Fiction logo

Maddie's Best: A Diner of Secrets and Shadows

Maddie's Best: A Diner of Secrets and Shadows

By David C. ConnorPublished 2 years ago 14 min read

The journey up to rural felt like an eternity, as the road stretched on endlessly through the countryside. With Johnny B as my companion in the truck, the ride seemed even longer. He had this uncanny ability never to stop talking, and I'm not exaggerating when I say he could talk your ear off for days without pause. It was as if he had a motor inside his head, constantly churning out stories, complaints, and opinions without a moment's rest.

On this particular day, Johnny B was in one of his most talkative moods. He kept flapping his gums about his wild wife, Mary, and the latest escapades she had dragged him into. He was a master at getting himself into trouble, and it seemed like Mary was always right there, leading the way. He'd nudge me sharply in the ribs, asking for validation on his harebrained schemes, and whether he was right or wrong. But it was no use trying to reason with him, as he was utterly convinced of his infallibility, even though his history suggested otherwise.

As if the incessant chatter wasn't enough, Johnny B had an annoying habit of fiddling with the radio every few minutes, trying to find his favorite rap station. Every time he turned the volume knob up, I felt my patience wearing thin. It was as if he was intentionally trying to test my sanity on this otherwise serene Sunday afternoon.

I yearned for a quiet and peaceful ride, where I could enjoy the scenic views and the serenity of the countryside passing by. But my hopes of finding solace in silence were dashed when the factory called, telling us that a delivery was ready. It meant we had to make a detour to pick up the supplies, even though I was hoping to spend the day undisturbed.

Unfortunately, I couldn't voice my displeasure about the detour because, you guessed it, Johnny B's uncle owned the factory. And he was our boss, which meant we couldn't say a damn word against Johnny B's shenanigans. It was frustrating, but I knew it was a part of the deal if I wanted to keep my job.

As we continued driving down the seemingly endless road, Johnny B couldn't stop complaining about the barren landscape around us. "All these damn trees and dirt, so much dirt," he grumbled, making me wonder why he chose to live in a rural area in the first place. "It's like the world ended," I muttered in response, my annoyance barely contained.

Finally, I spotted a small wooden sign coming up on the left, announcing "Maddie's Best." Johnny B noticed it too and immediately started cracking jokes, "Maddie's best? More like Maddie's pest!" he snorted, elbowing me again, as if his humor was the most entertaining thing in the world.

The road leading to the diner was bumpy and uneven, making me slightly wary of what we might find at the end. But when we arrived at Maddie's Best, I was both surprised and relieved to see a quaint and cozy little diner, like a nostalgic escape to the past. There was no flashy neon sign, just a charming wooden one welcoming visitors inside.

As we stepped through the door, a small bell above it gave a gentle jingle. The atmosphere inside was indeed reminiscent of a bygone era, with a checkered red and white floor, marble countertops, and red stools that surrounded the counter. On the other side of the counter were red booths with more marble tops, creating an inviting and classic diner setting.

The diner's patrons seemed friendly enough, with a few of them nodding or smiling at our entrance. A waitress on roller skates approached us, saying she'd be with us shortly. I had just begun to relax a little when Johnny B, in his usual obnoxious fashion, loudly remarked, "Hey, she's got big breasts!" I was mortified and snapped at him to show some respect. But he only laughed, reminding me that his uncle was my boss, and he had the upper hand in our relationship.

I tried to distance myself from Johnny B as much as the confined space allowed in the small booth. He continued his crude comments, trying to flirt with the waitress, while I inwardly cursed my fate for having to put up with him.

When the waitress returned to take our orders, I tried to be polite and ordered a simple meal – egg whites, turkey bacon, and orange juice. Johnny B, however, didn't hold back and ordered a gluttonous feast of eggs, bacon, sausage, hash browns, toast, and coffee. The waitress looked at me with concern, and I felt the need to explain that we weren't together, hoping to distance myself further from his outrageous behavior.

Before the food arrived, I looked outside the window and noticed the parking lot, which had been nearly empty when we arrived, was now teeming with cars. Most of the drivers were women, and strangely, many of them appeared to be pregnant. I wondered if there was some event happening nearby, but the sight made me feel uneasy, and my mind began to wander.

I thought about Janice, my ex-girlfriend, who couldn't have children, and how it had devastated her. She was a good woman who deserved happiness, but life had dealt her a cruel hand. My thoughts drifted to the challenges we faced together, the pain she endured, and how, in the end, it all became too much for her. My heart ached, and I couldn't shake off the memories of her struggles and the tragic end she met.

As I tried to push those painful thoughts aside, I noticed Johnny B's attention had been drawn to the same pregnant women outside. He commented snidely, "I thought women couldn't get pregnant anymore," and then mentioned his unsuccessful attempts to have children with his wife, Mary.

The atmosphere inside the diner seemed to shift subtly as the women's excitement grew. They seemed to be waiting for something, and the anticipation in the air was palpable. I felt a mix of curiosity and discomfort, wondering what was going on, but before I could ask anyone, the food arrived, momentarily distracting me.

