Families logo

When Healthy Eating Becomes Unhealthy

Why Healthy Eating Isn’t Always Healthy: Finding the Balance

By vitaplatesPublished 3 years ago 7 min read

Have you gone overboard with ‘clean eating’? You know, obsessing over every morsel that passes your lips to ensure it’s organic, sugar-free, non-GMO and devoid of anything remotely fun or tasty. While eating nutritious whole foods is important, there comes a point when healthy eating borders on unhealthy. Constantly depriving yourself of certain food groups or nutrients can be just as damaging to your wellbeing as a diet high in processed junk. If you recognize yourself in any of the following signs, it might be time to loosen the reins and make peace with the occasional indulgence. Your body and mind will thank you for it.

GET A FREE GUIDE EBOOKS FOR MAKING HEALTHY RECIPES

When ‘Clean Eating’ Goes Too Far: The Rise of Orthorexia

Have you found yourself becoming increasingly restrictive with your diet and intolerant of certain food groups? Do you feel guilty when you eat something not on your “approved” list? If so, your healthy eating may have crossed the line into orthorexia.

Orthorexia is an unhealthy obsession with eating only “pure” or “healthy” foods. Unlike anorexia, the motivation is less about weight loss and more about perceived health benefits. But taken to an extreme, orthorexia can be just as dangerous.

• It often starts innocently enough. You cut out processed foods, sugar, and red meat. Then it’s all grains, dairy, or anything not organic. Before you know it, your list of “forbidden” foods grows longer and longer.

• Life revolves around meal prep and eating the “right” foods. You spend hours reading labels and researching nutrition. Eating out or at social gatherings becomes stressful or avoided altogether.

• You develop an irrational fear of the health effects of eating certain foods. Even though there’s no evidence, you believe GMOs, gluten, or dairy will harm you. This anxiety and loss of control over food choices is mentally damaging.

The bottom line is balance and moderation. No one food group or diet philosophy is inherently bad. Rigid rules around eating often do more harm than good. If your healthy eating has become unhealthy, it may be time to broaden your mind (and your diet!) once again. Talk to your doctor if you need help finding your way back to normal.

GET A FREE GUIDE EBOOKS FOR MAKING HEALTHY RECIPES

The Downside of Cutting Out Entire Food Groups

Trying to eat perfectly healthy all the time can actually backfire. Cutting out entire food groups or macros may seem like the “right” thing to do, but it often does more harm than good.

— Restricting calories or major nutrients like carbs or fat can slow your metabolism and cause nutrient deficiencies. Your body needs a variety of foods to function properly.

— Avoiding gluten, dairy or other foods without a medical reason can limit your diet unnecessarily and make it hard to eat balanced meals. Unless you have a diagnosed allergy or intolerance, most people can enjoy these foods in moderation.

— An obsessive focus on “clean eating” can lead to an unhealthy relationship with food and even disordered eating. It’s easy to become overly strict or anxious about what you put in your body.

— Life is meant to be enjoyed. Depriving yourself of occasional treats or the social experience of sharing a meal can promote feelings of guilt, isolation and resentment.

The healthiest approach is a balanced one — eat a variety of nutritious foods, watch portion sizes, and allow yourself indulgences in moderation. Focus on how you feel and how your body responds to different foods rather than rigid rules. Your mental and social well-being are just as important as physical health.

Finding the right balance means learning to listen to your body and being kind to yourself. Ultimately, the most nutritious diet is the one that you can stick to happily and sustainably. Moderation and compassion are key.

GET A FREE GUIDE EBOOKS FOR MAKING HEALTHY RECIPES

How Strict Dieting Can Lead to Nutritional Deficiencies

When you take healthy eating to an extreme by strictly limiting entire food groups or calories, it can actually become unhealthy and lead to nutritional deficiencies.

GET A FREE GUIDE EBOOKS FOR MAKING HEALTHY RECIPES

  • Lack of Energy
  • Strict dieting often cuts out major sources of fuel for your body and brain, like carbohydrates, fats, and protein. Limiting these macronutrients too severely can sap your energy, make you feel irritable or lightheaded, and reduce your ability to concentrate or exercise.

  • Muscle Loss
  • If your diet is very low in protein and calories, your body may break down muscle for energy. This can weaken your muscles and slow your metabolism, making it harder to lose or maintain weight. Include good sources of protein with each meal, such as fish, eggs, nuts, and legumes.

