Fiction logo

Never Do These Six Things on Your First Date

How One Coffee Meeting Turned Into a Lifetime Lesson in Love and Human Behavior

By noor ul aminPublished 3 months ago 7 min read
Never Do These Six Things on Your First Date
Photo by Jonathan J. Castellon on Unsplash

The late-afternoon sunlight slanted through the glass windows of Bean & Brew Café, painting golden streaks across the wooden tables. The café hummed with quiet chatter—the rustling of newspapers, the hiss of the espresso machine, the occasional laughter drifting from nearby tables.

For most people, it was just another Saturday. For Amir, it felt like the beginning of something big.

He tugged at the cuffs of his shirt, checked his watch for the third time, and drummed his fingers nervously on the table. His heartbeat was uneven, fluttering between hope and dread.

Because today… he was meeting Sara

Not just meeting—meeting *in person*.

They had been talking for weeks after matching on a book discussion group online. What started as a casual exchange about favorite authors quickly grew into late-night conversations about childhood dreams, failures, fears, and ambitions. Amir thought he already knew her, but there’s always that jump from digital comfort to real-world uncertainty.

And in that jump, people either soar—or stumble.

Amir was about to stumble hard.

---

The Entrance: Lesson One

Sara arrived on time, her presence lighting up the room in a way Amir hadn’t expected. She wasn’t glamorous in the exaggerated sense, but there was something about her ease—the way she tucked her hair behind her ear, the smile she offered the barista, the calm way she scanned the café—that made her stand out.

Amir, however, was not there to see it.

At 3:00 p.m., the time they had agreed, his chair was empty.

At 3:05, Sara checked her phone, wondering if she had gotten the place wrong.

At 3:10, she ordered a latte to keep from feeling like someone abandoned at a table.

At 3:15, Amir rushed in, cheeks flushed, tie askew, his bag half-open like a man who had fought with both traffic and his own nerves.

“Sorry, sorry, sorry,” he panted, collapsing into the chair. “You won’t believe the traffic.”

Sara smiled politely, but inwardly she thought: *You knew traffic would exist. Why didn’t you plan for it?*

It wasn’t the lateness that hurt—it was the lack of effort. He hadn’t sent her a message. He hadn’t called. He had just shown up late, expecting forgiveness.

Lesson One: Never arrive late without a reason—or without respect.

---

The Monologue: Lesson Two

After they exchanged pleasantries, the waiter arrived with menus. Amir waved him off, announcing confidently, “I already know what I want.” Sara smiled, still browsing the list.

That small moment revealed a lot: Amir always liked to appear in control.

Once their orders were placed, Amir began talking. And talking. And talking.

“So, I work in finance—it’s demanding, but I thrive under pressure, you know? I’m also trying to get into fitness. I hit the gym four times a week. People say I’m disciplined. Oh, and in college, I was really into debate competitions. I actually won the regional one—funny story, I’ll tell you—”

Sara stirred her coffee slowly. At first, she nodded with interest, but twenty minutes later, she had barely spoken five sentences. Her silence wasn’t because she had nothing to say—it was because Amir left her no room to enter.

She wanted to tell him about her art, about the exhibition she was planning, about the way painting felt like breathing to her. But every time she opened her mouth, Amir cut in with another story about himself.

Finally, she interrupted gently:

“Would you like to know something about me, too?”

Amir blinked. For the first time, he realized how one-sided his enthusiasm had been.

Lesson Two: Never talk only about yourself. A date is a dialogue, not a monologue.

---

The Shadow of the Past: Lesson Three

Just as Sara began talking about her artwork—describing how she once painted an entire night sky on her bedroom ceiling—Amir smiled and said the worst thing he could have said:

“That’s so interesting! My ex used to paint too.”

The word *ex* dropped like a stone into the conversation.

Sara’s lips pressed into a thin line. He didn’t notice.

“She wasn’t as serious as you, though,” Amir continued, “but still… she had some talent. Sometimes I’d help her choose colors.”

Sara set her cup down slowly. “I don’t think you should bring her up right now.”

“Oh no, I didn’t mean it like that,” Amir rushed. “I’m just saying you remind me of—”

“Exactly.” Sara’s tone was calm but firm. “I don’t want to be someone’s reminder.”

Amir felt heat creep up his neck. He wished he could take the words back, but it was too late.