I struggled to eat, my appetite waning due to the unsettling situation and the constant presence of Johnny B. But I managed to finish my meal, hoping to make a quick exit from this bizarre place. Just as we were about to leave, a commotion erupted in the diner.

The women's voices grew louder as they chanted, "Maddie! Maddie! Maddie!" Their excitement seemed to be reaching a peak, and I couldn't understand what was going on. Then, I noticed a stunning woman step out of a large white limo that had just pulled up in front of the diner. She had an air of elegance and confidence that commanded attention.

She was Maddie, and she held a large silver tray covered with a lid. Her presence seemed to electrify the atmosphere, and all eyes were on her. I wondered who this mysterious woman was and what she had to do with the pregnant women and their fervor.

Johnny B, ever the opportunist, commented that he would get her number. But I saw something in Maddie's gaze as she looked back at him. It was as if she could see right through him, sizing him up like a predator eyeing its prey. My instincts told me that Johnny B was in way over his head, but he was too blinded by his own arrogance to

notice.

As Maddie's four men in black suits guided her into the diner, the pregnant women stepped aside, creating a path for her to walk through. It was as if she held a certain power over them, and they willingly let her pass. My curiosity grew as I observed the scene, wondering what made Maddie so special and why these women seemed so enthralled by her.

Maddie approached the counter where a pregnant woman was sitting, enjoying her strawberry milkshake. She greeted her warmly and even patted the woman's tummy gently. Then, with an air of grandeur, she unveiled the silver tray, causing a loud bang as the lid hit the floor.

To my surprise, the tray was filled with small packages wrapped in plastic. The pregnant women eagerly handed over wads of cash to Maddie in exchange for these mysterious packages. They clutched them with excitement, and it seemed as though they were getting something of immense value.

I tried to make sense of what was happening, but it felt like I was witnessing a scene from a surreal dream. I looked around at the women, their stomachs swelling with pregnancy, and I couldn't shake off the feeling that something extraordinary, and possibly sinister, was taking place.

Johnny B, not one to miss out on an opportunity, asked how much Maddie was charging for the packages. But the response he received surprised him. "Not for you," one of the women said with a mouthful of sandwich. "Only for women."

Johnny B's curiosity was piqued, and he began eyeing the silver tray like a hungry wolf eyeing a freshly caught prey. It was evident he wanted one of those packages, whatever they contained. He didn't seem to grasp the significance of the situation or the fact that these packages were meant exclusively for pregnant women.

Before I could warn him to back off, he lunged for the last sandwich on the tray. But his action didn't go unnoticed. Maddie's four men in black suits sprang into action, apprehending Johnny B in a swift and professional manner. They slammed him against the counter, exerting their strength on him, making it clear that he was no match for them.

Maddie herself approached Johnny B, and the air around her seemed charged with an unsettling energy. She looked at him with an expression that was both cold and calculating, as if she were deciding his fate. It was clear that Johnny B had no idea what he was getting himself into, and that realization seemed to hit him like a ton of bricks.

"He'll do," Maddie said in a tone that sent shivers down my spine. "He'll do very well."

I watched in horror as Johnny B struggled under the weight of the four men, realizing that he had somehow gotten involved in something beyond his comprehension. But before I could react, the focus shifted away from Johnny B and landed on me.

Maddie's gaze locked onto me, and I felt a chill run down my spine. It was as if she could see right through me, reading my thoughts and emotions like an open book. I tried to avert my gaze, feeling a sense of vulnerability in her presence.

She approached me slowly, and I was unable to tear my eyes away from her. In that moment, I felt exposed, as if she knew everything about me, my past, my fears, my hopes. It was a deeply unsettling sensation, as if she had seen into the darkest corners of my soul.

Suddenly, she spoke, and her voice was both captivating and menacing. "You won't do," she said simply, and I had no idea what she meant. It felt like she was talking about something much deeper and more profound than I could comprehend.

Before I could respond or ask any questions, the situation escalated. Maddie's four men, now standing around Johnny B, seemed to make a decision. They nodded to each other, and without a word, they released him, letting him stumble backward.

"You're done," Maddie said calmly but firmly, and Johnny B's eyes widened in disbelief. "If you don't shut up, then we're both done."

The realization of the gravity of the situation seemed to sink in for Johnny B. His bravado crumbled, and he was left speechless. It was a rare moment to see him silenced, and I couldn't help but feel a glimmer of satisfaction at seeing him humbled.

But the unsettling events in the diner were far from over. The waitress slammed the bill down on our table, making it clear that she wanted us to pay up and leave. I reached for my wallet, ready to pay for our meal, but Johnny B seemed unfazed. "I'm taking my time," he growled, trying to assert some control over the situation.

However, the waitress didn't budge. She stood her ground, staring at Johnny B with a mix of annoyance and contempt. "Something you want?" she asked, and her tone was sharp and assertive.

Johnny B seemed taken aback, not used to someone challenging him like this. He tried to brush off her question with a cocky retort, but the waitress didn't back down. "Nothing from me," she said, glancing at me with a knowing look.

I didn't know what was happening, but I didn't want any part of it. I wanted to leave, to get away from this strange and unsettling place. As I stood up, Maddie suddenly appeared at my side, her presence felt even before I saw her.

