BookClub logo

Willpower Doesn't Work Review

We rely on willpower to create change in our lives...but what if we're thinking about it all wrong? In Willpower Doesn't Work, Benjamin Hardy explains that willpower is nothing more than a dangerous fad that is bound to lead to failure. Instead of "white-knuckling" your way to change, you need to alter your surroundings to support your goals. This book shows you how.

By TAPHAPublished about a year ago 7 min read
Willpower Doesn't Work Review
Photo by Luca Bravo on Unsplash

Willpower Doesn’t Work: The book titled Hidden Keys to Success: How the Science of Self-Control Explains Why You Have Trust Issues, Get Sick, and Fail at Work by Benjamin Hardy questions one of the most powerful presumptions we have as a society: the fact that people can change through sheer will and determination. According to Hardy, who is an organizational psychologist, people underestimate how much foreign influence has on them. He has found that, instead of relying on the force of will, adjustment of place can induce the behaviours that bring about success and real change.

By way of this review, one gets to deliberate on various aspects such as the arguments raised and put forward by Hardy, the main highlights and the pointers as well as derived practical strategies for reconfiguration of habits and settings.

Click here to Willpower Doesn't Work for free with a 30-day free trial.

Overview and Central Argument

The core thesis of Willpower Doesn’t Work is straightforward but revolutionary: that is the idea if you find yourself now invoking the willpower factor then you are already in the doldrums. The ‘circuital’ approach of this particular article lays stress on the proposition, forwarded by Hardy, that our environment plays a decisive role in shaping our habits and decisions, and for this reason alone, it is necessary to be active in shaping an environment that would best fit in our plans. It also sits in contrast to the notion that one has to have willpower as the driving force to succeed in life, normally most self-improvement challenges relate to the poor designing of environments.

The Problem with Willpower

First, Hardy explains why desire control is not effective. Using evidence from the psychology domain, he argues that willpower is not only weak but also quickly depletes. The more we use it in the day for certain decisions the less of it is left for the rest of the other decisions. Such depletion causes decision tiredness, which is why it is easier to indulge oneself or make wrong decisions for the day.

He claims that contemporary society with its technology and tendency toward the endless distractions and the endless stream of demands and information thrust upon us increases the demand for willpower. Interestingly, instead of coming up with more ways of working even harder at it, Hardy says the solution is to modify the physical surroundings to remove any inducements to distraction.

Designing an intentional environment is a way of preparing to create individual plans and context-profiling to support specific enrollees.

Another advantage of Hardy’s approach is his focus on active zoning – that is on the intentional construction of the environment. Instead of teaching his clients how to fight temptation and use willpower , he offers ideas on how to create contexts that foster good habits and practices. This includes:

Removing Distractions: As per Hardy, readers should clean their head office and home, their actual and social media, and their house and home screen to free themselves from decision exhaustion.

Setting Up Triggers for Positive Habits: Pinning these specific cues and daily reminders nearby will help make it possible to practice these habits unconsciously.

Establishing Accountability: It is seen that Hardy always focuses on how people regulate their social contexts. Coating yourself with people who have similar objectives as you or those who can prod you can be even more encouraging than motivating oneself.

What makes Hardy’s advice practical is that it is not a commentary on what people should do, but rather how they could go about changing facets of their environment to suit their needs and goals.

Stress is a factor that defines the role of High-Stress and High-Growth experiences

The book is equally filled with discussions on what the author terms as forcing functions accounting for a huge proportion of the book. These are events that put a lot at risk or are situations that create new experiences and new ways of operating. For instance, registering for a marathon may make you stick to the train and push you in practice or moving to another city may challenge upon and make you change.

According to Hardy, the pressure in such environments is the key to growth, people are put in a situation that will ‘stretched’ to their limits. He insists on the need to place yourself in an environment occasionally where you are asked to rise to challenge since those moments transform the character and make one the best version of himself or herself.

Commitment and investment: the powerful tools

It was valuable to read another section of the book that discussed commitment as another form of culture. Hardy underlines the several key points of the best decisions and one of them is to go all the way. It can involve money as when you have to part with your, money to pay for a course or class conversely, it can be a public statement that makes you more responsible. The rationale behind it is that where there is a large interest at risk, there is more likely to be a large interest at stake.

