Rachel Reviews: The House of Promise by Indrajit Garai
Spain's love of bullfighting is explored in this tale of competition between family, money and tradition
A book about bullfighting is an ambitious undertaking, knowing how it is a tradition at the heart of Spain's culture. Passion, ceremony and performance are all wound up together in what is essentially organised animal cruelty and Garai, in this novel, attempts to tackle this rather conflicting set of issues through a vast array of characters who proffer, from their occupations and backgrounds, the vast plethora of views and circumstances that surround la corrida.
The story is really centred around three main characters. Firstly, Ignacio, a multi-talented man who we first meet as a flamenco dancer but who is also studying to be a vet whilst harbouring ambitions to be a matador. He loves Nuria who is his sister but not by blood or relation; Ignacio was brought up by Nuria's parents and so, they have grown side by side. However, as time passes, there is the danger of them growing apart, their views on bullfighting becoming more and more disparate, causing their relationship to fracture. Nuria becomes more involved in trying to change the culture, it becoming the passion she follows rather than love. And then, rather unusually, there is Victor, a bull as our third character.
Yes, a bull. And actually, I found the passages where we are inside Victor's head (or Mors as he's also known in the book) the most interesting and stimulating in the novel. Garai, by providing us with the perspective of the bull, offers an extra layer to the story, creating sympathy and awareness of a creature instead of a construct merely used in a fight for entertainment. Victor is intelligent and sensitive. Garai shows this through Victor's thought processes and his interactions with other animals and humans and this unusual approach works really well, over and above other aspects.
I liked this book and especially the debate that it prompts but at times, I found it confusing. It took a while for me to get all the characters clear in my head and there were parts where I had to reread paragraphs to be sure of their meaning. I also felt like there was a lot of telling - instead of being in the scenes, they were described more generally and lacked intensity despite the action that they presented and whilst I enjoyed the story and where it went, it was a trickier read than others by Garai.
All that said, it is still worth checking out.
Rachel Rating: 3 out of 5 stars
About the Creator
Keep reading
More stories from Rachel Deeming and writers in BookClub and other communities.
Rachel Reviews: The Outlands by Frank Torn
Having finished The Outlands, I am wondering how I can write this review to give you as full a sense of the book as I can. I think that I'm going to fail because all of the words that I want to use will make it seem unusual and I don't want it to sound unappealing because it's not.
By Rachel Deeming3 months ago in BookClub
My New Book is Finally Here
My poetry collection Beautiful and Brutal Things is done. It's actually done and finally published over 270 pages. Over a year of my life went into this book. More than a year, really. Long days at my computer, sometimes seven days a week because I couldn't stop even when I probably should have. Then two months of editing that felt harder than the writing itself. But it's finished, and I'm still standing, and the book is real.
By Tim Carmichael3 days ago in BookClub
The Other Woman in My Marriage Wasn’t a Stranger
When I first picked up "MY HUSBAND'S WIFE" book to read, I expected a dramatic story about betrayal and rivalry. The title suggests something bold and emotional, but what I found instead was a much more reflective and human narrative. This is not just a story about two women connected by one man. It is a story about how people understand themselves through love, memory, and comparison.
By Rosalina Jane2 days ago in BookClub
Comments (4)
Agree with the rest. Have always found bullfighting such a cruel sport. Kudos to Garai for pointing that out for us through a bull's perspective.
Kudo's to both Dharrsheena's and Lana's comments, the games in the Roman colosseum still haunt us in varied forms to this day. The lust for blood sport a stain upon us all. I'm heartened that the author weaves the animal's viewpoint into the story. I'm exhausted by the casual condescension toward our animal brothers and sisters. Another excellent review, Rachel!
Echoing Dharrsheena here: all entertainment with animals where they suffer should be banned. Great review, Rachel, but I’m also becoming weary of books with too many characters that you need to sort out in your head.
I think I would cry if I read this, because of Victor. If it were up to me, I would ban the use of animals in any form of entertainment. Loved your review!