Lesson Three: Never compare your date to your ex. Nobody wants to be a shadow of the past.

---

The Pasta Incident: Lesson Four

Food arrived. Amir’s plate of pasta steamed with red sauce, while Sara’s grilled chicken sandwich looked fresh and inviting.

He twirled his fork, took a bite, and immediately grimaced.

“This is way too spicy,” he snapped at the waiter. “Did the chef dump an entire chili jar in this? Do you even know how to cook here?”

The café went quiet for a second. The waiter, flustered but polite, apologized and offered to replace the dish.

Sara’s heart sank. She had worked in restaurants during college, had faced rude customers who forgot servers were human. Watching Amir’s harshness made her feel embarrassed.

She thanked the waiter kindly and tried to shift the mood, but her impression was already sealed.

Kindness isn’t measured in how you treat someone you want to impress—it’s measured in how you treat those you think you’ll never see again.

Lesson Four: Never be rude to the staff. It reveals more about you than you think.

---

The Glow of the Phone: Lesson Five

As they ate, Amir’s phone buzzed. He glanced at it.

Then it buzzed again. He picked it up.

Soon, he was scrolling through notifications, chuckling at memes his friend sent, and even replying to a group chat.

“Sorry, it’s just work stuff,” he muttered, though the smirk on his face betrayed otherwise.

Sara set her sandwich down. She didn’t say anything, but her eyes said it all: *If you’d rather talk to your phone, why invite me?*

The moments that could have been laughter, eye contact, and shared stories were lost in the glow of a screen.

Lesson Five: Never check your phone constantly. Be present, or be elsewhere.

---

The Walk: Lesson Six

After dinner, Sara suggested a walk in the nearby park. The night air was cooler, the city lights glittered like fallen stars, and for a brief moment, it felt like they could reset the day.

They strolled past street performers, small children chasing balloons, couples sitting on benches holding hands. Amir felt a spark of hope return.

But then, he misread the moment.

Without warning, he leaned closer, tilting toward her lips.

Sara pulled back. “Amir,” she said firmly, “let’s take things slow. I’m not ready for that.”

His face flushed with embarrassment. He had been so focused on what *he* wanted that he hadn’t noticed what she wasn’t giving: signals of comfort, signals of consent.

Lesson Six: Never rush intimacy. Respect boundaries—it’s the only foundation trust can grow on.

---

The Goodbye

When they reached the corner where their paths split, Sara thanked him politely.

“It was nice meeting you,” she said, though her tone was distant.

“Yeah, same,” Amir replied, watching her disappear into the crowd.

As he walked home, the evening replayed in his head—each mistake like a neon sign: late, self-absorbed, careless, rude, distracted, pushy.

But in that painful reflection, Amir realized something profound: first dates aren’t just about finding love—they’re about learning who you are when it matters most.

---

The Aftermath: Growth

Weeks later, Sara never replied to Amir’s follow-up texts. He understood why.

But instead of sulking, he wrote down everything he had done wrong, turning them into principles.

The next time he went on a date—with someone else, months later—he arrived early. He asked more questions than he answered. He never mentioned his ex. He tipped the waiter generously. His phone stayed in his pocket. And when the evening ended, he simply said, “I’d love to see you again if you’d like that.”

That second date blossomed into something real.

And it happened because he had learned—painfully, but permanently—that the smallest mistakes can cost the biggest opportunities.

---

Final Takeaway

Never do these six things on your first date:

1. Don’t be late without a reason.Time is respect.

2. Don’t dominate the conversation. Listen as much as you speak.

3. Don’t bring up your ex.** Leave the past in the past.

4. Don’t be rude to staff.Kindness is character.

5. Don’t live in your phone.Be present with the person.

6. Don’t push boundaries. Respect creates trust.

A first date isn’t about being flawless—it’s about being thoughtful, authentic, and kind. Get those right, and love might just follow.

---

Fan FictionLoveHumor

About the Creator

Reader insights

Be the first to share your insights about this piece.

How does it work?

Add your insights

Comments

There are no comments for this story

Be the first to respond and start the conversation.

Sign in to comment

    Find us on social media

    Miscellaneous links

    • Explore
    • Contact
    • Privacy Policy
    • Terms of Use
    • Support

    © 2026 Creatd, Inc. All Rights Reserved.