"You need to leave," she said softly but firmly, guiding me toward the door. "You won't do."

I felt a mixture of fear and relief as I made my way to the exit. I couldn't fully comprehend what had just transpired, but I knew that I needed to distance myself from Maddie's Best and its eerie secrets.

As I stepped out of the diner, I saw Johnny B, still dazed and confused, being escorted out by the four men in black suits. I didn't know what fate awaited him, and I couldn't bring myself to care. All I knew was that I had to get as far away from this place as possible.

I decided to walk back to the main road, leaving Johnny B and his truck behind. I didn't want any reminders of this bizarre encounter, and I couldn't bear to think about what had just happened. As I walked, I couldn't shake off the feeling that I had stepped into some otherworldly realm, a place where reality and illusion blended together.

About a mile or so up the dirt road, I spotted a sign for "Rural" indicating the next turn. I parked the truck by the side of the road, leaving everything inside, including my wallet. I didn't want Johnny B's uncle coming after me, and I figured I could find my way back to civilization without any issues.

With a wad of cash that I had fortunately kept in my pocket, I set off in the opposite direction, away from Maddie's Best and its strange allure. I walked for what felt like hours, my mind reeling from the events at the diner and the unsettling sight of the pregnant women.

As I continued walking, my thoughts kept returning to Janice, my ex-girlfriend. She had been unable to have children, a fact that brought her immense sorrow. Despite her pain, she had been a strong and kind-hearted woman, and her tragic end haunted me. The memory of her struggle and ultimate despair weighed

heavily on my mind.

Lost in my thoughts, I was suddenly interrupted by the sound of a truck pulling up beside me. I looked up to see a lone driver, an older man with a kind smile. He offered me a lift and asked if I was alright. I thanked him and climbed into the truck, feeling grateful for the unexpected help.

The man noticed the troubled expression on my face and asked if something was wrong. I hesitated for a moment, unsure of how to explain the strange and unsettling encounter at Maddie's Best. But eventually, I decided to share some of the events with him, feeling the need to unburden myself.

As I spoke, the man listened attentively, nodding his head from time to time. When I finished, he simply said, "Sounds like you stumbled upon something you weren't meant to see." His words sent a shiver down my spine, confirming my suspicion that there was more to Maddie's Best than met the eye.

The man dropped me off at a nearby town, and I thanked him for his kindness. As I walked the streets of the town, my mind still reeling from the events of the day, I couldn't help but wonder about Maddie and the pregnant women. What was their connection? What were those mysterious packages they exchanged for cash? And most importantly, what did Maddie mean when she said, "You won't do"?

I knew I had to put the strange encounter behind me, but it lingered in my thoughts like a haunting melody. I couldn't shake off the feeling that I had glimpsed into a hidden world, one where secrets and mysteries intertwined.

In the days that followed, I tried to distance myself from the memory of Maddie's Best and Johnny B's bizarre fate. But the image of those pregnant women and the enigmatic Maddie stayed with me, a constant reminder of a world I had stumbled upon and couldn't fully understand.

I wondered if I had made the right choice in leaving Johnny B behind, knowing that whatever lay ahead for him couldn't be good. But I also knew that I couldn't have saved him, that he had brought this upon himself with his arrogance and disrespect.

And so, I decided to focus on moving forward, leaving behind the strange and unsettling events of that Sunday afternoon. But as the days turned into weeks, and weeks into months, I couldn't shake off the feeling that I was forever changed by that encounter.

Life returned to normal, but a part of me felt forever connected to that small diner in the middle of nowhere. It was a place where reality blurred with the unknown, and where the mysteries of life seemed to converge.

I often found myself wondering about Maddie and the pregnant women, and I couldn't help but wonder if there was a deeper purpose to their strange gatherings. But I knew that some secrets were best left buried, and that it was wiser not to delve too deeply into the unknown.

In the end, I chose to focus on the present, cherishing the memories of Janice and the time we spent together. She had been a bright light in my life, and her memory served as a reminder to appreciate the beauty and simplicity of life.

As the years passed, Maddie's Best became a distant memory, fading into the realm of the forgotten. Life moved on, and I chose to embrace the present, cherishing the memories of the past while looking forward to the future.

But every now and then, as I passed by a diner or saw a pregnant woman on the street, I couldn't help but wonder if there was more to the world than met the eye. Perhaps there were mysteries and secrets waiting to be discovered, lurking just beyond the surface of reality.

And as I continued on my journey through life, I knew that some mysteries were best left unsolved, and some secrets were meant to remain hidden in the shadows of the unknown.

HorrorMysterySci FiPsychological

About the Creator

David C. Connor

Reader insights

Be the first to share your insights about this piece.

How does it work?

Add your insights

Comments (1)

Sign in to comment
  • HandsomelouiiThePoet (Lonzo ward)2 years ago

    Awesome Storytelling 📝👍❤️💯

Find us on social media

Miscellaneous links

  • Explore
  • Contact
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use
  • Support

© 2026 Creatd, Inc. All Rights Reserved.