Families logo

# **"Catfished by My Own Lie :The Day I Met My Online Alter Ego"**

*I created the perfect fake persona—until he showed up at my door.*

By Shehzad AhmadPublished 7 months ago 3 min read

A DM That Changed Everything**

The notification popped up on my screen at 2:37 AM.

**"Hey, I think we’re in the same city. Let’s meet."**

My stomach dropped. This wasn’t supposed to happen.

Three months ago, I’d created *Elena*—a cooler, bolder, infinitely more interesting version of myself. She had my face (just Photoshopped), my humor (but sharper), and a life I’d never live: world traveler, art collector, effortlessly charismatic. I’d only meant to see what it felt like to be *her* for a while.

But then I met *Daniel*.

And now he wanted to meet *Elena* in real life.

### **The Lie Spirals**

Daniel was everything I’d ever wanted—witty, kind, obsessed with obscure indie films. We messaged for hours, trading jokes and secrets. He thought *Elena* was real.

I should’ve ended it. But then he sent a voice note. His laugh was warm, his voice like honey. I was hooked.

**"So, coffee this weekend?"** he typed.

I panicked.

*"Super busy with work! Maybe next month?"*

He agreed. But a week later: **"Surprise—I’m outside your café. Saw your Instagram story."**

*Shit.*

I’d posted a fake check-in at *The Rusty Bean*. Now he was there, waiting for a woman who didn’t exist.

### **The Desperate Cover-Up**

I raced to the café, hiding behind sunglasses. And there he was—tall, tousled hair, scanning the room. My heart pounded.

I could’ve walked away.

Instead, I sat at the next table.

**"Daniel?"** I said, feigning surprise. **"Oh my god, I *thought* that was you!"**

He blinked. **"Uh… do I know you?"**

*Play it cool.* **"We met at Jake’s party last year? I’m Mia."**

His smile was polite but confused. **"Sorry, I’m actually waiting for someone."**

**"Elena, right?"** I blurted.

His eyes narrowed. **"How did you—?"**

**"She’s my cousin! She texted me—got stuck at work. Asked me to tell you."**

The lie slithered out so smoothly I almost believed it myself.

### **The Dangerous Game**

Daniel sighed, disappointed. **"Guess I’ll just grab coffee alone."**

**"I’ll join you,"** I said. *What are you DOING, Mia?*

Over lattes, we talked. Really talked. He was even better in person—quick-witted, eyes crinkling when he laughed. And somehow, *I* was funnier, sharper, more *Elena* than Mia had ever been.

Then his phone buzzed.

**"Weird… Elena just messaged me,"** he said, frowning. **"She says she’s *here*."**

Ice shot through my veins.

I hadn’t texted him.

### **The Twist: Someone Else Is Playing Elena**

Daniel stood, scanning the café. **"She says she’s wearing a red scarf."**

My breath caught. Across the room, a woman in a red scarf lifted her hand—*waving at Daniel.*

Who the hell was she?

Daniel turned back to me, suspicion flashing. **"Mia… what’s going on?"**

I opened my mouth, but the woman was walking over. Smiling.

**"Daniel? I’m Elena."**

### **The Shocking Truth**

She looked *nothing* like my photoshopped pics. But she *did* look… familiar.

Then it hit me.

*The Instagram model I’d stolen pics from.*

Realization dawned on her face too. **"Wait. You’re the catfish who’s been using my photos."**

Daniel’s head whipped toward me. **"You *pretended* to be her?"**

The café noise faded to a roar in my ears.

I bolted.

### **The Aftermath**

Daniel’s texts blew up my phone:

**"Who ARE you?"**

**"Was ANY of it real?"**

Then, the worst one:

**"I liked *you*, Mia. Not Elena."**

I never replied. Deleted everything. But months later, I spotted them together—Daniel and the *real* Elena—laughing over coffee.

At *The Rusty Bean.*

### **The Lesson**

I’d wanted to be someone else so badly, I lost myself completely.

And the cruelest part?

The version of me that Daniel liked… was *me* all along.

social media

About the Creator

Reader insights

Be the first to share your insights about this piece.

How does it work?

Add your insights

Comments

There are no comments for this story

Be the first to respond and start the conversation.

Sign in to comment

    Find us on social media

    Miscellaneous links

    • Explore
    • Contact
    • Privacy Policy
    • Terms of Use
    • Support

    © 2026 Creatd, Inc. All Rights Reserved.