  • Nutrient Deficiencies
  • When you ban entire food groups, you’re likely missing out on key vitamins and minerals. Strict vegan or raw food diets may lack important nutrients like B12, iron, zinc, omega-3 fatty acids, and calcium. Paleo or low-carb diets that shun grains can mean missing out on fiber, B vitamins, and antioxidants. Include a variety of whole foods in your diet or consider supplements to address any deficiencies.

The healthiest approach is to make balanced and sustainable long-term changes. Focus on nutritious whole foods, watching portion sizes, and being more active. Strict diets are difficult to stick with long-term and can be counterproductive. The best plan is the one you can follow for life.

GET A FREE GUIDE EBOOKS FOR MAKING HEALTHY RECIPES

The Mental Health Impacts of an Unbalanced Approach to Healthy Eating

When “healthy eating” becomes an obsession, it can take a major toll on your mental health and overall well-being. Many people develop an unhealthy fixation on food and exercise that leads to anxiety, depression, and damaged relationships.

  • Anxiety and Distress
  • Constantly worrying about every little thing you eat or how many calories you’ve burned can fill your mind with anxious thoughts. This anxiety often manifests as guilt over perceived “unhealthy” choices or distress over a missed workout. Over time, these anxious thoughts can become intrusive and hard to silence.

  • Depression
  • An unbalanced approach to wellness that focuses solely on strict rules and restrictions frequently leads to feelings of deprivation, failure, and low self-esteem. You may find yourself isolating from social events where you can’t control the food or beating yourself up over a piece of cake. These thoughts and behaviors can contribute to the development of depression.

  • Damaged Relationships
  • When your eating and exercise habits become obsessive, your relationships often suffer. You may avoid social events, lash out at loved ones, or constantly talk about your diet and routine — all of which can damage your connections with friends and family over the long run.

The key is finding balance and moderation in your pursuit of health. While nutrition and exercise are important, make sure to also nurture your relationships, engage in self-care, pursue hobbies, and allow for flexibility and imperfection. Your mental health and quality of life will thank you. Focus on progress, not perfection.

Finding the Middle Ground: Developing a Balanced Approach to Nutrition

Finding the middle ground with nutrition means developing a balanced approach. Extreme or restrictive diets are hard to sustain and can be unhealthy. The key is moderation.

GET A FREE GUIDE EBOOKS FOR MAKING HEALTHY RECIPES

Avoid Labeling Foods as “Good” or “Bad”

When you label foods as “good” or “bad,” it creates an unhealthy relationship with food and can lead to feelings of guilt or failure. All foods can be part of a balanced diet. Rather than cutting out entire food groups, focus on eating more whole foods and watching your portion sizes.

Practice Moderation and Mindful Eating

The 80/20 rule applies here. Aim for nutritious choices 80% of the time, leaving 20% for splurges or treats. Pay attention to hunger cues, eat when you feel hungry and stop when you’re satisfied. Take time to enjoy and savor your food. Eating slowly leads to greater satisfaction and can help you avoid overeating.

Be Flexible in Your Approach

Rigid diets set you up for failure. Have a general plan to guide you but be willing to go with the flow. If you have pizza and beer one night, get back to your balanced habits the next day. One high calorie meal won’t ruin your efforts. Learn how different foods and amounts make you feel so you can find the right balance for you.

Finding balance with nutrition is a journey. Don’t strive for perfection. Instead, focus on progress, not perfection. Make small changes over time and be kind to yourself along the way. Your mental and physical health will thank you.

GET A FREE GUIDE EBOOKS FOR MAKING HEALTHY RECIPES

Conclusion

So don’t beat yourself up if you occasionally indulge or go off your diet. Healthy eating is a balancing act, not an absolute. While nutritious whole foods should make up the bulk of your diet, leaving room for life’s little pleasures is part of sustainable healthy living.Your mental health and happiness matter too. Rather than labeling foods as ‘good’ or ‘bad’, focus on listening to your body and finding what fuels and satisfies you. Don’t get so caught up in the details that you lose sight of the big picture. Healthy eating is a journey, not a destination. Stay flexible in your approach and be kind to yourself along the way. Your body and mind will thank you for it.

GET A FREE GUIDE EBOOKS FOR MAKING HEALTHY RECIPES

advice

About the Creator

Reader insights

Be the first to share your insights about this piece.

How does it work?

Add your insights

Comments

There are no comments for this story

Be the first to respond and start the conversation.

Sign in to comment

    Find us on social media

    Miscellaneous links

    • Explore
    • Contact
    • Privacy Policy
    • Terms of Use
    • Support

    © 2026 Creatd, Inc. All Rights Reserved.