Fiction logo

I Fell in Love With My Best Friend — And I Never Told Them

And maybe that’s why I lost them — because I stayed silent while my heart screamed

By Muhammad SuhaibPublished 7 months ago 3 min read

We laughed like we had forever.

Talked like nothing could ever break us.

But while you told me about your crushes, your heartbreaks, your dreams…

I was busy falling in love with you — quietly, helplessly, and fully.

And I never told you.

Not because I didn’t want to.

But because I was afraid that telling you would mean losing you forever.

And maybe that’s why I lost them — because I stayed silent while my heart screamed.

We met like most people do—unexpectedly, effortlessly. It wasn’t love at first sight. It wasn’t even attraction. It was comfort. A kind of safety I didn’t know I needed until I felt it with you.

You were just a friend, at first. But then you became my person—my daily message, my “did you eat yet?” text, my “what do you think of this song?” voice note. You became my routine, my peace. And somewhere between the laughter and the long conversations, I fell for you.

Not in a movie-scene kind of way. There was no dramatic moment, no slow-motion realization. It was quiet. Slow. Real.

It happened on an ordinary Tuesday when you told me about your latest crush. You were so excited, so animated, eyes lighting up like the night sky—and I smiled. I laughed. I helped you pick the right words to text them. But inside, something cracked.

That’s when I knew.

I loved you.

And I never told you.

Maybe it was fear. Maybe it was pride. Maybe I just didn’t want to lose what we already had. So I stayed silent. While you shared your heart with others, I protected mine from you.

I watched you fall in and out of love. I was always there to pick up the pieces. Always there when they didn’t text back. Always there when you felt like you weren’t enough—when to me, you were everything.

Sometimes I’d wonder what it would be like to tell you. I’d rehearse it in my head:

"I think I love you."

"I don’t want to just be your friend anymore."

"You’re the one I wait for every day, even when we have nothing to say."

But the words never made it past my throat. I convinced myself that you didn’t feel the same, that I wasn’t worth the risk. That our friendship—our beautiful, honest, unfiltered friendship—would shatter the moment I let love enter the room.

So I stayed quiet.

And in that quiet, I loved you loudly—in the way I remembered every detail you told me; in the way I always answered your calls, no matter how late; in the way I knew which silence meant tired and which one meant broken.

But silence has a price.

One day, you met someone new. And this time, it felt different. You glowed around them in a way you never did before. You used to message me about everything—now your texts came slower, shorter, colder. I was still your friend, just not your favorite one anymore.

And it hurt. God, it hurt more than I expected.

Not because you were happy. But because I wasn’t part of your happiness anymore.

I remember the day you told me you were in love. Your eyes sparkled. You told me how safe they made you feel, how they understood you, how you didn’t have to explain yourself.

And all I could think was: “That used to be me.”

That night, I cried myself to sleep. Not because you were gone. But because you were never mine to begin with.

I still wonder—what if I had told you?

Would you have loved me back? Or would you have walked away? Would we have grown into something beautiful, or would I have lost you anyway?

I guess I’ll never know.

Now, we talk sometimes. Short messages, old memories. You still call me your best friend, but it doesn’t feel the same. There’s a space between us that wasn’t there before. Maybe it’s time. Maybe it’s distance. Or maybe… it’s all the things I never said.

I loved you.

Still do, in some soft corner of my chest.

But I’ve learned that not all love needs to be spoken.

Some love is just meant to be felt—in silence, in sacrifice, in moments that never made it to the surface.

So if you ever read this—and maybe you will—I hope you know:

You weren’t just my best friend.

You were my favorite person.

And I loved you.

Quietly.

Hopelessly.

Completely.

Love

About the Creator

Muhammad Suhaib

Writer of emotions, collector of moments, and believer in the power of words.

I write to feel, to heal, and maybe to help you do the same.

Stories, poems, and confessions — straight from the soul.

Reader insights

Be the first to share your insights about this piece.

How does it work?

Add your insights

Comments (1)

Sign in to comment
  • Marie381Uk 7 months ago

    Sad to read 💔🌻🌻🌻

Find us on social media

Miscellaneous links

  • Explore
  • Contact
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use
  • Support

© 2026 Creatd, Inc. All Rights Reserved.