the moonlight. She moved closer and her heart clenched in her chest.

It was Rachel’s bracelet, half-submerged in the water, its tiny charms catching the light. Elena’s mind raced. How had this gone unnoticed before? The police had scoured the area. Had someone placed it there recently?

As she reached out to pick it up, a cold wind suddenly blew across the lake, chilling her to the bone. The fog thickened, swirling like smoke, and a low sound drifted across the water—soft, distant, like a whisper carried on the breeze.

"Ethan, did you hear that?" Elena’s voice was barely more than a breath.

He nodded, his eyes wide. "It’s coming from the lake."

They both turned their flashlights toward the water, and that’s when they saw it—movement beneath the surface. It was subtle at first, just a faint distortion in the water. But then the ripples grew, swirling outward as though something was rising from the depths. Elena’s breath caught in her throat as she saw it—a pale face just beneath the surface, eyes wide and staring, mouth open in a silent scream.

She stumbled back, her heart pounding in her chest. "What the hell is that?!"

Before Ethan could respond, the water exploded. Dark, wet hands shot up from the lake, dripping and rotten, fingers like claws reaching for them. Ethan screamed, yanking Elena back as the hands grasped at the edge of the dock, pulling something with them.

It was a figure—a woman, or what had once been a woman. Her skin was pale and bloated, her eyes sunken deep into her skull, her hair tangled and wet. She dragged herself up onto the dock, her lips moving, but no sound came out. Her eyes locked onto Elena, hollow and pleading.

"Run!" Ethan shouted, pulling Elena toward the shore.

They bolted, feet pounding against the wood as more figures began to rise from the lake, their decayed bodies emerging from the black water. The whispers grew louder, overlapping voices calling out, begging for help, for release.

Elena’s mind raced as they fled through the fog. The stories were true. The lake was cursed, and those who had disappeared had not simply vanished—they had been claimed by the water. But why? What did it want? And why was it trying to pull them in now?

They didn’t stop running until they reached the edge of the forest, where the fog began to thin. Ethan bent over, hands on his knees, gasping for breath. Elena turned back toward the lake, her heart still racing, her mind struggling to comprehend what she had just seen.

The figures were gone, the lake once again calm and still. But she knew better now. It wasn’t over. Whatever haunted that lake, whatever force had taken Rachel and Connor, was still there, waiting.

"Elena..." Ethan’s voice was shaky. "We have to tell someone. We can’t let anyone else go near that place."

She nodded, her hands trembling as she clutched Rachel’s bracelet. But deep down, she knew the truth. Stillwater Lake wasn’t just haunted—it was hungry. And it would never stop until it had claimed them all.

The whispers from the lake echoed in her ears, even as they retreated into the safety of the forest. It wasn’t over. Not yet.

Stillwater Lake was patient. It had all the time in the world.

supernatural

About the Creator

Ayushi Mehra

Hello everyone, I want to express my heartfelt gratitude for taking the time to read my stories. Your opinions, thoughts, and suggestions are incredibly valuable to me, and I would be honored if you considered joining my community.

Reader insights

Be the first to share your insights about this piece.

How does it work?

Add your insights

Comments

There are no comments for this story

Be the first to respond and start the conversation.

Sign in to comment

    Find us on social media

    Miscellaneous links

    • Explore
    • Contact
    • Privacy Policy
    • Terms of Use
    • Support

    © 2026 Creatd, Inc. All Rights Reserved.