This is where Hardy’s message resonates strongly: The concept that a lack of commitment results in strange consequences. Just as you cannot gamble and not take your bets seriously when you invest something, you are likely to be more committed to your efforts than you would be if you were just betting on the result.

The Emerging Synthetic Framework Identity and Values

Hardy also briefly discusses the aspect of identity and how it influences people’s actions. They are connected with the notion that behaviour always corresponds to the image which is formed in one’s mind, and depends on the environment. Consistent with the notion here is the fact that by consciously integrating an identity that is in tandem with our goals (e.g. perceiving the self as an athlete, a writer or an entrepreneur), and having the reinforcement of relevant symbols along with people around, it eases the process of behaving in a particular way.

The final part of this book provides helpful lessons on how identity and behaviour work together. Reflecting on Hardy’s guidelines on how to create a context that supports a particular identity is very useful and actionable for readers willing to change something in their lives.

Evaluating Personal Stories and Dynamic Writing

The writing style of Hardy is easy to ordain and much of it is drawn from the author’s personal experience as well as cases of people that he has been coaching or researching. He successfully explains the facts and phenomena that relate environment to behaviour by telling stories. From a man who has personally adopted children and taken them as his foster children or a man who had to switch jobs because last year’s psychologically coherent team was working in a single open space, the author engages the reader and enthuses him.

The use of real-life scenarios makes the given recommendation practical and easy to understand how minor changes indeed help to induce a major behavioural change. This message gains credibility knowing that Hardy himself has undergone a personal transformation validating the concept that environment design is a leverage for improved living.

Critiques and Limitations

Despite the general strength of the arguments presented in While Willpower Doesn’t Work, the book is not without its weaknesses. Some people may question that concerning trying to overcome temptations, Hardy exaggerates the I±ow of self-discipline and does not attach enough value to the part that possesses the measure of willpower. Although there is much evidence to support his concentration on the environment, there are cases when a simple determination can have a great impact on the final result.

Finally, there are general and purely practical remarks which may appeal to the readers who are ready to believe that they can easily solve such problems while in fact, some suggestions seem to presuppose a rather high level of privilege. For instance, it is not possible for everyone to change the working environment from top to bottom, or to spend huge sums of money on high-stress activities for growth. In some ways the solutions that Hardy proposes may seem more achievable but definitely for those with the freedom of more flexibility in their job description and/or the ability to influence more aspects of that job description.

Conclusion

Willpower Doesn’t Work is a well-written and readily absorbent book of recommendations for anyone who wants to transform a life. Where Scout argues that people’s willpower is enough to get them through life, Benjamin Hardy turns this notion on its head while offering readers practical tips on how they can make their environment suitable for success. With his concentration on preventive strategies, demanding progress conditions, as well as identity-dependent practises, this workbook is helpful for career and individual growth recommendations.

Finally, the guide’s most important feature is a set of recommendations to improve relationships with a narcissistic partner. The readers are left in no doubt about how to plan one’s life for success, though some of the prescriptions may be adjusted to meet the peculiarities of one’s life situation. Hardy’s message is clear: in fact, if you desire to leave your willpower zone and move to the accomplish zone it is about time you upgrade the environment.

Click here to Willpower Doesn't Work for free with a 30-day free trial.

Book of the DayBook of the MonthBook of the WeekBook of the YearReading ListRecommendationReviewReading Challenge

About the Creator

TAPHA

Hi! Whether you're looking for insightful answers or a fresh perspective on a topic,I'm here to provide engaging, accurate,and thought-provoking content tailored just for you. Stick around, and let's explore the world of knowledge together!

Reader insights

Be the first to share your insights about this piece.

How does it work?

Add your insights

Comments

There are no comments for this story

Be the first to respond and start the conversation.

Sign in to comment

    Find us on social media

    Miscellaneous links

    • Explore
    • Contact
    • Privacy Policy
    • Terms of Use
    • Support

    © 2026 Creatd, Inc. All Rights Reserved.