Fiction logo

The Stranger in the Mirror

A Story of Identity

By Oluseyi SogaoluPublished about a year ago 4 min read
The Stranger in the Mirror
Photo by Kenny Eliason on Unsplash

In the quiet, sunlit town of Ravenwood, people went about their lives with a predictable calm. The streets were lined with charming cottages, and the rhythms of daily life were gentle. It was the kind of place where everyone knew everyone, and secrets were rare. But beneath the surface of this idyllic existence lay a mystery that would unravel the life of one unsuspecting resident.

Emily Carter was a young woman with a simple, contented life. She worked as a librarian at the local library, a job she loved for its quiet charm and the endless rows of books that seemed to whisper stories from every era. Her life was filled with the comforting routine of organizing books, helping patrons, and the occasional chat over coffee with her close-knit group of friends.

One brisk autumn afternoon, while Emily was dusting off old volumes in the library’s basement storage, she discovered an old, ornate mirror hidden behind a stack of forgotten boxes. The mirror’s frame was a masterpiece of intricate woodwork, adorned with elaborate patterns that hinted at a bygone era. Curious, Emily decided to take it home, thinking it might make an interesting addition to her cozy apartment.

The moment Emily placed the mirror in her bedroom, she felt a subtle shift in the air. The mirror seemed to hold a depth that was both intriguing and unsettling. She brushed off the odd feeling and went about her evening routine, trying to ignore the sense of unease that had settled over her.

That night, as she prepared for bed, Emily glanced at the mirror. In the dim light, she noticed something strange—her reflection seemed slightly off. It was subtle but unmistakable. Her reflection’s eyes seemed to be looking at her with an intensity that felt foreign. Emily shook off the feeling, attributing it to fatigue, and went to sleep.

Over the next few days, Emily began to notice more peculiarities. Her reflection appeared to move independently at times, mirroring her actions with a slight delay or in unexpected ways. It was as though the mirror’s surface had become a portal to another version of herself, one that was just a step behind, yet somehow more aware.

One evening, as Emily prepared dinner, she caught sight of her reflection in the mirror. To her horror, she saw a figure standing behind her—someone who looked exactly like her but with an unsettling, almost malevolent expression. She spun around, but the room was empty. The reflection vanished, leaving her breathless and shaking.

Determined to understand what was happening, Emily began researching the mirror. She discovered that it was an antique, crafted by a long-forgotten artisan known for creating mirrors with extraordinary properties. Legend had it that these mirrors could reflect not only the physical self but also the hidden facets of one's identity—both the good and the dark.

As she delved deeper into the mirror’s history, Emily learned of stories about people who had encountered their own darker selves through these reflections. These reflections were said to be a manifestation of hidden fears, unresolved issues, or suppressed desires. Emily began to realize that her own reflection was not merely an image but a part of her—one that had been buried and now sought to emerge.

The more she examined the mirror, the more she saw in her reflection—the suppressed fears and insecurities she had hidden away. She saw moments of self-doubt, past regrets, and unspoken desires. The reflection seemed to be confronting her with these aspects of herself, challenging her to acknowledge and confront them.

One night, the reflection spoke to her. Emily stood before the mirror, her heart racing, as the reflection's lips moved, forming words she could not initially understand. As the voice became clearer, it spoke of her deepest fears and desires, of the parts of herself she had avoided facing. It was as though the mirror was urging her to accept these aspects, to reconcile with the parts of herself she had denied.

In a moment of clarity, Emily understood that the mirror was not a malevolent force but a tool for self-discovery. It was showing her the parts of herself that needed healing and acceptance. The reflection, though unnerving, was a mirror to her inner self, revealing truths she had kept hidden.

Determined to confront her fears, Emily spent the next few weeks reflecting on her past, facing her regrets, and addressing her insecurities. She began to embrace the parts of herself she had once rejected, finding strength in acknowledging her vulnerabilities and desires.

Gradually, the reflection in the mirror began to change. The malevolent expression softened, and the reflection’s eyes were filled with understanding and empathy. It was as though the mirror had guided her through a journey of self-acceptance and personal growth.

One evening, as Emily stood before the mirror, she saw her reflection smiling warmly. It was no longer a stranger but a part of herself she had come to understand and accept. The mirror had fulfilled its purpose, revealing not a dark, hidden version of herself, but a deeper understanding of who she truly was.

With a newfound sense of peace, Emily decided to keep the mirror, not as an object of fear, but as a reminder of the journey she had undertaken. The mirror, once a source of unease, had become a symbol of self-discovery and growth.

In the quiet town of Ravenwood, Emily continued her life with a renewed sense of purpose. The mirror remained a cherished part of her home, reflecting not only her image but the journey she had taken to find and embrace her true self.

Psychological

About the Creator

Reader insights

Be the first to share your insights about this piece.

How does it work?

Add your insights

Comments

There are no comments for this story

Be the first to respond and start the conversation.

Sign in to comment

    Find us on social media

    Miscellaneous links

    • Explore
    • Contact
    • Privacy Policy
    • Terms of Use
    • Support

    © 2026 Creatd, Inc. All Rights Reserved.