What Happened to Evan Wheeler: The Old Barn

Part 6

“What are you talking about?” I tried to act as if nothing happened, but he saw right through the act.

“Evan, I already know all about you and your family. My family lived a few houses down when you killed your family. I told the police that you were with Flynn that morning, so when Jemarie said that you poisoned the cake they ate, it made the police believe everything you had been trying to tell them when your parents were alive.” Josh explained quickly.

The scar on his face looked familiar, but I don’t remember ever seeing him. I looked around cautiously.

“If you’re coming, then let’s go. I have to get rid of her before she starts to smell.”

He jumped into the car and we sped off.

“Thanks for helping me when that happened, but why did you move to the other end of the city? Was it because of me?” I was so confused.

“No,” Josh shook his head “I moved there eleven years ago. My wife and I bought the house together and she ended up passing away right after we moved in. I wasn’t expecting you to move across the street.” He laughed a little, but I could tell it wasn’t something I should press him about. I nodded my head and he changed the subject.

“Are you going to have to move again?”

“No. Everyone here knows me as Cameron Miller. There’s no need to go anywhere again.” I shook my head. We got out of the car and I grabbed two bags. Josh grabbed two more and we went in opposite directions. It smelled really bad, but I knew that I needed to go as far out as I could and put the bags in different areas. It was dark, and I couldn’t see anything. I knew we had to move fast because there’s a guy that comes through here with a flashlight every half hour to make sure there are no people sleeping.

I put one bag down and push it down into the rest of the trash that was everywhere. I walked out a little more and did the same thing with the other bag before turning around. I walked back to the car, and thought about what I would do with the other three bags. I didn’t think it was safe to have the whole body in the same place. Four bags was more than enough. When I got to my car, Josh was already leaning against it.

“There’s a farm not too far from here. We can take the rest of her there and give her to the pigs.”

I nodded and we headed towards the farm. Luckily, I knew what he was talking about. We used to have bonfires there before Madison and I got married. It was maybe five minutes away from the landfill, but it was far enough away so that you couldn’t smell all the trash. I parked at the end of the driveway, and we jumped out. I wanted to get this over with because I was a little nervous about her being dead for a second time. If the poison in the cake would have worked I wouldn’t need to do all of this.

“Don’t try to bitch out now Evan,” Josh was quiet, but just barely loud enough for me to hear him. We walked to the barn, and no one was there. The pigs were in their sty. I lead two of them to the mud pit and emptied the last three bags out into the mud. Immediately, they started to eat and I sat there with them. After I was sure that the parts were gone, we left. I made sure to lead the pigs back to their sty and then Josh and I went home. After maybe twenty minutes of driving, I pulled into my driveway.

“I checked the head and Madison pulled the teeth so there's no way she’ll be identifiable. The landfill also floods pretty often around this time of year so she’ll decompose faster.”

“How do you know that?”

“I killed Adam Browning when we were kids.”

“I thought he went to Virginia with his grandparents?” I was so confused.

“Nope, he was eaten by those pigs.” There were no emotions in Josh’s eyes and I could tell that he wasn’t lying.

I opened my mouth to say something, and then I saw the porch light turn on. Madison was sitting on the porch.

“Are you going to sit around and become besties or are you going to help me finish cleaning this?”

I nodded at Josh and walked into the house. As soon as I walked into the house Madison screams.

“I think my water just broke.”