Fiction logo

I Rented a House That Doesn’t Exist on Any Map

A Mysterious Stay That Blurred the Lines Between Reality, Deception, and the Supernatural

By Farooq HashmiPublished 6 months ago 3 min read
Image By PicLumen

The Listing That Seemed Too Good to Be True

It all began with a vacation plan. I had been working nonstop for months and needed a break—not just from work, but from life itself. So, I opened my laptop and started browsing rental properties on a popular vacation website. That's when I saw it: “Cozy Stone Cottage by the Woods Total Privacy.” The photos were stunning. Ivy-covered walls, rustic wooden interiors, an old fireplace, and misty woods in the background. It was like something out of a fairytale, or a horror movie.

The price? Surprisingly cheap. Too cheap. But I didn’t question it. The reviews were glowing, all five stars. "Magical," one said. "So peaceful I lost track of time," another claimed. Within minutes, I’d booked it for the weekend. The host messaged me a brief and polite note: “Key will be under the mat. Enjoy your stay.”

Arrival: A House Out of Nowhere

I followed the GPS, driving two hours out of town, past farms and forests, until I reached a narrow dirt road that didn’t even have a name. Still, the pin on the map pointed straight ahead. I drove carefully until I saw it the cottage from the pictures. Identical, except... something felt off. The air was heavy. The silence, unnatural. But the place looked clean and ready.

True to the host’s message, the key was under the mat. Inside, it smelled faintly of lavender and aged wood. There was no Wi-Fi, no cellphone signal, but that only added to the charm. Or so I thought.

Strange Occurrences Begin

The first night was quiet, though I woke up at 2:17 AM to the sound of footsteps outside the window. I convinced myself it was a deer or some other animal. But the second night, I heard the same sound. Except this time, the footsteps circled the house... slowly... deliberately.

I tried to turn on the porch light, but it wouldn’t work. Neither did the flashlight app on my phone no signal, no service, no internet. I peered through the blinds, but saw nothing. Just thick mist clinging to the trees like cobwebs.

Then, I noticed something odd. A photo on the wall, which had shown a scenic meadow earlier, now displayed something else entirely: the very same house but it looked dilapidated, abandoned. I blinked. Was I imagining things?

A House That Doesn’t Exist

Image By FreePik

The morning of the third day, I decided to take a walk to clear my head. I followed the trail into the woods and found an old man sitting on a rock, whittling wood. He looked up and said, “You’re staying in that place?”

I nodded, and his face went pale. That house burned down over 30 years ago. Took a whole family with it. Ain’t no house there now. Just ashes and stories.

I laughed, thinking he was messing with me. But something about his eyes hollow, afraid made my stomach tighten.

I rushed back, and on impulse, opened Google Earth using offline mode. I zoomed in on my location. The satellite image showed nothing just an empty clearing. No house. No driveway. No structure. Nothing.

The Vanishing

I packed my bags immediately. But when I tried to leave, my car wouldn’t start. The battery was dead. Or drained. I started walking, heart racing. After 15 minutes, I looked back the house was gone.

I hadn’t taken a wrong turn. I’d been walking straight. But there was nothing. No cottage. No chimney. No scent of lavender. Just forest and fog.

Eventually, I made it to the main road and flagged down a passing truck. The driver asked if I was okay, and when I told him where I’d been, he turned silent. "You sure about that? There hasn’t been a house up there in decades.”

Unexplainable Evidence

I returned home, shaken but alive. I checked the rental website to report the listing, but it was gone. No trace of my reservation, no record of the host, no reviews. Even the confirmation email had vanished from my inbox.

I did, however, find one thing in my luggage that didn’t belong: a photo, printed on old, weathered paper. It was me standing in front of the cottage, smiling. But there was no one there to take it.

And in the background, barely visible in the shadows of the window behind me, was a face. Pale. Watching.

Final Thoughts: Between Reality and Something Else

I still don’t know what happened that weekend. Was it a glitch in technology, a ghost story come to life, or some bizarre psychological break? All I know is I stayed in a house that, according to every map, never existed. A place that welcomed me and then erased itself from reality.

So if you ever come across a rental listing that seems too perfect, too cheap, or too remote trust your gut. Because some doors, once opened, don’t lead to where you think they do.

HistoricalHorrorMysteryShort Story

About the Creator

Farooq Hashmi

Thanks for reading! Subscribe to my newsletters.

- Storyteller, Love/Romance, Dark, Surrealism, Psychological, Nature, Mythical, Whimsical

Reader insights

Be the first to share your insights about this piece.

How does it work?

Add your insights

Comments

There are no comments for this story

Be the first to respond and start the conversation.

Sign in to comment

    Find us on social media

    Miscellaneous links

    • Explore
    • Contact
    • Privacy Policy
    • Terms of Use
    • Support

    © 2026 Creatd, Inc. All Rights Reserved.