Education logo

Before We Were Strangers

A quick review of Before We Were Strangers summarizes what the book covers.

By Ermelita T. EngracioPublished about a year ago 2 min read
Before We Were Strangers
Photo by iwin on Unsplash

Introduction

The novel begins with Matt posting a Craigslist "Missed Connections" ad, recalling his first love, Grace, from their NYU days. This sets the stage for a story that intertwines the past and present, gradually revealing their shared history and the reasons behind their separation.

Chapter Summaries

Chapter 1: A Missed Connection

Matt, a successful photographer, spots Grace on a New York subway platform after 15 years. Unable to approach her in time, he writes a heartfelt Craigslist post, reminiscing about their youthful romance.

Click here to get Before We Were Strangers for free from Audible when you sign up for a free trial-Click here for access.

Chapter 2: College Days

The story flashes back to their time at NYU. Matt is an aspiring photographer, and Grace, a talented cellist, is his next-door neighbor. They form an immediate connection, bonding over their artistic passions.

Chapter 3: Building Their Friendship

Their friendship deepens through shared experiences, including late-night conversations and creative projects. Romantic tension grows, though both are hesitant to risk their close bond.

Chapter 4: Falling in Love

Matt and Grace eventually confess their feelings and their relationship blossoms. They spend an idyllic year together, filled with love and dreams of a shared future.

Click here to get Before We Were Strangers for free from Audible when you sign up for a free trial-Click here for access.

Chapter 5: Separation

After graduation, Matt accepts an internship with National Geographic, which requires him to leave for South America. Miscommunication and withheld letters create a rift between them, leading Grace to believe Matt has moved on.

Chapter 6: Life Apart

In the years apart, Grace marries someone else and has a child, while Matt pursues a successful photography career but feels unfulfilled. Both struggle with unresolved feelings for each other.

Chapter 7: The Craigslist Ad

Grace sees Matt's Craigslist post and responds. They meet, and the flood of emotions forces them to confront their unresolved past and the pain of their separation.

Click here to get Before We Were Strangers for free from Audible when you sign up for a free trial-Click here for access.

Chapter 8: Reconnection

As they spend time together, Matt and Grace rekindle their bond. However, Grace is hesitant due to the complexities of her current life, including her late husband's memory and her responsibilities as a mother.

Chapter 9: Revelations and Healing

Matt learns about the withheld letters and discovers Grace’s daughter, who turns out to be his. This revelation brings both joy and heartache as they navigate the challenges of blending their lives.

Chapter 10: A New Beginning

Despite their struggles, Matt and Grace realize their love is worth fighting for. The novel ends on a hopeful note, as they commit to building a future together as a family.

Click here to get Before We Were Strangers for free from Audible when you sign up for a free trial-Click here for access.

Conclusion

Before We Were Strangers is a heartfelt tale about lost love and second chances. Renée Carlino masterfully balances the emotional depth of the character's past with the promise of a brighter future. The story is a reminder that love, even when tested by time and distance, can endure and heal.

book reviews

About the Creator

Reader insights

Be the first to share your insights about this piece.

How does it work?

Add your insights

Comments

There are no comments for this story

Be the first to respond and start the conversation.

Sign in to comment

    Find us on social media

    Miscellaneous links

    • Explore
    • Contact
    • Privacy Policy
    • Terms of Use
    • Support

    © 2026 Creatd, Inc. All Rights Reserved.