Review The Lost Colony

The Lost Colony by Irina Shapiro is a fascinating blend of historical fiction, mystery, and romance that transports readers to one of the greatest mysteries in American history: one of the most famous instances – the vanishing of the Roanoke Colony. Using two timelines, the novel connects the past to the present where contemporary characters work to solve the mystery of the missing settlers from the end of the sixteenth century.

Click here to read The Lost Colony for free with a 30-day free trial

Summary of the Plot

Only two major points of view are presented in this story. They are both present-day novels, the first is based around an archaeologist named Dr. Quinn Allenby who receives a call to check out recently excavated items in Roanoke Island. The other timeline takes us back to the late fifties and sixties of the 16th century and lets the reader join the Roanoke colony and see what those settlers had to go through with the help of the diary of Elinor Dare, a fictional character who is a descendant of the historical Virginia Dare, the first child of English parentage born in the New World.

Quinn's Journey: In the modern timeline, Quinn is a middle-aged woman, far from the perfect happy family life she was living in the past: she has just been through a recent very painful divorce When she is asked by a local news team of Roanoke Island to dig into a newly discovered grave. This grave contains information that could help explain whatever happened to the lost colony of Roanoke. The movie becomes more than just a thrilling historical discovery where, as she investigates more she’s discovered not only secrets of history but also secrets of herself, overcrowded relationships and suppressed feelings.

The Story of Elinor Dare: In the beginning, the real hardships of life in the New World are depicted as colonial settlers of Roanoke. They have to experience food diseases and conflicts with local Indians. Elinor Dare becomes an interesting character in the picture, which reveals all the suffering and struggles of Roanoke women in a new world. Her story gives what could have happened to the lost colony a mix of history, history-turned-fiction, and history-wishful thinking.

Themes Explored

History and Mystery: As with the majority of contemporary performing arts, the main theme of The Lost Colony is based on the historical enigma of Roanoke. Using diligent historical records, Shapiro can create a plausible narration of what may have happened to the colony, while keeping the narrative fairly real but for the part where she had to use her creativity to make a story out of little evidence. From the historical perspective, revolving around enigmas, the novel is a good cocktail of historical truth and fiction, as far as an interested reader is concerned.

Human Resilience: Thus, the timelines presented in the novel are focused on the main theme of the work – the invincibility of the spirit. The weakness of Elinor Dare and the Roanoke settlers is the depiction of the early pioneers forced to endure so much in their endeavour to make a new start. In the modern timeline, Quinn’s scar combines a blow, with human endurance, becoming a new person and leaving behind the pain of the past behind.

Click here to read The Lost Colony for free with a 30-day free trial

Connection Between Past and Present: Another one of the themes nailed down in the show is the theme of tradition and inheritance. Again Shapiro does an excellent job of making the connection between Elinor and Quinn while highlighting their stories achievements and personal sacrifices. The historical study also examines how current events are aware of previous events and policies of various individuals and the government.

Love and Loss, The element of love is present in the story as it is typical for many of Shapiro’s books. In two time frames, there are emotions of love and the loss of a loved one as parts of the story’s main protagonists. Marshall’s love is filled with happiness and despair in White’s case and pain and healing in Gyllenpalm’s case.

Writing Style and Structure

Irina Shapiro has always been famous for her descriptions and well-developed characters, and The Lost Colony has them too. What seems to be most impressive is how the author gives the reader impressions of the historical 16th-century Roanoke as well as present North Carolina. Even though Shapiro provides necessary historical information, she writes this novel in an entertaining manner that will not put off those who are no experts in history.

The interrelated timelines work well and bind two different plots without one overpowering the other. Shapiro once more brings suspense and intrigue, both in the storyline of Prague and the present-day scenario, well attributable to being `hooked on the past’. It also makes sure that the story stays full of feelings and relatable characters to make up for it.

Strengths of the Novel

1. Well-researched Historical Fiction: First of all, I would like to underscore that Shapiro did quite extensive research on the history of the Roanoke Colony. Such focus enhances the believability of the tale and history as a part of the story adds historical accuracy along with adding dramatic meaning.

2. Dual Timelines: It can be argued that the use of the two alternating timelines is one of the novel’s biggest assets. It lets the reader witness the story from two points of view, enriching the story, as well as the reader, and the character’s involvement.

3. Strong Female Protagonists: Finally, the two main female characters, Quinn, and Elinor are both complex and empowered women. These are rather inspiring and give the characters some kind of dimension to the story. Much of what the readers read about, they can relate to and would likely want the characters to succeed.

4. Engaging and Accessible Writing Style: Shapiro isn’t as blunt as Jonathan Safran Foer in 9/11 so the novel won’t be considered as heavy by most people who would be willing to read a novel about 9/11. Her writing is detailed and she can make her readers feel anxious more so when interpreting enigmas, especially the one that revolves around the missing colony.

Weaknesses of the Novel

1. Predictability in Modern Romance: Despite a rich emotional arc for the protagonist Quinn, the reader may find some aspects of her romantic plot too stereotypical, relying on clichés of the modern contemporary romantic genre. Some others may not find this as a problem given the nature of the readership but it’s relatively uncreative to some extent.

2. Slower Pacing in Certain Sections: The pace of the novel seems to be quite steady, however, convinced might be some of the moment’s lack of interest – mostly in the middle of the book. These sections pay more attention to character development, while this process though necessary, may seem, to the viewers, a letup in the action.

Conclusion

The Lost Colony by Irina Shapiro is an engaging historical mystery that should be enjoyed by readers of historical fiction, dual timeline novels and women’s stories of triumph. It is the first historical novel with a well-developed historical base and a suspenseful and well-developed plot The novel would give some details of one of the greatest mysteries of history as well as tell the wonderful and touching story of love and the connection between two generations.

What one learns from the novel is not a direct history lesson, but a well-crafted story from the author, Shapiro. There are some foreseeable scenes and a few sluggish parts but The Lost Colony is quite engrossing. It should appeal to anyone interested in Shapiro’s earlier books and historical thrillers.

Click here to read The Lost Colony for free with a 30-day free trial