I Cheated Once—and It Still Haunts Me

I’m going to tell you something I’ve never said out loud.

Years ago, I cheated on my partner. Just once. It happened so quickly, so stupidly, that for a long time I convinced myself it didn’t matter. But it does. It always did.

We’d been together four years at the time. I was 27, old enough to know better, but not wise enough to see how fragile trust really is. We were in that phase where you start to take each other for granted. Busy jobs. Endless bills. Arguments over nothing—laundry on the floor, whose turn it was to do dishes.

But beneath it, there was love. A lot of it.

One night I went out with coworkers to celebrate a project launch. We went too hard. Shots, beers, karaoke. I felt light and free in a way I hadn’t in months. My friend Jon kept handing me drinks. He was funny, charming, always flirting. I told him to stop—laughed it off, pushed him away.

But when the bar closed, and the cold air hit us outside, I was dizzy. My head fuzzy, my heart weirdly hungry. I called a cab but he said, “Let’s just share one.” I didn’t protest.

In the cab, he kissed me. I kissed him back.

I wish I could say that was all.

We ended up back at his place. It was frantic, messy, regrettable even as it was happening. The entire time, I was aware of the wrongness of it. That it wasn’t love, wasn’t even lust—just escape. Just a dumb, selfish moment.

The next morning, I woke up before him and left.

I remember shaking on the subway home. I kept checking my phone for messages from my partner, terrified there’d be something like: “Where were you?” But there was only a simple, loving text: Hope you had fun last night. Can’t wait to see you.

That gutted me.

I took a shower so long the water ran cold, like it could scrub off my guilt. It didn’t.

I didn’t confess.

People say you should always tell. But I didn’t. I thought: If I tell them, I’m doing it to ease my own guilt, not to help them. I told myself it would never happen again (it didn’t). That if I just worked harder, loved them better, it would even out.

I became the best partner I could be after that. Thoughtful. Attentive. Patient. I cooked dinners. Bought flowers. I asked about their day and actually listened.

But it was always there.

A stain.

I’d watch them sleeping and feel a physical ache in my chest. This was the person who would drop anything for me, who had seen me at my worst and still loved me. And I had betrayed them for no good reason.

Years passed.

We stayed together. Built a life. It wasn’t perfect (whose is?), but it was real, and warm, and for the most part, happy.

Except I carried it with me.

I flinched at every story about cheating. I’d feel sick when friends told me about getting cheated on. When my partner would say things like “I trust you more than anyone,” I’d smile and nod, but my stomach would twist.

They deserved better.

I considered confessing hundreds of times. Wrote letters I never sent. Practiced speeches in the mirror. But every time I imagined their face—shocked, hurt, disbelieving—I stopped. I couldn’t do it.

Was that cowardice? Definitely.

Was I protecting them? Maybe.

Or maybe I was just protecting myself.

A year ago, they proposed to me.

I said yes.

We’re engaged now. Planning a wedding. Picking venues, colors, menus. Smiling for pictures. Everyone says we’re perfect together.

And in many ways, we are.

But I know the truth.

Some nights I lie awake and think about Jon’s apartment, the flicker of streetlights on the wall, the horrible dullness of his words the next morning: “You okay?”

I wasn’t okay.

I’m not sure I ever will be.

If you’re reading this hoping for a redemption arc, I don’t have one.

I didn’t confess. I didn’t “come clean.” I didn’t lose everything and rebuild.

I just kept going.

I try to love my partner so fiercely it might count for something. I volunteer for their family, support their dreams, hold them when they cry. I am the person they believe me to be in every way but one.

And it eats at me.

I don’t know what I’d want from them if the roles were reversed.

Forgiveness? Probably.

But I don’t know if I’d be able to give it.

This is my truth.

I cheated once.

And it still haunts me.

THE END

✅ Community Suggestion:

Humans (best choice) or Families

✅

infidelity, confession, relationships, guilt, truth, love, regret, personal essay, emotional

✨ If you enjoyed this story, please ❤️ it and hit Subscribe to follow my journey. I share honest, personal essays every week. Your support means the world!