Top 10 Worst Premier League Signings of 2025-26

The 2025–26 Premier League season has been full of surprises. Some transfers have been brilliant, while others have failed to meet expectations. Unfortunately, not every player who joined a Premier League club has adapted well. Some high-profile signings have struggled with injuries, form, or the pace of English football. In this article, we rank the worst Premier League signings of 2025, highlighting players whose performances have been disappointing so far.

List of 10 Worst Premier League Signings of 2025–26

10. Jadon Sancho - Aston Villa

Jadon Sancho joined Aston Villa on loan from Manchester United in what many believe was a rushed decision. The club expected him to boost their attacking options, but so far, Sancho has been largely ineffective. He has not started a single Premier League game and has made only five substitute appearances. Paying 80% of his Manchester United wages, Aston Villa fans are left questioning if this signing was truly necessary. His slow start and lack of impact make him one of the worst Premier League signings of 2025.

9. Harvey Elliott - Aston Villa

Harvey Elliott moved to Aston Villa on loan from Liverpool hoping for more playing time. Villa hoped he would become a key player in midfield, but Elliott has struggled to impress. With only three appearances and no goals or assists, he has failed to justify his loan move. Fans are disappointed, and his lack of influence makes him one of the worst Premier League signings of 2025. Elliott still has potential, but so far, he has not adapted well to Villa's style.

8. Mads Hermansen - West Ham United

West Ham spent £20 million to sign goalkeeper Mads Hermansen from Leicester City, expecting him to replace Lukasz Fabianski. Hermansen began the season as the first-choice goalkeeper but conceded 11 goals in just four games, including errors against Chelsea. He was quickly replaced by Alphonse Areola. The defensive struggles under Hermansen's watch make him one of the worst Premier League signings of 2025. His poor start shows the club may have rushed this transfer.

7. Jamie Gittens - Chelsea

Chelsea signed Jamie Gittens from Borussia Dortmund for a deal potentially worth £52 million. Brought in as a left-winger, Gittens looked promising but has struggled in his first ten games. He has managed only one assist and no goals. The pressure of a high transfer fee and Premier League intensity has shown that he is not ready yet, making him one of the worst Premier League signings of 2025. Chelsea fans expected more impact from this young player.

6. Benjamin Sesko - Manchester United

Benjamin Sesko arrived at Manchester United with high expectations after a £73.7 million transfer. Although he has scored two goals and provided one assist in 11 games, Sesko has often been left out of the starting XI. Fans expected more consistency and impact for such an expensive signing. His struggles with adaptation make him one of the worst Premier League signings of 2025. Manchester United supporters have been frustrated with the gap between his potential and actual performance.

5. Xavi Simons - Tottenham Hotspur

Tottenham spent £51.8 million to sign Xavi Simons, hoping he would be a central figure in the team. However, the Dutch midfielder has struggled with the physical demands of the Premier League. He often disappears in key matches, limiting his impact on the team's performance. Combined with a lack of support from Tottenham's forwards, Simons has been a disappointment and is counted among the worst Premier League signings of 2025. His signing has so far failed to meet expectations.

4. Milos Kerkez - Liverpool

Liverpool brought Milos Kerkez to strengthen the left-back position. However, in 11 games, he has often been outshone by Andrew Robertson and looks nervous under pressure. Critics have called him inexperienced, and despite a clean sheet against Arsenal, he has not been consistent. These struggles place him among the worst Premier League signings of 2025, as Liverpool had hoped for more immediate impact from this transfer.

3. Liam Delap - Chelsea

Chelsea signed Liam Delap for £30 million, but the striker has been affected by a long-term hamstring injury. He has appeared in only five games and has not scored or assisted. Despite showing potential in training, his lack of contribution so far makes him one of the worst Premier League signings of 2025. Chelsea fans are still hoping for a recovery, but his slow start has been disappointing.

2. Florian Wirtz - Liverpool

Florian Wirtz joined Liverpool for £116 million amid huge expectations. However, he has struggled to fit into Arne Slot's system and has not scored or assisted in 11 appearances. While Wirtz is clearly talented, the pressure of the Premier League and tactical demands have limited his contribution. His underwhelming performance makes him one of the worst Premier League signings of 2025, showing that even top talent can struggle to adapt quickly.

1. Alexander Isak - Liverpool

Alexander Isak became Liverpool's record signing, with high hopes for regular goal-scoring. Unfortunately, injuries and competition for positions have limited his impact. In five appearances, he has only provided one assist and no goals. Considering his price, Isak's contribution has been minimal, making him the clear leader among the worst Premier League signings of 2025. Liverpool fans are disappointed with this transfer so far.