Top 10 Rare Coins That Could Be Sitting in Your Collection

Many people inherit or collect coins without realizing their potential value. Some of the rarest—and most valuable—coins have been found in everyday collections, forgotten drawers, and old jewelry boxes. Whether you’re a casual collector or simply wondering what to do with an inherited stash, it’s worth taking a closer look at your coins.

You might be surprised to learn that some coins could be worth thousands—if not more. Before you search for coin buyers near me or consider where to sell silver jewellery, check out this list of the top 10 rare coins that could be sitting in your collection.

1. 1909-S VDB Lincoln Cent

This coin is one of the most famous and sought-after pennies in U.S. history. Only about 484,000 were minted before the designer’s initials "V.D.B." were removed from the coin's reverse due to public criticism. If you come across a 1909 Lincoln cent with "S" (San Francisco mint) and “V.D.B.” on the back, you could be holding a small fortune.

Estimated Value: $700 – $5,000+

2. 1916-D Mercury Dime

Collectors highly value this dime due to its limited mintage—only around 264,000 were produced. It’s easily identified by the "D" mintmark on the reverse. Even worn versions can sell for hundreds.

Estimated Value: $1,000 – $15,000+

3. 1943 Copper Penny

During World War II, the U.S. Mint made pennies out of steel to save copper for the war effort. However, a small number of copper planchets were accidentally used in 1943, making these copper pennies extremely rare.

Estimated Value: $100,000+

4. 1955 Double Die Penny

This famous error coin shows a clear doubling of the date and lettering on the obverse (front) side. It’s one of the most recognized and collectible error coins in circulation.

Estimated Value: $1,500 – $10,000+

5. 1932-D and 1932-S Washington Quarters

As the first year of the Washington quarter series, both the Denver (D) and San Francisco (S) mint versions had low mintages, making them very collectible.

Estimated Value: $200 – $1,000+

6. 1878-CC Morgan Silver Dollar

Minted in Carson City, Nevada, this coin is part of the popular Morgan dollar series and highly desired due to its rarity and historical significance. Many collectors focus specifically on Carson City coins.

Estimated Value: $300 – $3,000+

7. 2004-D Wisconsin Quarter (Extra Leaf)

This state quarter features an error where an extra leaf appears on the corn husk—either a "low leaf" or "high leaf." These quarters have become hot commodities among modern error collectors.

Estimated Value: $100 – $500+

8. 1921 Peace Dollar

Struck in low numbers and for just one year, the 1921 Peace Dollar is a transitional coin between the Morgan and Peace series. Its high-relief design also makes it unique and valuable.

Estimated Value: $150 – $1,500+

9. Indian Head Cents (1877 Edition)

The Indian Head cent is widely collected, but the 1877 edition is especially rare. With fewer than 900,000 struck, it’s a key date that can significantly raise the value of a coin collection.

Estimated Value: $900 – $3,000+

10. Draped Bust Coins (1796–1807)

If you’ve inherited old U.S. coins, keep an eye out for Draped Bust dimes, quarters, or half dollars. These early American coins can fetch thousands, depending on condition and mint year.

Estimated Value: $1,000 – $20,000+

What To Do If You Find a Rare Coin

If you believe you have a valuable coin in your possession, take these steps:

1. Don’t Clean It

Cleaning a rare coin can actually decrease its value. Professionals prefer coins in their natural, unaltered state—even if they appear dirty or tarnished.

2. Get a Professional Appraisal

Before listing it for sale, have the coin professionally appraised by a reputable local dealer. If you're searching online for coin buyers near me, make sure to read reviews and choose a trusted name like Eagle Coins or similar shops in your area.

3. Know the Market

Rare coins fluctuate in value based on precious metal prices and collector demand. Keep an eye on the market or ask your local expert whether it’s the right time to sell.

Bonus Tip: Don’t Forget About Jewelry!

In addition to coins, some older jewelry—especially pieces made from silver or featuring foreign coin charms—can carry hidden value. If you’re cleaning out a jewelry box and thinking, “Maybe I should sell silver jewellery,” it’s worth checking each item for hallmarks, purity stamps, and any embedded coins.

Many local dealers who specialize in coins also buy silver jewelry, offering you a one-stop solution for evaluating both.

Final Thoughts

Rare coins can sometimes be found in the most unexpected places—tucked away in change jars, handed down from relatives, or hidden in old collections. Knowing what to look for can help you unlock value you never knew you had. Whether you’re looking to sell silver jewellery, assess your coin collection, or find coin buyers near me, your first step should be to get your items professionally reviewed.

Local coin shops such as Eagle Coins Gold and Silver Buying offer more than just great prices—they offer insight, transparency, and personal service that online platforms simply can’t match. So before you overlook that jar of old coins, take a second look. You might just be holding one of these top 10 treasures.